Chase Matthews: Why We’re Still Obsessed with the Soul of Zoey 101

If you grew up in the mid-2000s, you probably spent a good chunk of your weekends wondering why a guy with a "bushy afro" and a penchant for falling off bicycles couldn't just tell the girl of his dreams how he felt. I’m talking about Chase Matthews.

He was the heartbeat of Zoey 101. Honestly, without Chase, Pacific Coast Academy (PCA) would have just been a bunch of rich kids eating sushi and riding Jet-X scooters. He was the anchor. The "nice guy" who actually finished first—eventually. But looking back in 2026, there is so much more to the character and the actor who played him, Sean Flynn, than just a 15-year-old crush.

The Mystery of the Season 4 Disappearance

Let’s address the elephant in the room: where the heck was Chase in Season 4? It’s one of the biggest "what if" moments in Nickelodeon history. One minute he’s the male lead, and the next, he’s shipped off to a prep school in London, replaced by James Garrett (played by Austin Butler, who, yeah, went on to do okay for himself).

The onscreen reason was heartbreaking. Chase overheard a rumor that Zoey was moving to England and, in a fit of "noble" sacrifice, told her she should go. Then he moved there to be with her just as she moved back to PCA to be with him. Classic TV trope. But the real-world reason? Sean Flynn wanted to go to high school. He wanted to be a normal kid.

He’s admitted in recent years—specifically on the Ned's Declassified Podcast Survival Guide—that he kind of regrets that move. It’s a wild story. He left the biggest show on TV to go to regular school, only to get kicked out shortly after. You can’t make this stuff up.

✨ Don't miss: The Lil Wayne Tracklist for Tha Carter 3: What Most People Get Wrong

Why Chase Matthews Was the Original "Simp" (And We Loved Him for It)

Long before "simping" was a term on TikTok, Chase Matthews was the blueprint. He didn't just like Zoey Brooks; he was hopelessly, cosmically devoted to her.

The Time Capsule Incident

Remember the "Time Capsule" episode? It’s legendary. Zoey records a DVD (yes, a DVD, we’re old) saying what she thinks of everyone. She mentions Chase. He spends the whole episode acting like a frantic spy trying to dig it up because he needs to know if she loves him.

• The internal struggle: He finally gets the disc. He’s got the laptop ready.
• The moral high ground: He doesn't watch it. He puts it back.
• The payoff: Ten years later, fans finally got the "What Did Zoey Say?" short film where we find out she called him her soulmate.

It took a decade for that payoff. Talk about a slow burn.

Breaking Down the Sean Flynn Legacy

It’s impossible to talk about Chase without talking about the Flynn dynasty. Sean isn’t just some kid who got lucky at an open call. He’s the grandson of Errol Flynn, one of the biggest stars of Hollywood’s Golden Age.

🔗 Read more: Songs by Tyler Childers: What Most People Get Wrong

But Sean didn't play the "movie star" card. On set, he was known for being the guy who did his own stunts (mostly falling down) and having genuine chemistry with the cast. While many child stars burned out, Sean took a different path. He’s worked behind the scenes in production and, as of late, has been more involved with the "PCA Alumni" through the Zoey 102 movie on Paramount+.

The Zoey 102 Reality Check

When Zoey 102 dropped, it was a slap in the face for some fans. We found out that Chase and Zoey actually broke up pretty shortly after the series finale. Why? Because real life is messy.

In the movie, we see a 32-year-old Chase. He’s an elementary school teacher. He’s still sweet, still a little bit of a dork, but he’s carrying 15 years of "what could have been." The movie basically centers on them reuniting at Quinn and Logan's wedding.

What most people get wrong about their reunion:
People think it was just a "happily ever after" moment. It wasn't. It was about two adults admitting they were terrible at communicating when they were 16. Chase was dating someone else (Danielle) and Zoey was basically a mess. But that kiss at the end? It felt earned. It wasn't the "Jewish afro" teenager anymore; it was two people who finally grew up.

💡 You might also like: Questions From Black Card Revoked: The Culture Test That Might Just Get You Roasted

Is Chase Matthews Still Relevant?

You might ask why we still care about a character from a show that ended nearly 20 years ago.

It’s because Chase represented a very specific kind of vulnerability. He wasn't the "cool guy" like Logan. He wasn't the comic relief like Michael. He was the guy who was okay with being the best friend until he wasn't. He showed a generation of boys that it was okay to be sensitive, to play guitar, and to be absolutely terrified of rejection.

What You Can Do Now

If you’re feeling nostalgic, don’t just rewatch the old episodes. Check out the recent interviews with Sean Flynn. He’s incredibly well-spoken about the pressures of being a child star and the reality of the industry.

• Watch Zoey 102 on Paramount+ if you haven't seen the adult versions of these characters.
• Look for the "What Did Zoey Say?" short on YouTube to see the bridge between the old show and the new movie.
• Follow the cast on social media. They actually have a group chat called "PCA Alumni" and occasionally share behind-the-scenes stories that never made it to the Nick airwaves.

The legacy of Chase Matthews isn't just about a crush. It’s about the fact that sometimes, the person who's been there since day one is the one worth waiting fifteen years for.

Basically, we're all still just students at PCA at heart.

Next Steps:
Go watch the "Time Capsule" episode again. Pay attention to the background details—you'll notice Chase is almost always looking at Zoey even when he isn't the focus of the scene. It makes the eventual series finale much more impactful.