You’re standing in the grocery aisle, staring at a wall of glass and plastic bottles. It’s overwhelming. You’ve got the $30 artisanal extra virgin olive oil sitting next to a massive jug of yellow vegetable oil, and somewhere in between, there’s avocado, coconut, and grapeseed oil all claiming to be the healthiest thing since sliced bread. Honestly, most of the advice we’ve been given over the last twenty years about the best oil to cook with is either outdated or just plain wrong. We were told to fear saturated fats, then told to fear seed oils, and now everyone is terrified of "smoke points" as if a little wisp of vapor is going to instantly turn your dinner into a carcinogen.
It’s complicated.
Finding the right fat for your pan isn't just about nutrition; it's about chemistry. When you heat an oil past its breaking point, the molecular structure literally falls apart. This creates polar compounds. These aren't just "bad vibes" for your food; they are actual byproducts that can cause inflammation and ruin the flavor of a perfectly good ribeye. But here is the kicker: the oil with the highest smoke point isn't always the most stable.
Why the smoke point is kinda a lie
We’ve been conditioned to look at the back of the bottle for a number—usually something like 400°F or 450°F. This is the smoke point. It's the temperature at which the oil stops shimmering and starts burning. For a long time, the logic was simple: high smoke point equals good for searing, low smoke point equals good for salad dressing.
That’s a bit too simple.
Research, including a pretty famous 2018 study published in ACTA Scientific Nutritional Health, challenged this. Researchers heated various oils to high temperatures for long periods and measured how many "polar compounds" (the nasty stuff) were produced. Interestingly, Extra Virgin Olive Oil (EVOO) performed better than many high-smoke-point refined oils like grapeseed or canola. Why? Because EVOO is packed with antioxidants. These antioxidants act like a shield, protecting the fatty acids from oxidizing even when the heat gets cranked up. So, while your olive oil might smoke a little sooner than a bottle of highly processed vegetable oil, it might actually be safer for your body in the long run.
The best oil to cook with for high-heat searing
If you are trying to get that crust on a steak or a piece of salmon, you need heat. Lots of it.
💡 You might also like: Why the Long Head of the Tricep is the Secret to Huge Arms
Avocado oil is the undisputed heavyweight champion here. It has a massive smoke point, often cited around 520°F. Unlike many other high-heat oils, it isn't chemically extracted with hexanes. It’s basically pressed from the flesh of the fruit. It’s high in monounsaturated fats—the same "good" fats found in olive oil—making it incredibly stable. You’ve probably noticed it’s gotten expensive lately. That’s because it’s hard to produce, but if you’re doing a stir-fry or a sear, it’s worth the price of admission.
Then there is Ghee.
Ghee is just clarified butter. By simmering butter and removing the milk solids and water, you’re left with pure fat. Those milk solids are what burn in regular butter (which is why butter smokes at a measly 350°F). Ghee, however, can handle upwards of 485°F. It gives you that nutty, rich, French-bistro flavor without the acrid taste of burnt dairy. It’s a staple in Indian cooking for a reason. It’s stable. It’s delicious.
A quick word on "Vegetable Oil"
What even is "vegetable oil"? Usually, it’s a polite way of saying soybean oil, or a mix of corn, sunflower, and canola. These are highly refined. They go through a process of bleaching and deodorizing to make them neutral. While they have high smoke points, they are often very high in Omega-6 fatty acids. While we need Omega-6s, the modern diet is usually drowning in them, which can lead to a systemic inflammatory response. If you’re trying to optimize for health, this probably isn't the best oil to cook with on a daily basis.
The Olive Oil Controversy: Can you actually fry with it?
There’s this persistent myth that if you cook with extra virgin olive oil, you’re basically poisoning yourself. That’s just not true. People in the Mediterranean have been frying in olive oil for centuries.
The nuance is in the quality.
📖 Related: Why the Dead Bug Exercise Ball Routine is the Best Core Workout You Aren't Doing Right
If you use a high-quality, fresh EVOO, it has a high concentration of polyphenols. These protect the oil from breaking down. However, if you buy a cheap, "light" olive oil that’s already been sitting on a bright grocery shelf for six months, it’s likely already partially oxidized.
- Light Sautéing: EVOO is perfect. The flavor stays intact, and the heat isn't high enough to cause issues.
