Christmas Cactus vs Thanksgiving Cactus: Why You Probably Have the Wrong One

You bought it for the holidays. It was covered in those neon-pink, tubular blooms, sitting right there on the grocery store shelf next to the poinsettias. The tag probably said "Christmas Cactus." But here is the thing: it almost certainly wasn’t.

Most people are actually growing a Thanksgiving cactus without even realizing it. Does it matter? Honestly, for the health of the plant, not really. They both want the same humid, jungle-style love. But if you’re a stickler for botanical accuracy—or if you’re wondering why your "Christmas" plant is blooming in early November—you’ve likely fallen for the Great Holiday Houseplant Switcheroo.

These plants aren't your typical desert-dwelling, spine-covered cacti. They are epiphytes. In the wild, specifically the coastal mountains of southeast Brazil, they grow on tree branches or rock crevices, soaking up dappled sunlight and drinking in the humidity of the rainforest. They are part of the Schlumbergera genus, and telling them apart requires looking at the "leaves," which are actually flattened stem segments called phylloclades.

The Secret is in the Teeth

If you want to know what you’re actually holding, look at the edges of those green segments. This is the "Aha!" moment for most indoor gardeners.

The Thanksgiving cactus (Schlumbergera truncata) has very distinct, pointed hooks or "teeth" along the margins of its segments. Some people call them crab claw cacti because those points look like tiny pincers. It’s aggressive-looking, but soft to the touch. On the flip side, the true Christmas cactus (Schlumbergera x buckleyi) has segments that are rounded, smooth, and more symmetrical. They look scalloped or teardrop-shaped. No points. No teeth.

Why does the store sell you the "wrong" one? It’s basically logistics. Schlumbergera truncata (Thanksgiving) is much easier to ship because its stems are more upright. It also blooms earlier, which fits the retail window perfectly. The true Christmas cactus has a more pendulous, weeping habit. Its stems hang low and heavy, making it a nightmare to pack into a cardboard box without snapping half the plant off. Because of this, the true buckleyi variety is rarely found in big-box stores anymore. It’s mostly passed down as a "pass-along" plant, shared via cuttings between grandmothers and neighbors.

Pollen and Petals: A Deeper Look

Wait. There’s more.

👉 See also: Sleeping With Your Neighbor: Why It Is More Complicated Than You Think

If the teeth aren't enough of a giveaway, check the flowers. On a Thanksgiving cactus, the anthers (the bits that hold the pollen) are yellow. If you look at a true Christmas cactus flower, the pollen is usually pink or purplish.

Then there is the shape of the bloom itself. Thanksgiving cactus flowers are zygomorphic. That's a fancy way of saying they are asymmetrical. If you look at them head-on, they look a bit like they’ve been squashed or pulled back by the wind. The Christmas cactus flower is much more regular and straight.

And then we have the "Easter Cactus" (Rhipsalidopsis gaertneri), just to make things complicated. This one doesn't even belong to the Schlumbergera genus anymore (botanists love changing names). Its flowers are star-shaped and usually pop up in the spring. Its segments are thick, rounded, and often have tiny little bristles at the ends.

How to Actually Get Them to Bloom

I hear this constantly: "My cactus grows like crazy, but it never flowers."

It’s frustrating. You do everything right, you water it, you give it a nice pot, and... nothing. Just green leaves for three years straight. These plants are "short-day" photoperiodic. They need a very specific trigger to set buds. Basically, they need to think the world is ending or at least that winter is coming.

To get a Christmas cactus or Thanksgiving cactus to bloom, you have to manipulate two things: light and temperature. Starting in September or October, the plant needs about 12 to 14 hours of total, uninterrupted darkness every single night. If you have it in your living room and you leave the TV on or a lamp glowing until midnight, you’re resetting its internal clock. It won't bud. Put it in a guest room that stays dark, or literally put a box over it at 6:00 PM.

✨ Don't miss: At Home French Manicure: Why Yours Looks Cheap and How to Fix It

Temperature is the other lever. They like it cool. If you can keep the plant in a room that stays between 50°F and 55°F (about 10°C to 13°C), it will often set buds even if the light isn't perfect. Professional growers often use this cold-stress method because it’s more reliable than trying to maintain pitch-black darkness in a greenhouse.

The Watering Paradox

Here is where most people kill their holiday cacti. They treat them like a cactus from a Road Runner cartoon. They think, "Oh, it's a cactus, I'll water it once a month and give it a handful of sand."

