Washington Irving wasn't just writing a ghost story when he published "The Sketch Book of Geoffrey Crayon, Gent." in 1820. He was basically roasting the social climate of post-Revolutionary America. Most people think of the characters in The Legend of Sleepy Hollow as cardboard cutouts from a Disney cartoon or a Tim Burton flick. They see a skinny guy, a pretty girl, and a headless ghost. But honestly? The actual text is way more cynical—and a lot funnier—than the movies suggest.
The story takes place in a "sequestered glen" near Tarry Town, New York. It's a place where time stands still. The people there are descendants of Dutch settlers, and they’re obsessed with the supernatural. Into this weird, drowsy ecosystem wanders Ichabod Crane. He’s an outsider. A "Connecticut Yankee" looking to strip-mine the town for its resources.
Ichabod Crane: Not Your Typical Hero
Ichabod is kind of a mess.
Irving describes him as looking like a "weathercock, perched upon a steeple." He’s tall, lank, and has huge ears. But his physical appearance isn't the most interesting thing about him. It’s his appetite. Ichabod is a bottomless pit. He eats everything in sight, but he also hungers for status. He isn't in Sleepy Hollow because he loves teaching children or appreciates the local culture. He’s there to find a wealthy wife, sell off her father's land, and move further west with a pocket full of cash.
That’s the part most adaptations skip. Ichabod is a bit of a predator.
He uses his position as a schoolmaster to stay at the homes of his students, where he basically eats the parents out of house and home. He flatters the mothers. He plays with the older boys. He makes himself "useful" just so he can keep his belly full. When he sets his sights on Katrina Van Tassel, it’s not because she’s brilliant or kind. It’s because her father, Baltus Van Tassel, owns a massive, thriving farm. Ichabod looks at Katrina and sees "a vast quantity of soft cakes" and "pigs with an apple in their mouth."
He’s a man of science and "Cotton Mather," yet he's the most superstitious person in the county. This contradiction is what makes him so human. He’s a smart guy who is constantly terrified of his own shadow. He represents the "new" America—intellectual, ambitious, but also rootless and deeply anxious.
The Problem with Ichabod's Conscience
He thinks he’s better than the locals. He really does.
Ichabod views the Dutch farmers as simpletons, yet he’s the one who gets duped by their folklore. Irving writes that Ichabod’s "appetite for the marvelous" was as great as his physical hunger. He would spend hours reading Mather’s History of New England Witchcraft until he was too scared to walk home in the dark. To cope, he would sing psalms. Imagine a spindly man walking through the woods at night, shrieking hymns at the top of his lungs to keep the devils away. It’s hilarious. It’s also exactly why he was the perfect target for a prank.
✨ Don't miss: Why October London Make Me Wanna Is the Soul Revival We Actually Needed
Katrina Van Tassel: The Mastermind in a Silk Petticoat
If Ichabod is the glutton, Katrina is the enigma.
She’s often portrayed as a "damsel," but in the book, she’s a "coquette." That’s 19th-century speak for a flirt who knows exactly what she’s doing. She’s the only child of the richest farmer in the area, and she’s used to getting her way.
Why did she even talk to Ichabod?
Honestly, she probably used him.
Brom Bones was the alpha male of Sleepy Hollow. He was loud, strong, and arrogant. Katrina likely used Ichabod’s attention to make Brom jealous, or maybe just to have some fun. She’s described as wearing "ornaments of pure yellow gold" and a "provocatively short" petticoat to show off her feet. She wasn’t some shy flower. She was a woman of wealth and influence who understood the power dynamics of her village perfectly.
When Ichabod finally proposes to her at the end of the party—well, Irving doesn't tell us exactly what was said. But he tells us enough. Ichabod leaves the house looking "desolate and chopfallen." Katrina likely rejected him flat out. She had no intention of leaving her father’s farm to move to the wilderness with a wandering schoolteacher. She was playing a game, and Ichabod didn't realize the stakes until it was too late.
Brom Bones and the Art of the Prank
Abraham Van Brunt, or "Brom Bones," is the hero of the local boys.
He’s the "Herculean" figure of the piece. He’s got broad shoulders, curly black hair, and a reputation for being a bit of a rowdy jerk. But he’s not a villain. In the world of characters in The Legend of Sleepy Hollow, Brom represents the old-world strength and local tradition that Ichabod is trying to infiltrate.
- He’s a skilled horseman (his horse, Daredevil, is as wild as he is).
- He has a "rough, chivalrous" sense of humor.
- He prefers a physical fight to a mental one, but he's surprisingly clever.
