Honestly, it feels like forever ago that we were all huddled around our screens watching Kara Danvers clumsily spill coffee while trying to hide her cape. The cast of Supergirl series basically lived in our living rooms for six seasons, and even though the show wrapped up in 2021, the fandom hasn't really let go. You've probably seen the headlines about the "new" Supergirl movie coming out in mid-2026, but let’s be real—for many of us, Melissa Benoist is the Girl of Steel.
People keep asking where everyone went. Did they just fly off into the sunset? Not exactly. Some are winning Tonys on Broadway, others are writing the very comics that inspired them, and a few have hopped over to entirely different genres, like time-traveling family dramas or gritty John Wick spin-offs.
Melissa Benoist: Life After the Cape
Melissa was always the heart of the show. After hanging up the suit, she didn't just disappear into the Fortress of Solitude. She actually leaned heavily into her theater roots and her production company, Three Things Productions.
Kinda cool fact: she actually made her Broadway debut while the show was still running, but lately, she’s been focused on "The Girls on the Bus," which, yeah, was a bit of a departure from punching aliens. By early 2026, she's become a regular fixture at fan conventions. If you caught her at FanX late last year, you saw her and Tyler Hoechlin (our TV Superman) basically roasting each other on stage. She’s been pretty open about wanting to focus on being a mom while picking projects that actually mean something to her. She isn't chasing every blockbuster, and honestly, we respect that.
👉 See also: Kate Moss Family Guy: What Most People Get Wrong About That Cutaway
Chyler Leigh and the Hallmark Pivot
Then there’s Alex Danvers. Chyler Leigh gave us one of the best sister dynamics on TV. Most fans were surprised when she moved over to the Hallmark Channel, but if you haven't seen The Way Home, you're missing out. It's not your typical "small town girl meets baker" story; it's a weird, emotional time-travel mystery.
As of right now, in early 2026, the show is heading into its fourth and final season. Chyler has basically become the queen of this new "fantasy-drama" niche. It’s a different vibe from the DEO, but her character, Kat Landry, has that same "I’ll do anything for my family" grit that Alex had.
The Villains and the Besties: Where Are They?
We can't talk about the cast of Supergirl series without mentioning the Luthors.
✨ Don't miss: Blink-182 Mark Hoppus: What Most People Get Wrong About His 2026 Comeback
- Katie McGrath (Lena Luthor): Katie is basically the internet's favorite person. Since the show ended, she’s popped up in The Continental (that John Wick prequel series) looking absolutely lethal. Most recently, she’s been filming for The Ex-Wife season two, stepping into a role that lets her use that trademark intensity. She still stays pretty low-key on social media, which just adds to the mystery, doesn't it?
- Jon Cryer (Lex Luthor): Jon really proved everyone wrong with his Lex. Many people just saw him as Alan from Two and a Half Men, but he was terrifying. Lately, he’s been back in the comedy world with NBC, but he’s gone on record saying he’d suit up as Lex again in a heartbeat if the multiversal stars aligned.
- David Harewood (J’onn J’onzz): Our favorite Martian is currently killing it on the London stage. He’s been starring in a massive production of Othello that’s been getting rave reviews. He’s also become a huge advocate for mental health, releasing books and documentaries that are way more "real world hero" than anything the Arrowverse could write.
Nicole Maines: From Playing Dreamer to Writing Her
This is probably the coolest transition of the whole group. Nicole Maines didn’t just play Nia Nal; she became her. She started writing the Dreamer comics for DC while the show was still on the air, and she hasn't stopped.
Right now, she's actually a legit powerhouse in the DC Comics writing room. She just released a trade paperback of her Secret Six run, and word is she’s co-writing a major Justice League arc for 2026. It’s rare to see an actor have that much impact on the source material of the character they played. She’s basically making sure Nia Nal stays a central part of the DC Universe forever.
Jeremy Jordan and the Broadway Takeover
Winn Schott was the "guy in the chair" we all loved. If you’ve been following Jeremy Jordan, you know he belongs on a stage. For most of 2024 and 2025, he’s been the face of The Great Gatsby on Broadway. He’s actually set to take his final bow as Jay Gatsby in March 2026. The guy has a set of pipes that can literally shake a theater, and while we miss his tech-support quips, seeing him lead a massive musical is where he’s meant to be.
🔗 Read more: Why Grand Funk’s Bad Time is Secretly the Best Pop Song of the 1970s
Why the Supergirl Cast Still Matters
People still care about this group because they felt like a real found family. That’s hard to fake for 126 episodes. Even as the new DCU (the James Gunn era) starts to cast new versions of these characters—like Milly Alcock taking over as the big-screen Supergirl—the CW cast remains the "gold standard" for a lot of fans.
They navigated some weird times, too. Remember the mid-season breaks, the move from CBS to The CW, and that massive Crisis on Infinite Earths crossover? It was a lot.
If you're looking to keep up with the cast of Supergirl series, the best way is to look toward the stage and the page. Check out David Harewood’s theater work if you’re in London, or grab Nicole Maines' latest comic at your local shop. They might not be wearing capes every Tuesday night anymore, but they’re definitely still doing "super" things.
Next Steps for Fans:
- Check out The Way Home on Hallmark if you want to see Chyler Leigh’s latest work before it ends this spring.
- Keep an eye on Broadway casting if you're a Jeremy Jordan fan; he rarely stays away from the stage for long after a big run ends.
- Pick up the Secret Six trade paperback by Nicole Maines to see how Nia Nal’s story is evolving in the comics.