You know that feeling when a product launches and suddenly it’s everywhere? That’s exactly what happened with the Charlotte Tilbury Mascara Exagger Eyes. People were losing their minds over the glass bottle before they even swiped it on their lashes. Honestly, I get it. The tube looks like something you’d find on a 1920s vanity—heavy, sleek, and weirdly satisfying to hold.
But here’s the thing. There was a massive amount of confusion when this dropped. Half the internet thought it was a tubing mascara. It’s not. Let’s just clear that up right now. If you’re looking for those little rubbery tubes that slide off with just warm water, this isn't that. It’s a volumizing formula through and through, but it’s trying to do something much more ambitious than your average black goop in a plastic tube.
Why the Glass Bottle Actually Matters
Most people think the glass is just for "the aesthetic." It’s basically the ultimate "shelfie" bait. But there’s a technical reason Charlotte went with glass. Plastic is porous. Over time, air seeps in and your mascara dries out, becoming a clumpy mess within six weeks. Glass doesn’t breathe. This keeps the formula—which they call "Lash Vinyl-Black Wrap Tech"—fresher for way longer.
It feels expensive because it is. You’re paying $29 for a mascara that won't turn into a desert after a month. Plus, it’s recyclable, which is a nice win for the planet while you’re making your eyes look like a Hollywood starlet’s.
The Brush: A Tale of Two Sides
The wand is a bit of a weirdo, but in a good way. It’s an Ultra-Curved Lash Styler Brush. If you look closely, the bristles aren't symmetrical. One side is soft for "loading" the product onto the lashes, and the other side is sharp and laser-cut to comb them out.
💡 You might also like: Different Kinds of Dreads: What Your Stylist Probably Won't Tell You
- The Inner Curve: This is for the roots. You press it in and pull up to get that lift.
- The Outer Curve: This is for the "wiggle." It separates the lashes so you don't end up with three giant spider legs.
I’ve seen people complain that it’s clumpy. Usually, that’s because they’re just swiping blindly. You have to use the different sides of the brush as intended. If you just gloop it on, yeah, it’s going to be heavy. But if you use the "styler" side to fan things out? The result is basically a lash lift in a bottle.
Does It Really Last 28 Hours?
Charlotte claims this provides 28-hour exaggerated volume. Let’s be real—who is wearing mascara for 28 hours? If you’re at an EDM festival or pulling a truly regrettable all-nighter, maybe. But for the rest of us living normal lives, the real question is whether it smudges by 3:00 PM.
Surprisingly, for a non-waterproof and non-tubing formula, it holds up. It uses lash-plumping polymers that "wrap" the lash rather than just sitting on top of it. This makes it smudge-proof and humidity-proof. I’ve seen reviews from people with super oily eyelids who swear this is the only thing that doesn't give them raccoon eyes by lunch.
Charlotte Tilbury Mascara Exagger Eyes vs. Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes
This is the big debate. If you already own Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes, do you need this?
📖 Related: Desi Bazar Desi Kitchen: Why Your Local Grocer is Actually the Best Place to Eat
The Pillow Talk mascara is all about vertical lift. It’s got that flat-sided paddle brush that "paints" the lashes upward. It’s great for length, but it can be a little tricky to master. The Charlotte Tilbury Mascara Exagger Eyes is more about "multiplied" volume. It makes you look like you have double the amount of lashes.
If you have short, sparse lashes, Exagger Eyes is the better bet. It fills in the gaps. If you already have thick lashes and just want them to hit your eyebrows, stick with Pillow Talk. Honestly, Exagger Eyes feels more like a traditional mascara experience but "leveled up." It’s easier to use for most people because the brush is chunky and grabs everything in one swoop.
What's Actually Inside the Formula?
It isn't just black ink. They’ve packed it with Jojoba Waxes. This is huge because most volumizing mascaras make your lashes feel like dry twigs. You know that "crunchy" feeling where you’re afraid your lashes might actually snap off if you blink too hard? You don't get that here.
The Jojoba keeps them soft. Even after two coats, you can still touch your lashes and they feel like hair, not plastic. It’s also infused with ultra-black pigments. It’s a very "inky" black. Some mascaras look a bit grey once they dry down, but this stays dark and shiny—hence the "vinyl" name.
👉 See also: Deg f to deg c: Why We’re Still Doing Mental Math in 2026
The Reality Check: Is It Worth the $29?
No product is perfect. Despite the "no-clump" marketing, this is a thick formula. If you’re used to very thin, natural-looking mascaras (like Glossier Lash Slick), this is going to feel like a lot. It’s a drama-first mascara.
Also, it’s a bit of a workout to remove. Since it’s designed to last 28 hours and resist sweat, you can't just splash your face with water and expect it to vanish. You need a solid oil-based cleanser or a bi-phase remover (the kind you shake up). If you try to scrub this off with a regular face wash, you’re going to lose some soldiers. Be gentle.
How to Get the Best Results
If you want to actually see that "9x volume" claim, don't just start at the tips.
- Start at the very base. Wiggle the inner curve of the brush right into the lash line. This mimics the look of eyeliner and makes the lashes look thicker at the root.
- Pull through to the ends using the outer curve to separate.
- Don't wait too long between coats. If you let the first coat dry completely, the second coat might get "grabby" and cause clumps.
- Use the tip for those tiny inner corner lashes. The wand is tapered enough that you can really get in there without poking your eye out.
Actionable Next Steps
If you’re ready to try it, start with the travel size. It’s around $15, and since mascara technically expires every three months anyway, it’s a great way to see if the formula works for your specific lash type without dropping $30. If you have oily lids, skip the primer—this formula is designed to grip the lash on its own, and adding more layers might actually encourage smudging rather than preventing it. Check your local Sephora or the Charlotte Tilbury site for the mini version before committing to the heavy glass bottle.