If you’ve been following the MIAA lately, you know that the Catholic Memorial football score is usually a lopsided affair in favor of the Knights. Honestly, it’s gotten to the point where seeing a "41-14" or a "47-0" on the scoreboard feels like just another Tuesday for the West Roxbury powerhouse. They aren't just winning; they are systematically dismantling opponents with a blend of high-end talent and a coaching philosophy that feels more collegiate than high school.
Look at the December 6th state championship at Gillette Stadium. The final tally was Catholic Memorial 41, Bishop Feehan 14. That wasn’t a fluke. It was a statement. The Knights walked into the home of the Patriots and put up over 300 rushing yards, basically telling the Shamrocks that they couldn't be stopped at the line of scrimmage. It's a specific kind of dominance that makes you wonder if anyone in Division 2 can actually hang with them for four quarters.
The 2025 Campaign: Breaking Down the Numbers
The 2025 season was a roller coaster, but the kind that only goes up. They finished with a 10-2 record, which might look "human" until you realize who those two losses were against. We’re talking about absolute dogfights with Xaverian Brothers and St. John’s Prep—the literal titans of Massachusetts football.
Key Scores from the Championship Run
- State Final: Catholic Memorial 41, Bishop Feehan 14
- State Semifinal: Catholic Memorial 49, Winchester 0
- Quarterfinal: Catholic Memorial 47, Wellesley 0
- The Rivalry Game: Catholic Memorial 48, BC High 27
That Winchester score? 49-0. In a playoff game. That’s just mean. But it shows the gap between the elite programs and the "very good" ones. CM isn't just playing for the win; they’re playing for a standard. Coach John DiBiaso has these guys firing on all cylinders, and when Harvard-bound QB Kise Flannery is under center, the offense feels like a cheat code.
🔗 Read more: Liverpool FC Chelsea FC: Why This Grudge Match Still Hits Different
Why the Scoreboards Look the Way They Do
It’s not just about having the best athletes, though having guys like Mac Fitzgerald (a BC commit) and Isaiah Simmons certainly helps. It’s the depth. You’ve got Ibrahim Kaba and Christian Simmons rotating in the backfield, meaning the defense never gets a break from fresh, fast legs.
Most high school teams have a "star player" problem. If the star gets shut down, the offense dies. At Catholic Memorial, if you stop the primary option, the secondary option is usually a Division I prospect anyway. That’s why you see these explosive second halves. In the BC High game, it was 48-27, but the score feels closer than the game actually was because CM just wears people down.
Addressing the "Easy Schedule" Myth
You'll hear people in the stands or on social media claiming CM has it easy in Division 2. It’s a common gripe. "They should be in Division 1," they say. While the debate about divisional placement is a whole different rabbit hole, you can't argue with who they actually play.
💡 You might also like: NFL Football Teams in Order: Why Most Fans Get the Hierarchy Wrong
They went out of state to play St. Thomas Aquinas (NJ) and won 35-7. They traveled to New York and beat St. Francis 56-32. These aren't cupcake games. These are intentional, high-stakes matchups designed to prepare them for the postseason. When they finally hit the MIAA playoffs, they've already seen the best talent the Northeast has to offer.
The Xaverian Heartbreaker
The only real "blemish" on the local record was that 25-22 loss to Xaverian Brothers on October 17th. It was an instant classic. A game-winning field goal by Xaverian’s Zander Govostes as time expired snapped CM’s 17-game win streak against their rival. It was a reminder that they can be beaten, but it took a perfect drive and a zero-second field goal to do it.
What to Expect Next
If you're looking for the next Catholic Memorial football score, you're likely looking at the 2026 preseason or looking back at the recruitment trails. This program doesn't rebuild; they reload. With players like Christian Simmons and Liam Conlon returning, the defensive identity isn't going anywhere.
📖 Related: Why Your 1 Arm Pull Up Progression Isn't Working (And How to Fix It)
Practical steps for fans and scouts:
- Watch the Tape: If you want to see how a modern power-run game works, go back and watch the Winchester or Bishop Feehan game film.
- Follow the Commits: Keep an eye on Mac Fitzgerald and Kise Flannery as they transition to the college level; their performance is a direct reflection of the CM system.
- Check the 2026 Schedule: The Knights usually release their schedule late spring. Look for those out-of-state "power" matchups early in September.
- Go to Gillette: If they make the finals again (and let's be real, they probably will), the atmosphere at the state championship is the closest thing you'll get to a college bowl game in New England.
The reality is that Catholic Memorial has built a culture where the final score is almost a foregone conclusion. They've found a way to marry Catholic Conference grit with modern offensive explosive plays, and until someone finds a way to match their size on the interior lines, those scoreboards are going to keep leaning heavily toward the Knights.