Finding the right Catherine the Great books is honestly a bit of a nightmare because everyone wants to talk about the horse. You know the rumor. It's fake, by the way—a piece of French revolutionary propaganda meant to slut-shame a powerful woman after she died. If you go into a bookstore looking for the "real" Catherine, you're going to find a massive pile of historical fiction that reads like a soap opera and dense academic texts that feel like reading a phone book.
She was an obscure German princess named Sophie who arrived in Russia with nothing but a few dresses and a very sharp brain. She ended up running the largest empire on earth. To understand that kind of climb, you need a book that understands power, not just scandal.
The Gold Standard: Robert K. Massie’s Masterpiece
If you only ever read one of the many Catherine the Great books out there, make it Catherine the Great: Portrait of a Woman by Robert K. Massie. Massie is basically the king of Romanov history. He spent years digging through the archives, and it shows. What makes this one different is that he treats her like a human being rather than a caricature of an empress.
He captures the sheer loneliness of her early years. Imagine being fifteen, stuck in a foreign court where your husband plays with toy soldiers in bed and your mother-in-law (Empress Elizabeth) literally steals your baby the moment it’s born. Massie writes this with such a narrative drive that it feels like a novel. You're there in the drafty palaces. You feel the Russian winter.
But it’s not all feelings. Massie explains the Enlightenment. Catherine was pen pals with Voltaire and Diderot. She wanted to bring "Reason" to a country that was still mostly feudal. Massie doesn't shy away from her failures, though. She talked a big game about freeing the serfs, but when push came to shove, she actually made their lives worse to keep the nobles happy. It’s a complicated, messy, brilliant biography.
📖 Related: Finding the Right Words: Quotes About Sons That Actually Mean Something
What Most People Get Wrong About Her Memoirs
Most people don't realize that Catherine wrote her own story. Well, parts of it. The Memoirs of Catherine the Great is a wild read because she’s a totally unreliable narrator. She’s writing for an audience. She wants you to like her. She wants you to think her husband, Peter III, was an idiot who deserved to be overthrown.
Reading her own words is essential if you want to see how she marketed herself. She was the original master of personal branding. In the Oxford World's Classics edition, you get a real sense of her voice—witty, slightly arrogant, and incredibly observant. She describes the Russian court as a "glittering cage."
Honestly, it's hilarious in spots. She mocks the fashion, the smell of the courtiers, and the absurdity of the rituals. But you have to read between the lines. She leaves out the blood. She leaves out the coup details where her lovers likely strangled her husband. It’s the 18th-century version of a highly curated Instagram feed.
The Political Power Moves
For those who want to skip the romance and get into the "Great" part of her name, Catherine the Great by Isabel de Madariaga is the heavy hitter. It’s long. It’s dense. It is absolutely not a beach read. But if you want to understand how she restructured the Russian government and expanded the borders into Crimea and Poland, this is the one.
👉 See also: Williams Sonoma Deer Park IL: What Most People Get Wrong About This Kitchen Icon
De Madariaga was a legendary historian who grew tired of people focusing on Catherine's lovers. She argued that Catherine’s "Greatness" came from her legal reforms and her sheer administrative stamina. She worked twelve-hour days. She wrote her own laws.
Why the "Lover" Narrative is Overblown
We have to talk about the favorites. Yes, she had lovers. Orlov, Potemkin, Zubov—the list goes on. But most Catherine the Great books treat this like a tawdry romance novel. In reality, these men were often her political partners.
- Grigory Potemkin: He wasn't just a boyfriend; he was basically her co-emperor.
- Simon Sebag Montefiore’s book Catherine the Great and Potemkin is the best resource here.
- It uses their private letters, which are frankly shocking.
- They’re erotic, sure, but they’re also full of military strategy and statecraft.
Montefiore shows that they might have actually been secretly married. They shared power in a way that was totally unique for the time. He stayed her most trusted advisor even after they stopped sleeping together. That's a level of emotional maturity you don't expect from 18th-century autocrats.
The Darker Side: Serfdom and Rebellion
You can't talk about Catherine without talking about Yemelyan Pugachev. He was a Cossack who claimed he was her "dead" husband, Peter III, and led a massive peasant uprising. If you want to see the gritty, non-palace side of her reign, look into Autocrats and Peasants or specific academic journals covering the Pugachev Rebellion.
✨ Don't miss: Finding the most affordable way to live when everything feels too expensive
Catherine’s reaction to the rebellion changed her. She started as a liberal reformer and ended as a hardened autocrat. She realized that to keep her crown, she needed the support of the landowners, and the landowners wanted their serfs kept in chains. It's the great tragedy of her reign. She was a woman of the Enlightenment who presided over a dark age for the Russian peasantry.
Practical Advice for Your Reading List
If you’re just starting, don't dive into the 900-page academic tomes. You’ll get bored and quit.
Start with Robert K. Massie. His prose is the most accessible and "human." Once you have the timeline of her life down, move to her Memoirs to see how she lied about it. Finally, if you're still obsessed, go for Montefiore to understand the weird, brilliant partnership she had with Potemkin.
Avoid the books that have covers looking like "bodice-rippers" (the ones with the half-undressed women on the front). Those are almost always historically inaccurate junk. Look for books published by university presses or renowned historians like Virginia Rounding, whose biography Catherine the Great: Love, Sex, and Power strikes a good balance between the personal and the political without being trashy.
Your Catherine the Great Reading Strategy
- Identify your interest: Are you here for the politics, the personal drama, or the military expansion?
- Check the sources: Does the author cite the "Instruction" (Nakaz) Catherine wrote? If not, skip it.
- Look for the Potemkin letters: Any modern book that doesn't reference the correspondence discovered in the last few decades is outdated.
- Balance the perspectives: Read one Western biography and then try to find a translated Russian perspective if you can; the viewpoints on her "Germanness" vary wildly between the two.
Catherine was a woman who took a failing, backward country and forced it onto the world stage. She was a mother, a lover, a usurper, and a philosopher. No single book can capture all of that, but starting with the right ones ensures you aren't just reading the 200-year-old gossip of her enemies.