It sounds impossible. You have a U.S. passport, or maybe you were born in a small town in Ohio, yet you find yourself in the back of a van or sitting in a windowless room at a processing center. For most people, the idea of citizens being detained by ICE feels like a plot point from a dystopian novel. But it happens. It’s a real, messy, and bureaucratic nightmare that surfaces more often than the government would like to admit.
Mistakes happen. Systemic glitches occur. Databases don’t talk to each other. When these things collide, Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) sometimes picks up the very people their agency is legally barred from touching.
How American Citizens End Up in ICE Custody
The law is pretty clear: ICE has no authority to detain U.S. citizens. Period. However, the path to a detention center usually starts with a "detainer" request. This is basically a polite—but firm—ask from ICE to a local jail, requesting that they hold someone for up to 48 hours after their scheduled release so ICE can come take a look.
Data from the Transactional Records Access Clearinghouse (TRAC) at Syracuse University shows that over the years, thousands of detainers have been placed on people who turned out to be U.S. citizens. It’s not always a case of "bad guys" doing "bad things." Often, it’s a typo. A name is misspelled in a database. A social security number is one digit off. Or, quite frequently, the government’s own records are just hopelessly out of date.
Take the case of Francisco Erwin Galicia. He was a 18-year-old born in Texas. He spent nearly a month in CBP and ICE custody in 2019 despite having a Texas birth certificate. Why? Because of a discrepancy in his travel documents and a suspicion by officers that his papers were fraudulent. He lost 26 pounds in three weeks. He wasn't allowed to shower. This isn't just a "clerical error" when it's your life on the line.
The Problem with "Probable Cause"
ICE agents operate under administrative warrants. They don't usually need a judge to sign off on a detainer. They just need "probable cause" to believe someone is deportable. But if the database they are checking says "Foreign Born" and hasn't been updated to show that the person naturalized ten years ago, that officer thinks they have their man.
The system relies on a patchwork of old records. Think about the tech your local DMV uses. Now imagine that tech deciding whether or not you get to go home to your kids tonight. It’s scary.
Why the System Fails So Regularly
The primary culprit is often the Interacting Operational Data Archive (IOTA) and other interconnected databases like ENFORCE. These systems are massive. They are also prone to the "garbage in, garbage out" rule of computing. If an officer 20 years ago fat-fingered a data entry, that error stays there.
- Naturalization delays: It takes time for a "Lawful Permanent Resident" status to update to "U.S. Citizen" across all federal platforms.
- Derivative citizenship: This is the most complex one. If you were born abroad but your parents became citizens while you were a minor, you might be a citizen and not even have the paperwork to prove it yet.
- Cognitive disabilities: In several documented cases, citizens with mental health issues were unable to effectively communicate their status to officers, leading to prolonged detention and even deportation.
The ACLU has filed numerous lawsuits over this. In one notable settlement, the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department had to change how they handled ICE detainers because so many citizens were being caught in the net. Basically, if you don't look "American" enough to an officer, and your paperwork has a glitch, you’re at risk.
👉 See also: Picture of Trump at Pope's Funeral: What Really Happened at the Vatican
The Human Cost of Getting It Wrong
Detention isn't a "waiting room." It's jail. Sometimes it’s worse than jail because the constitutional protections that apply to criminal defendants—like the right to a court-appointed lawyer—don't apply in immigration proceedings.
Imagine being Davino Watson. He was a U.S. citizen held in ICE detention for 1,273 days. That is over three years. He was nearly deported several times. He didn't have a lawyer because he couldn't afford one, and the government isn't required to give you one in these cases. By the time he was released, he had lost everything. When he sued for damages, a court eventually ruled that while the government messed up, he wasn't entitled to a cent because of the statute of limitations. Honestly, it's one of the most heartbreaking examples of the system's failure.
What Happens Inside?
Once you are in the system, it's a race against time. You have to prove you are who you say you are. But if your ID was taken during booking, and you aren't allowed to call your family, how do you get your birth certificate?
ICE facilities are often run by private contractors like GEO Group or CoreCivic. Their staff are trained to follow protocols, not to be investigative journalists. If the file says "detain," they detain.
Legal Protections and Your Rights
If you find yourself or a loved one in this situation, you need to know that the Fourth Amendment still applies. It protects against unreasonable searches and seizures. Being a citizen detained by ICE is, by definition, an unreasonable seizure.
- The Right to Remain Silent: You don't have to tell them where you were born. You don't have to talk about your immigration status.
- The Right to Counsel: While the government won't pay for it, you have the right to call an attorney. Do it immediately.
- Habeas Corpus: This is the "big gun." It’s a legal petition that demands the government bring a prisoner before a court to determine if their detention is lawful. It’s often the only way to get a judge to look at a citizen's case quickly.
Jacqueline Stevens, a professor at Northwestern University, has done extensive research on this. Her studies suggest that roughly 1% of people detained by ICE might actually be U.S. citizens. When you consider that ICE detains hundreds of thousands of people a year, 1% is a staggering number of Americans being deprived of their liberty.
Real-World Steps to Protect Yourself
It's weird to think an American needs to carry proof of citizenship, but if you have a complex immigration history or were naturalized, it's a good idea to have digital copies of your documents.
🔗 Read more: Protest in Front of White House Today: What Really Happened with the Iran Rally
Keep a "Go Bag" of Data
Keep a scan of your passport, naturalization certificate, or birth certificate on a secure cloud drive. Give access to a family member. If you are ever picked up, they need to be able to fax or email those documents to the deportation officer (DO) assigned to your case immediately.
Don't Sign Anything
This is the golden rule. ICE often presents forms like "Stipulated Request for Judicial Order of Removal." This is basically you agreeing to be deported. Once you sign that, it is incredibly hard to undo, even if you are a citizen. They might tell you that signing it will let you go home. It won't. It will put you on a plane.
Contact Your Representative
Congressional offices have "caseworkers." These people have a direct line to ICE legislative affairs. A call from a Senator’s office can often do more in four hours than a lawyer can do in four days.
The Reality of Reform
Is the government fixing this? Sorta. There have been memos issued under various administrations telling agents to be more careful. They are supposed to "high-level" review any case where someone claims to be a citizen. But the pressure to hit numbers and the reliance on flawed databases means the "citizen filter" is more like a sieve.
The complexity of U.S. citizenship laws—especially regarding people born abroad to U.S. citizen parents—is so high that even immigration lawyers struggle with it. Expecting a field agent with a few weeks of training to get it right every time is, frankly, unrealistic.
What to Do if This Happens to You
If you are a citizen and ICE detains you, the situation is an emergency. There is no other way to put it.
- State your citizenship clearly and repeatedly. Say, "I am a United States citizen."
- Request to see a supervisor. Do not just argue with the intake officer.
- Call a specialized immigration attorney. Even though you are a citizen, you are currently trapped in the immigration system, and you need someone who knows how to navigate it.
- Contact advocacy groups. Organizations like the ACLU, Northwest Immigrant Rights Project (NWIRP), or Americans for Immigrant Justice have experience with these specific "wrongful detention" cases.
- Document everything. Names of officers, times, dates, and what was said. This will be vital for any subsequent civil rights lawsuit.
The most important thing to remember is that you have the law on your side, even if the person holding the keys doesn't realize it yet. Stay calm, don't sign away your rights, and get a lawyer involved as fast as humanly possible.
Moving forward, the best defense is being prepared. Ensure your family knows where your citizenship documents are. If you’ve naturalized, keep your certificate in a safe place but have that digital backup ready. The system is huge and impersonal; you have to be your own loudest advocate to make sure it doesn't swallow you up by mistake.