New York City in December is basically a giant, glowing movie set. You’ve seen it a thousand times. The steam rising from the manholes, the oversized snowflakes hitting a yellow cab, and that specific shade of Rockefeller Center gold. It feels like home even if you’ve never stepped foot on the A-train.
But here is the thing: a lot of what you think you know about Christmas movies filmed in New York is a lie. Or, at the very least, a very clever bit of Hollywood sleight of hand.
I’m talking about the "New York" streets that are actually in Toronto. The "Upper West Side" apartments that are soundstages in Vancouver. Honestly, it’s kinda fascinating how much we’ve been tricked into believing that the Big Apple is the only place these stories happen, even when the cameras aren't actually there.
The Elf Illusion: 55 Central Park West and Beyond
Take Elf, for instance. Everyone remembers Buddy the Elf’s epic journey from the North Pole, through the Lincoln Tunnel, and straight into the arms of his very confused father.
You might think the whole movie was a Manhattan takeover. It wasn't.
While director Jon Favreau really did film Will Ferrell wandering through the actual Lincoln Tunnel (which, by the way, is terrifyingly dangerous and mostly illegal for pedestrians), the "Hobbs family apartment" isn't a single place. The exterior is real—it's 55 Central Park West. If that address sounds familiar, it should. It’s the same "Spook Central" building from Ghostbusters.
But the inside? Pure Vancouver.
💡 You might also like: Ashley My 600 Pound Life Now: What Really Happened to the Show’s Most Memorable Ashleys
The production team built a massive set in an old mental health facility in Canada because they needed high ceilings to make Will Ferrell look even more gargantuan than he already is. If they had filmed in a real UWS apartment, the crew wouldn't have had room to breathe, let alone fit a 6-foot-3-inch elf jumping on a couch.
What’s actually real in Elf:
- The Empire State Building: The lobby scenes where Buddy tries to find Walter Hobbs? Those are the real deal.
- Rockefeller Center: The date with Jovie was shot on location, though they had to deal with massive crowds.
- The Snowball Fight: This happened at the Pine Bank Arch in Central Park. It’s one of the few scenes where the "magic" of the park is actually the park itself.
Home Alone 2: The Most "New York" Movie Ever Made (Mostly)
If there is one film that defined the 90s version of Christmas movies filmed in New York, it is Home Alone 2: Lost in New York.
Kevin McCallister basically treated the city like a $30,000-a-night playground. And honestly? The production was surprisingly committed to the bit. They spent months in the city from late 1991 into 1992.
The Plaza Hotel scenes are legendary. Donald Trump (who owned the hotel at the time) famously bullied his way into a cameo just to let them film in the lobby. But here is a fun fact: the "Suite" Kevin stays in? That was a set. The actual rooms at The Plaza are nice, but they aren't "run-through-a-giant-gold-hallway" big.
There’s also the tragedy of Duncan’s Toy Chest.
I hate to be the one to tell you this, but Duncan’s Toy Chest doesn't exist. It never did. It was inspired by FAO Schwarz, but the exterior of the "store" in the movie is actually the Rookery Building in Chicago. They just slapped some New York signs on it and hoped nobody would notice.
📖 Related: Album Hopes and Fears: Why We Obsess Over Music That Doesn't Exist Yet
The "Must-Visit" Spots That Are Actually Real
- Radio City Music Hall: Kevin stands right outside the neon marquee. It looks exactly the same today.
- Wollman Rink: This is where Harry and Marv (the Sticky Bandits) are plotting while they skate. It’s in the southern part of Central Park and is arguably the most cinematic spot in the city during winter.
- Bethesda Terrace: The scene where Kevin escapes in the carriage? That’s the heart of the park. It’s a masterpiece of 19th-century architecture that actually looks better in person.
The Miracle on 34th Street Reality Check
We can't talk about Christmas movies filmed in New York without the OG. The 1947 Miracle on 34th Street is a love letter to Macy’s.
Most people assume the parade scenes were staged. They weren't.
Edmund Gwenn (the guy who played Kris Kringle) actually participated in the 1946 Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade. He was the real Santa for the crowds that day. The cameras were tucked away in the crowds and on balconies to catch "guerrilla-style" footage. That’s why the reactions from the kids look so genuine—they didn't know they were in a Hollywood movie. They just thought they were seeing Santa.
The 1994 remake, however, had a bit of a tiff with Macy’s. The department store refused to be part of the film, which is why it features the fictional "Cole's" instead. It’s just not the same.
The Weird Case of Eyes Wide Shut
Okay, hear me out. Eyes Wide Shut is technically a Christmas movie. There is a tree in almost every single scene. It’s a dark, psychological thriller, sure, but the holiday vibes are suffocating.
Here is the kicker: Stanley Kubrick never left England to film it.
👉 See also: The Name of This Band Is Talking Heads: Why This Live Album Still Beats the Studio Records
He was terrified of flying. So, he had his crew measure the exact width of Third Avenue. He had them fly in real New York newspaper vending machines and trash. He built a "Greenwich Village" on a backlot at Pinewood Studios in the UK.
If you watch it closely, the proportions are all wrong. The streets are too clean. The "Don’t Walk" signs look a bit off. It’s a surrealist's version of New York, but for years, people genuinely thought Tom Cruise was wandering around the West Village.
Why NYC Stays the Christmas King
So, why do we keep coming back to Christmas movies filmed in New York?
It’s about the scale. New York is one of the few places where you can be surrounded by 8 million people and still feel like you're in a private snow globe. There’s a density of "Christmas-ness" there that you just can't replicate on a backlot in Burbank.
Even Serendipity—which is basically a 90-minute ad for the restaurant Serendipity 3 and Bloomingdale's—captures a very specific, wealthy, romanticized version of the city that people crave. We want the frozen hot chocolate. We want the chance encounter at the ice rink.
Actionable Ways to Live the Movie
If you’re planning to visit the locations of these Christmas movies filmed in New York, don't just go to Times Square. It’s a trap. Do this instead:
- Hit the Queensboro Bridge: Walk the pedestrian path like Kevin did in his cab. The view of the skyline is better than anything you'll see from the ground.
- Go to 19 East 61st Street: This is the spot where the 1947 Kris Kringle told a shopkeeper their reindeer were in the wrong order. It’s now a boutique apartment building, but the limestone vibe is still there.
- Skip the Rockefeller Tree at Night: If you want that Home Alone 2 moment with the tree, go at 4:00 AM. Seriously. Otherwise, you’ll be shoulder-to-shoulder with tourists and the "magic" will evaporate in about five seconds.
- Visit 55 Central Park West: Stand on the corner of 66th Street. Look up. It’s the Hobbs house. It’s the Ghostbusters building. It’s quintessential New York.
New York doesn't need to fake it, even when the movies do. The real city is grittier, louder, and way more expensive than it looks on screen, but when the lights hit the snow on 5th Avenue, you realize the movies actually undersold it.
Next Steps for Your NYC Movie Tour:
- Map out your route starting at Macy’s Herald Square (the 34th Street entrance is the most iconic).
- Grab a coffee and head north toward The Plaza; it’s a long walk, but you’ll pass the Empire State Building and Rockefeller Center on the way.
- End your day at Wollman Rink just before sunset to catch the skyline lighting up as the skaters take the ice.