Robert Louis Stevenson didn't just write a book about a map. He basically invented the way we think about pirates. When you picture a guy with a parrot on his shoulder and a peg leg, you aren't thinking about actual 18th-century maritime history. You're thinking about the specific characters in Treasure Island. It’s kind of wild how a story written for a kid’s magazine in the 1880s still defines our collective imagination today.
Most people remember the gold. They remember the "X marks the spot." But the gold is just a plot device. The real engine of the story is the shifting, dangerous chemistry between a young boy and a group of the most charismatic villains in English literature. It's a coming-of-age story wrapped in a thriller, and honestly, it’s much darker than the Muppet version suggests.
The Problem With Jim Hawkins
Jim is our eyes and ears. Usually, in Victorian adventure novels, the kid protagonist is a bit of a bore—a "moral compass" who does everything right. Jim isn't that. He’s impulsive. He's actually kind of a liability at times. He sneaks out of the stockade. He steals the Hispaniola on a whim.
If Jim hadn't been so reckless, the expedition probably would have failed. He’s the first of the characters in Treasure Island we meet, starting at the Admiral Benbow Inn, and his growth is basically a descent into the "gray area" of adulthood. He starts out terrified of the "brown old seaman" Billy Bones and ends up being the only person who truly understands the moral complexity of a murderer like Long John Silver. He’s the survivor.
Why Long John Silver is the GOAT of Villains
Let's talk about Silver. If you look at the history of literary antagonists, few are as layered as Long John. He isn't a "bad guy" in the way a cartoon character is. He’s a mentor. He’s a cook. He’s a diplomat. He’s a cold-blooded killer.
Stevenson based Silver on his friend William Henley. Henley was a poet who had lost a leg to tuberculosis, but he had a "masterful" personality that people couldn't help but admire. That’s the secret sauce. You want to like Silver. When he tells Jim he’s "smart as paint," you feel the same glow of pride Jim feels, even though you know Silver would probably slit Jim’s throat if the gold required it.
Silver’s "sea-cook" persona is a brilliant mask. He manages to run a mutiny right under the noses of Dr. Livesey and Squire Trelawney because he knows exactly how to manipulate class dynamics. He acts like the humble servant while secretly organizing a massacre. That’s why he’s the most enduring of the characters in Treasure Island. He doesn't die at the end. He slips away with some of the gold, a final middle finger to the Victorian idea that the "good guys" always win decisively.
💡 You might also like: Brother May I Have Some Oats Script: Why This Bizarre Pig Meme Refuses to Die
The Drunk, the Squire, and the Doctor
The "respectable" men of the book are often more dangerous than the pirates because of their incompetence.
Squire Trelawney is a great example. He’s the one with the money. He’s also the one with the big mouth. He basically broadcasts the entire secret mission to every tavern in Bristol, which is how Silver manages to staff the ship with his own crew. Trelawney represents the blustering, well-meaning, but ultimately foolish upper class.
Then you have Dr. Livesey. He’s the real backbone of the "moral" side. He’s cool under pressure. He treats the pirates’ wounds even when they’re trying to kill him because he’s bound by his Hippocratic Oath. It’s a fascinating bit of characterization—he’s a man of science and law in a place where neither exists.
And we can't forget Billy Bones. He only lasts for the first few chapters, but he sets the entire tone. He’s the one who brings the "sea-chest" and the "Black Spot" into the story. His paralyzing fear of a "one-legged seafaring man" creates a psychological horror that lingers long after he dies of a rum-induced stroke.
Ben Gunn and the Reality of Isolation
Ben Gunn is often played for laughs. He’s the guy who has been marooned for three years and really, really wants some cheese. But if you look closer, Ben is a tragic figure. He’s what happens when the pirate lifestyle hits the wall of reality.
He’s deranged, sure. But he’s also the most resourceful of all the characters in Treasure Island. He’s the one who actually found the treasure while everyone else was busy fighting. He represents the "ghost" of the pirate era—a remnant of Captain Flint’s crew who has seen the horror of the lifestyle and just wants to go home and be a "pious" man again. His obsession with toasted cheese is funny, but his desperation for human contact is heart-wrenching.
📖 Related: Brokeback Mountain Gay Scene: What Most People Get Wrong
The Pirates: More Than Just Redshirts
The mutineers aren't just a faceless mob. Stevenson gives us specific, terrifying glimpses into their world:
- Israel Hands: The cynical gunner who Jim eventually has to kill in self-defense. Their fight on the masts of the Hispaniola is one of the most tense scenes in the book. Hands is pure, nihilistic violence.
- Pew: The blind beggar. He only appears briefly, but his tapping cane is the scariest sound in the book. He shows that even the "weakest" pirates are ruthless.
- Black Dog: The first hint of the trouble to come. He’s the scout, the one who proves that Billy Bones’ past is catching up to him.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Cast
People think this is a story about good vs. evil. It’s not. It’s a story about competence vs. incompetence.
The pirates are highly competent but lack a moral center. The "gentlemen" have a moral center but are often staggeringly bad at sea-faring and security. Jim Hawkins survives because he learns to bridge the two worlds. He learns the ruthlessness of the pirates and the discipline of the doctor.
When we look at the characters in Treasure Island, we’re looking at a deconstruction of the British Empire's ideals. Stevenson was writing at a time when the "adventure" of empire was starting to look a lot like simple greed. By making his most compelling character a murderous sea-cook, he forced readers to confront the fact that charisma is often more persuasive than virtue.
Identifying the True Stakes
The real conflict isn't just about who gets the chest. It's about Jim’s soul. Every interaction he has with Long John Silver is a lesson in how to lie, how to survive, and how to lead. By the end of the book, Jim is haunted. He doesn't want to go back. He has nightmares about the surf breaking on the shore and the parrot screaming "Pieces of eight!"
That’s the hallmark of great character writing. The characters change the world, and the world changes them.
👉 See also: British TV Show in Department Store: What Most People Get Wrong
Actionable Steps for Readers and Writers
If you're looking to dive deeper into these archetypes or use them in your own creative work, here is how to analyze them effectively:
1. Study the "Silver" Archetype
Don't write villains who are just mean. Write villains who are helpful. Silver is Jim's best friend for half the book. This creates a "betrayal" arc that hits much harder than a standard hero/villain dynamic.
2. Use Contrast in Your Cast
Notice how Stevenson pairs the characters. The rigid Dr. Livesey is the perfect foil for the chaotic Ben Gunn. The bumbling Squire is the perfect tool for the calculating Silver. Use these "odd couple" pairings to generate dialogue that moves the plot forward.
3. The "Ghost" Character
Captain Flint is never seen. He’s dead before the book starts. Yet, his influence is on every page. In your own storytelling, try creating a "Flint"—a character who is gone but whose past actions dictate every move the living characters make.
4. Re-read the Original Text
If you’ve only seen the movies, you're missing the nuances of Jim’s internal monologue. Notice how often he admits to being terrified or how he describes the smell of the pirates (it's usually rum and tobacco). Those sensory details are what make the characters in Treasure Island feel like people rather than tropes.
For a deeper understanding of the maritime history that influenced Stevenson, you can explore the Golden Age of Piracy records at the Royal Museums Greenwich. Seeing the real-life inspirations for these figures makes the fiction even more impressive.