Honestly, if you’ve been watching Chipotle Mexican Grill Inc stock lately, it’s felt a bit like opening a burrito only to find they forgot the guac. Disappointing. Frustrating. Maybe a little messy. After a 2024 that saw a massive 50-for-1 stock split and the departure of star CEO Brian Niccol to Starbucks, the vibes around CMG have shifted from "unstoppable rocket ship" to "cautious recovery story."
But here’s the thing. While the stock got hammered in 2025—dropping nearly 40% at one point—the narrative for 2026 is starting to look a lot more like a comeback than a collapse.
People are panicked about younger diners pulling back. They're worried about portion-size scandals on TikTok. They're biting their nails over whether the new guy, Scott Boatwright, can actually fill Niccol’s shoes. It’s a lot of noise. But if you look at the actual numbers coming out of the Newport Beach headquarters, the engine under the hood is still humming, even if the road has been bumpy.
The Post-Split Reality of Chipotle Mexican Grill Inc Stock
The 50-for-1 split in June 2024 was supposed to make the stock "accessible." It did. Instead of needing $3,200 for a single share, you could suddenly jump in for about $65. But accessibility doesn't always equal upward momentum.
By early 2026, the stock has been hovering in the high $30s to low $40s range. It's a far cry from the post-split highs, and the P/E ratio, which once sat at a sky-high 70, has cooled off to a more digestible 35. Some analysts, like those at The Motley Fool, argue it should probably be in the 20s until the same-store sales stop shrinking.
Others see a "spicy revival."
Oppenheimer recently pointed out that the 2026 setup is actually pretty favorable because the comparisons to 2025 are so low. When you have a bad year, it’s a lot easier to look like a hero the next year. Management just reaffirmed their guidance for the rest of 2025, which signaled to the market that the bleeding has mostly stopped.
Why the 25-to-35 Crowd is Ghosting Their Burritos
We have to talk about the "lifestyle" problem.
Scott Boatwright, who was officially named permanent CEO in late 2024, has been very transparent about who is missing from the stores. It’s the 25-to-35-year-old cohort. These are the folks with household incomes under $100,000 who are feeling the squeeze of inflation, rent, and everything else. They represent about 40% of Chipotle’s business.
When they stop showing up twice a week and start cooking beans at home, Chipotle Mexican Grill Inc stock feels the heat.
Can Scott Boatwright Actually Lead?
There was a lot of drama when Brian Niccol left. He was the guy who saved Chipotle after the E. coli disasters of 2015. Losing him felt like losing the franchise quarterback. But Boatwright isn’t some random outsider. He’s been the Chief Operating Officer since 2017. He’s an "operator at heart," meaning he cares about how fast the line moves and whether the steak is seasoned right.
💡 You might also like: How to Create Job Ads That Attract Talent Without Sounding Like a Corporate Bot
He’s doubling down on a few key things:
- Chipotlanes: These drive-thrus are gold. About 80% of the 350+ new stores planned for 2026 will have them.
- Throughput: He wants the crew to be faster. If the line moves quicker, the revenue goes up. Simple math.
- International Expansion: Mexico, South Korea, and Singapore are all on the map for 2026.
It’s not as "sexy" as Niccol’s marketing-heavy approach, but it might be exactly what the company needs to stabilize. The board clearly thinks so; they skipped a long external search and handed him the keys because he knows where all the bodies are buried—or, in this case, where the efficiency leaks are.
The Portion Size "Scandal" and the Brand’s Health
You’ve seen the videos. Someone films a worker giving a "light" scoop of chicken, it goes viral, and suddenly everyone thinks Chipotle is "shrinkflating" them. The company actually had to spend money retraining staff at "outlier" locations to make sure bowls were being filled properly.
While it sounds like a PR headache, it hasn't actually broken the brand. Digital sales still make up nearly 37% of the business. People are still ordering; they’re just being more selective about when they do it.
What the Analysts are Whispering for 2026
If you look at the consensus, it’s a "Moderate Buy."
Wells Fargo is the cheerleader in the room, with a price target around $55, suggesting a massive upside. On the flip side, firms like Stephens & Co. are more cautious, looking at a low of $35 if consumer spending doesn't bounce back by the summer.
The big catalyst everyone is waiting for is the Q4 earnings report on February 3, 2026. If Boatwright guides for positive same-store sales growth for the back half of the year, the stock could catch fire. If he’s vague or cautious, we might stay in this "wait and see" purgatory for another six months.
Actionable Insights for the CMG Investor
Buying Chipotle Mexican Grill Inc stock right now isn't the "sure thing" it was in 2023, but it’s a classic value play in a high-growth wrapper. Here is how to actually think about it:
- Watch the $40 mark. This has become a bit of a psychological ceiling. If the stock can break and hold above $42 after the February earnings, the "revival" story gains teeth.
- Focus on the margins. Beef and chicken costs are still high, and new tariffs have added about 30 basis points of pressure. If Chipotle can keep their restaurant-level margins above 24% despite these costs, they are winning.
- The "CAVA" Factor. Keep an eye on competitors. When CAVA misses earnings, sometimes CMG gets dragged down with it just because they're in the same "fast-casual" bucket. Don't let the sector noise distract you from Chipotle's specific unit economics.
- Wait for Q2 2026. Most experts agree the "easing of consumer pressures" won't really start until the second quarter of this year. If you're looking for a quick flip, you're probably in the wrong stock. This is a 12-to-18-month recovery play.
The era of easy growth for Chipotle is over. Now, it’s about the grind. It’s about 370 new stores a year, better digital loyalty perks, and proving that a burrito is still the best value for a twenty-something with twenty bucks in their pocket.
If you believe the 25-to-35-year-olds are coming back once the economy settles, this might be the cheapest you’ll see the stock for a long time. If you think the "golden age" of fast-casual is dead, well, there are plenty of other tickers in the sea. But betting against the burrito has historically been a losing move.
To get a better sense of the timing, check the February 3rd earnings call transcript specifically for "throughput metrics" and "2026 margin guidance." Those two numbers will tell you more than any TikTok video ever could.