If you’ve spent any time at a card show lately, you’ve probably heard the name Chase Burns whispered like he’s the next coming of Nolan Ryan. Honestly, the hype makes sense. When a kid is touching 101 MPH in high school and then goes on to break Paul Skenes' signing bonus record, people notice. But here’s the thing: the world of modern baseball cards is a confusing mess of "1st Bowmans," "Prospect Cards," and "True Rookies."
Most collectors are rushing out to buy anything with his face on it, but if you want to actually build a collection that holds value, you have to know which Chase Burns rookie card is the one worth your lunch money.
The Big Confusion: Is it a "1st" or a Rookie?
In the hobby, we have this weird distinction that drives newcomers crazy. Chase Burns made his MLB debut for the Cincinnati Reds on June 24, 2025. Because he arrived so fast—literally the first pitcher from the 2024 draft class to hit the big leagues—the card companies had to scramble to keep up.
Strictly speaking, his "True Rookie" cards (the ones with the official RC logo) didn't start appearing in base sets until late 2025 and 2026. However, if you talk to any serious investor, they’ll tell you the most important card is actually his 2024 Bowman Draft 1st Bowman.
Why? Because in baseball, the "1st Bowman" is the gold standard. It’s the card that marks his entry into the professional ranks. Even though it doesn't have the RC shield, it's the one that usually commands the highest prices.
The 2024 Bowman Draft Breakdown
This is where the real money is. When 2024 Bowman Draft hit the shelves, Chase Burns was the headliner. He was the #2 overall pick, a Wake Forest legend, and a guy with a "compete gene" that scouts drool over.
The Chrome Autograph (CPA-CB)
This is the "Holy Grail" for Burns collectors. If you’re looking at a 2024 Bowman Draft Chrome Prospect Autograph, you’re looking at his most significant card. I’ve seen PSA 10 Gem Mint copies of the base auto go for over $400, while rare parallels like the Gold Refractor (/50) have fetched upwards of $7,000 in recent auctions.
Actually, one of the 5/5 Red Refractors recently cleared $19,000. That’s a lot of pressure on a young arm.
Non-Auto Chrome (BDC-55)
Not everyone has five figures to drop on a piece of cardboard. The base Chrome card (number BDC-55) is the "working man's" version. It’s affordable, looks great with that classic refractor shine, and is relatively easy to find. You can usually snag a raw copy for the price of a decent pizza, though the "Sapphire" versions or the "Lunar Glow" parallels definitely carry a premium.
2025 and Beyond: The Official Rookie Year
Once 2025 rolled around and Burns started mowing down hitters in the majors, Topps and Panini shifted gears. We started seeing cards like the 2025 Bowman Chrome #BCP-122.
Interestingly, some of these 2025 releases still label him as a "Prospect," even though he was already starting games in Cincinnati. It creates this weird overlap. For example, the 2025 Bowman Chrome Reptilian Refractors have become a cult favorite because of the wild design, even if they aren't technically his "first" card.
Donruss and Prizm (The Panini Factor)
Look, I know some collectors hate the "unlicensed" look (no team logos), but Panini does some cool stuff. The 2025 Panini Prizm Blue Prizms and the Donruss "Rated Prospects" cards are great for people who prefer high-action photography over the traditional Bowman look. Just keep in mind that these typically don't hold value as well as Topps/Bowman products because of the lack of MLB branding.
What Really Happened With the Signing Bonus?
It's worth mentioning why the Chase Burns rookie card market is so aggressive. He signed with the Reds for $9.25 million. That broke the record previously held by Paul Skenes. When a team invests that kind of cash, they aren't planning on letting him sit in the minors for three years.
He moved from Single-A Dayton to Double-A Chattanooga in the blink of an eye. By the time he debuted in June 2025, the card market was already in a frenzy. He finished his 2025 rookie stint with 67 strikeouts in just about 43 innings. Those are "stuff" numbers. Even if his ERA was a bit high (around 4.57), the strikeout rate kept the card prices high.
How to Spot a "Fake" or Misleading Listing
You’ll see a lot of eBay listings using the term "RC" or "Rookie" for cards that aren't actually rookies.
- College Cards: Leaf and Onyx put out cards of Burns while he was still at Tennessee and Wake Forest. These are cool, and many are autographed, but they aren't considered "True Rookies" by the hobby.
- 1st Bowman vs. RC Logo: A 2024 card with a "1st" logo is usually more valuable than a 2026 card with an "RC" logo. It’s counter-intuitive, but that’s baseball for you.
- Condition is Everything: Because modern cards have such high production runs, a PSA 9 is often worth barely more than a raw card. If you’re buying for investment, it’s usually PSA 10 or bust.
Practical Next Steps for Collectors
If you're looking to jump in now, don't just buy the first thing you see on a social media livestream.
Basically, you should decide if you’re a "flipper" or a "holder." If you think Burns is the next superstar, look for a 2024 Bowman Draft Chrome Refractor (non-auto). It’s a safe entry point. If you have a larger budget, target the 1st Bowman Chrome Autograph in a PSA 10 slab.
Keep an eye on the 2026 season stats. Pitchers are notoriously volatile. One "pop" in the elbow and these cards lose 80% of their value overnight. But if he stays healthy and keeps that 100 MPH heater, that $400 card today could look like a steal in two years.
Check the "sold" listings on eBay rather than the "asking" prices to get a real sense of what people are actually paying. Markets move fast, and with a talent like Burns, the floor is high, but the ceiling is even higher.
💡 You might also like: Mexico vs US Gold Cup: Why This Rivalry Still Gets Everyone Fired Up
Actionable Insight: Focus your search on 2024 Bowman Draft #BDC-55 for the best balance of long-term prestige and entry-level pricing. Avoid the 2023 collegiate sets if your goal is strictly investment growth, as the hobby almost always prefers players in their professional uniforms.