Brom tries to fight Ichabod for Katrina’s hand, but Ichabod won't bite. Ichabod knows he’d get crushed in a physical brawl, so he avoids Brom like the plague. This drives Brom crazy. He resorts to "scoundrel" pranks: smoking out the schoolhouse, turning things upside down, and ridiculing Ichabod in front of Katrina.
🔗 Read more: How to Watch The Wolf and the Lion Without Getting Lost in the Wild
The Night of the Party
The turning point happens at the Van Tassel "quilting frolic."
Brom sits in a corner, brooding, while Ichabod dances (badly). But then the ghost stories start. This is where Brom wins. He tells a story about racing the Headless Horseman and winning. He plants the seed of fear in Ichabod’s mind, knowing the schoolmaster is already primed for terror.
Brom isn't just a bully. He’s a guy protecting his turf. Whether he actually was the Headless Horseman that night is never explicitly confirmed by Irving, but the "shattered pumpkin" found next to Ichabod’s hat the next morning is a pretty big clue. Brom marries Katrina shortly after Ichabod disappears. Whenever the story of Ichabod is told, Brom "looked exceedingly knowing" and would "burst into a hearty laugh."
Make of that what you will.
The Headless Horseman: The Shadow Character
You can't talk about the cast without the Hessian.
The ghost is said to be the spirit of a Hessian trooper whose head was carried away by a cannonball during "some nameless battle" of the Revolutionary War. He isn't just a monster; he’s a remnant of the war. Sleepy Hollow is a place where history lingers. The Horseman is the manifestation of the town’s collective memory and its fear of outsiders.
What’s interesting is that the Horseman only appears to those who are already looking for him. Ichabod’s imagination does half the work. The "ghost" is a reflection of the person seeing it. For the locals, it's a fun story to tell by the fire. For Ichabod, it's a death sentence.
Supporting Players in the Hollow
While the "big three" get all the glory, the atmosphere of the story depends on the background characters.
💡 You might also like: Is Lincoln Lawyer Coming Back? Mickey Haller's Next Move Explained
Baltus Van Tassel is the epitome of the "contented man." He’s wealthy, but he doesn't flaunt it in a mean way. He just wants everyone to be fed and happy. His farm is described in such lush detail that it becomes a character itself. The "sleek porkers," the "regiment of turkeys," and the "pigeons" all serve to highlight what Ichabod wants to take for himself.
Hans Van Ripper is another important figure. He’s the "choleric" old farmer who lends Ichabod his horse, Gunpowder. Van Ripper represents the stern, practical side of the Dutch community. He’s a "furious rider" himself, but he has no patience for Ichabod’s nonsense. When Ichabod disappears, Van Ripper is more upset about the loss of his horse and the fact that Ichabod burned his "stolen" books than he is about the man himself.
Why the Characters Still Matter Today
We all know an Ichabod.
He’s the guy who thinks he’s the smartest person in the room but lacks basic common sense. He’s the person who moves into a new neighborhood and immediately starts complaining about how things are done. We also know Broms—people who use humor and physical presence to maintain their status.
The genius of Washington Irving was creating a cast that feels grounded despite the supernatural trappings. He captured the tension between the "refined" East Coast and the "rugged" frontier. He showed how stories and folklore can be used as weapons.
Actionable Insights for Reading the Legend
If you want to truly appreciate these characters, don't just watch the movies. Here is how to approach the original text for the best experience:
- Look for the Satire: Read Ichabod’s descriptions as a parody of the "intellectual elite." Irving was making fun of people who thought book learning made them superior to everyone else.
- Focus on the Food: Notice how often Ichabod thinks about eating. It’s his primary motivation. It turns a "spooky" story into a commentary on greed.
- Question the Narrator: The story is told by Diedrich Knickerbocker, a fictional historian who isn't always reliable. He’s heard the story from an old gentleman at a meeting. The layers of storytelling mean we’re getting a "version" of the truth, which adds to the ghostly, uncertain vibe of the town.
- Observe the Landscape: The trees, the brooks, and the "Witch's Tree" are treated with as much personality as the humans. The setting is what dictates the characters' behavior.
The Legend of Sleepy Hollow isn't a story about a ghost killing a man. It's a story about a community using its legends to eject a person who didn't belong. Ichabod Crane didn't die; he likely ran away in shame, found a job as a lawyer or a politician, and lived a long life elsewhere. But in the minds of the people of Sleepy Hollow, he was carried off by the Horseman. And honestly? The legend is a much better story than the reality.