- Roasting Vegetables: Again, EVOO is great. Most ovens are set to 400°F, but the surface of the food rarely reaches that temperature due to moisture evaporation.
- Deep Frying: You can, but it’s expensive and the flavor might be too intense.
Saturated fats are making a comeback
Animal fats like lard and tallow were the pariahs of the 90s. But from a purely chemical standpoint, they are rock stars in the kitchen. Saturated fats don't have the "double bonds" that unsaturated fats have. This means there is no place for oxygen to attach and break the molecule apart. That’s why bacon grease stays solid at room temperature.
Beef tallow, specifically, is becoming a favorite again in high-end kitchens. It makes the best French fries you will ever eat. Seriously. McDonald’s famously used a blend of tallow and oil for their fries until 1990, which is why older generations swear they tasted better back then. Tallow is stable, nutrient-dense, and surprisingly heart-healthy when sourced from grass-fed animals. It contains conjugated linoleic acid (CLA), which has been linked to fat loss in some studies.
What about Coconut Oil?
Coconut oil is a weird one. It’s about 90% saturated fat, which makes it incredibly shelf-stable. It won't go rancid for a long time. It’s great for baking or for certain Southeast Asian dishes where you want that specific tropical aroma.
But it has a relatively low smoke point (350°F for unrefined). If you’re using "refined" coconut oil, that goes up to about 400°F, but you lose some of the health benefits. Also, let’s be real—sometimes you don’t want your fried eggs to taste like a Piña Colada.
The Seed Oil Debate: Should you be worried?
You might have seen people on social media calling seed oils "industrial sludge." This refers to oils like cottonseed, rapeseed (canola), and safflower oil. The argument is that the high-heat, chemical-solvent extraction process makes them inflammatory before they even reach your kitchen.
👉 See also: Why Raw Milk Is Bad: What Enthusiasts Often Ignore About The Science
Scientists like Dr. Guyenet or researchers at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health often point out that clinical trials don't always support the "seed oils are toxic" narrative. They argue that replacing saturated fats with these polyunsaturated fats can actually lower LDL cholesterol.
So, who is right?
The truth probably lies in the middle. While seed oils might not be "poison," they are certainly less stable than fruit oils (olive, avocado) or animal fats. If you have the choice, reaching for the avocado oil is generally a safer bet for your cellular health than reaching for the generic "vegetable oil" blend.
Practical Steps for your Kitchen
Stop trying to find one single "best" oil. It doesn't exist. Instead, you need a small toolkit of fats based on what you’re actually doing.
- For your morning eggs and low-heat sautéing: Use butter or extra virgin olive oil. The flavor is the priority here, and the heat is low enough that stability isn't a huge concern.
- For roasting veggies at 425°F: Go with avocado oil or a high-quality olive oil. Spread them thin on the pan so they roast rather than steam.
- For searing meat: Use avocado oil, ghee, or tallow. You want that pan screaming hot, and these fats can take the punch.
- For salad dressings: Always extra virgin olive oil. Don't waste your expensive oil on a hot pan where the subtle flavor notes will just evaporate anyway.
- For baking: Butter or coconut oil usually provide the best texture and moisture.
Check your dates. Oil is a fresh product. If that bottle of walnut oil has been in the back of your pantry since the Obama administration, throw it away. It’s rancid. Rancid oil has a sharp, paint-thinner smell. If it smells off, it is off. Buying smaller bottles more frequently is almost always better than buying the gallon-sized tub at the warehouse club, unless you're running a commercial kitchen.
Keep your oils in a cool, dark place. Light and heat are the enemies of fat. If your olive oil is in a clear glass bottle sitting right next to your stove, you’re basically inviting it to go bad. Look for dark glass or tin containers.
At the end of the day, the best oil to cook with is the one that fits the temperature of your pan and the flavor of your dish. Don't overthink the "perfect" choice, but do favor minimally processed fats like avocado and olive oil over the highly refined stuff. Your gut—and your taste buds—will probably thank you.
Summary Checklist for Smart Cooking
- High Heat (Searing/Frying): Avocado oil, Ghee, Beef Tallow.
- Medium Heat (Roasting/Sautéing): Olive oil, Coconut oil, Butter.
- No Heat (Dressings/Finishing): Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Walnut oil, Flaxseed oil.
- Storage: Dark bottles, cool pantry, away from the oven.
- The Smell Test: If it smells like crayons or old plastic, toss it.