Wrong. So wrong.

Remember the Brazilian rainforest? These things love moisture. They hate sitting in a swamp, but they want to stay consistently damp. If the top inch of soil feels dry, water it. If you let the soil get bone-dry to the point where the segments start to shrivel and look like raisins, the plant is incredibly stressed. It might survive, but it’s going to drop every single one of its flower buds as a defense mechanism.

Pro tip: use a well-draining mix. Use something like 60% potting soil and 40% perlite or orchid bark. You want the water to run straight through the bottom of the pot. If your pot doesn't have a drainage hole, stop right now and go get one that does. Seriously. Standing water at the bottom of a pot is the fastest way to turn your $20 plant into a pile of mushy brown rot.

Common Myths and Realities

• Myth: They need huge pots. Honestly, they like being a bit root-bound. If you put a small cactus in a giant pot, the soil stays wet for too long because the roots can't drink it all up. This leads to root rot. Keep them snug.
• Myth: You should move them around to follow the sun. These plants are notorious for "bud drop." Once they set those tiny little flower nubs, they hate being moved. Changing the light angle or the temperature even slightly can cause the plant to jettison its buds in a huff. Pick a spot and leave it there until the blooming is over.
• Myth: They live for a few years. False. A well-cared-for Schlumbergera can live for 50 to 100 years. There are families that have "legacy" cacti passed down through three generations. They become massive, woody, trunk-like shrubs over time.

Soil, Humidity, and the "Hidden" Humidity Hack

Since these are jungle plants, the dry air inside a heated house in December is their worst enemy. If your skin feels itchy and dry, your cactus is probably struggling too.

🔗 Read more: Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen Menu: Why You’re Probably Ordering Wrong

You don't need a fancy humidifier. Just grab a tray, fill it with pebbles, and pour water in so the water level is just below the top of the stones. Sit your pot on top of the stones. The water evaporates right around the leaves, creating a little micro-climate of humidity without rotting the roots. It works. It’s cheap. Do it.

When it comes to feeding, don't overdo it. Use a balanced liquid fertilizer (like a 10-10-10) at half-strength once a month from the time the flowers fade in the spring until about late summer. Stop fertilizing in September. You want the plant to stop putting energy into new green growth and start focusing on flower production.

Why Your Cactus is Turning Purple

If you notice the segments of your Christmas cactus or Thanksgiving cactus are turning a reddish-purple hue, don't panic. It's not a disease. It's usually a sign of one of two things: stress or light.

Plants produce anthocyanins (that purple pigment) as a kind of sunscreen. If it's getting too much direct, harsh sunlight, it will "tan" purple. It can also happen if the plant is too cold or if it's lacking magnesium. If the plant looks healthy otherwise, the purple tint is actually quite beautiful and won't hurt anything. If the segments look limp and purple, check your roots; they might be struggling to take up nutrients.

Actionable Steps for a Longevity Plant

If you want your holiday cactus to survive the season and become a family heirloom, follow this specific rhythm:

1. Post-Bloom Rest: Once the last flower falls off (usually January or February), give the plant a "nap." Water it less and don't fertilize for about six weeks. It’s tired.
2. The Spring Growth Spurt: In March, start regular watering and light feeding. This is the best time to prune. If you want a bushier plant, twist off one or two segments from the ends. This forces the plant to branch out, meaning more stems and more flowers next year.
3. Summer Vacation: If you live in a temperate climate, put your cactus outside in the summer. Keep it in full shade—under a tree is perfect. The fresh air and natural humidity do wonders.
4. The Autumn Reset: Bring it back inside before the first frost. This is when you start the 12-hour darkness cycle to trigger those winter blooms.
5. Propagation: Never throw away the pieces you prune. Let the broken ends dry out for 48 hours (this is called "callousing"), then stick them straight into a small pot of damp soil. They root incredibly easily, and now you have free gifts for friends.

The difference between a Christmas cactus and a Thanksgiving cactus might seem like pedantic plant-nerd trivia, but understanding which one you have—and where it actually comes from—is the key to keeping it alive for the next several decades. Stop treating it like a desert dweller and start treating it like the tropical beauty it is. The reward is a massive explosion of color right when the rest of the world is turning grey and cold.

Keep the soil damp, the nights dark, and the pot small. You’ll have a blooming beast on your hands by next November. Or December. Depending on the teeth.