If you’ve spent any time in the rabbit hole of the 2018 Frederick, Colorado murders, you’ve likely seen the grainy footage. It’s early. The sun isn't up yet. We see Chris Watts backing his white work truck into the driveway, a move his neighbor Nate Trinastich famously called "not normal." But then, there’s that flash of movement. A "red car" or a small red silhouette appearing to move near the garage.
The internet went wild over it.
People claimed it was a getaway driver. Or Nichol Kessinger. Some even suggested it was a second vehicle used to transport bodies. Honestly, when a case is this horrific, the human brain desperately looks for a "reason" or a co-conspirator to make sense of the senseless. But the reality of the Chris Watts red car is a mix of surveillance artifacts, neighborly routines, and a whole lot of misinformation.
The Surveillance Footage Mystery
Let's look at the footage from Nate’s Vivint camera. It was the linchpin of the initial investigation. When police stood in Nate’s living room watching the playback, Chris was visibly shaking. He knew what that camera saw. Or rather, he knew what it almost saw.
The "red car" theory usually stems from a specific clip where a small, reddish light or shape appears to pull out from the area between the Watts home and the neighbor’s house (the "Betty" house).
What was it really?
Most investigators and dedicated "sleuths" who have stabilized the footage believe this wasn't a car at all. It was likely a light reflection. When Chris’s truck lights hit certain surfaces—like the neighbor's garage door or a reflective window—the sensor on the camera struggled with the low light. This creates "ghosting."
Basically, the camera sees a light, tries to adjust, and creates a trailing shape that looks like a moving vehicle.
There’s also the "Betty" factor. Betty, the neighbor on the other side, was known to leave for work early. Some analysts have pointed out that her car, while not bright red, could appear distorted in the infrared-to-color transition of a security camera at 5:00 AM.
The Nichol Kessinger Connection
You can't talk about the Chris Watts red car without mentioning his mistress, Nichol Kessinger. This is where the "red paint" rumors started.
During the discovery phase, it was noted that Kessinger had a history with a Toyota. Some theorists pointed to a "red car" seen in the neighborhood and tried to link it to her. There were even claims she ordered red touch-up paint around the time of the murders.
- Fact: The car NK drove was a dark gray/metallic Ford Mustang.
- Fact: Police tracked her phone pings. While a ping hit a tower in Frederick early that morning, there is no verified video of her car at the scene.
- Fact: Investigators cleared her of physical involvement in the actual homicides.
The "red car" theory often feels like a way to put her at the house when the evidence doesn't quite get her there. It's a tempting narrative, but it's built on pixels, not plates.
The Red Gas Can Confusion
Sometimes people search for the Chris Watts red car but they are actually remembering the red gas can.
In the surveillance video, you clearly see Chris walking back and forth. He’s loading the truck. At one point, he carries a bright red plastic gas can and places it in the bed of his truck. He later claimed he did this as a "prop" to make it look like he was heading straight to an oil site for a long day of work.
It’s a striking image. That splash of red against the white truck and the gray morning. It’s possible that in the collective memory of true crime fans, the "red object" Chris was carrying morphed into a "red car" seen in the distance.
Tire Tracks and the "Helper" Theory
There was a lot of talk about tire tracks found on the far side of the Watts property. People suggested a small car—perhaps the mysterious red one—parked on the grass to avoid Nate’s camera.
The Frederick Police Department and the CBI (Colorado Bureau of Investigation) looked into this. The ground was dry. The tracks weren't fresh enough to be definitive. More importantly, the timeline of Chris loading the truck was so tight that a second person or vehicle would have almost certainly been caught on one of the many cameras in that suburban cul-de-sac.
Saratoga Trail was a suburban maze. Everyone had a Ring doorbell or a Nest cam by 2018. If a red car had sped away from that house, we’d have more than a 2-pixel smudge to show for it.
Why the "Red Car" Myth Persists
Why do we keep talking about it?
👉 See also: Lake Murray Lightning Strike: What Really Happened at Dominion Beach
Because the "lonely monster" story is harder to swallow than a "conspiracy" story. If Chris had help—if there was a red car waiting to whisk away evidence—then it’s a planned hit. If he did it alone, in a fit of rage or a cold, calculated internal shift, it feels more terrifyingly random.
The Chris Watts red car has become a piece of true crime folklore. It’s like the "man on the grassy knoll" for the Frederick murders. People want there to be more to the story because the actual story—a man killing his pregnant wife and two daughters because he wanted a "fresh start"—is too bleak to accept.
What the Evidence Actually Shows
If you look at the 2,000+ pages of the Discovery documents released by the Weld County District Attorney’s Office, the vehicle focus is almost entirely on two cars:
- The White Work Truck: The Ford F-150 that Chris used to transport the bodies to the Cervi-319 site.
- Shanann’s Lexus: The white Lexus that was parked in the garage the whole time. This was a "Level" car she earned through her work with Thrive.
There is no mention of a red vehicle registered to the Watts family or any close associates that was in the area that morning.
Moving Beyond the Rumors
When researching this case, it’s easy to get lost in the "what ifs." But looking at the facts helps clarify the noise.
- Check the source: Most "red car" clips are from YouTube creators using digital zoom, which adds artifacts to the video.
- Trust the pings: GPS data from Chris’s truck showed exactly where he went. No second car followed him to the oil field.
- Focus on the physical: The FBI and CBI spent months on this. They didn't miss a whole car.
If you’re diving deep into the Watts case, focus on the psychological profile and the digital footprint. That’s where the real answers are. The "red car" is likely just a ghost in the machine—a trick of light and shadow on a morning that changed everything.
Instead of chasing phantom vehicles, look into the actual GPS logs of the work truck. They provide a minute-by-minute account of his movements that morning, leaving no room for a mysterious accomplice in a red car to have played a role in the disposal of the bodies.