Selecting a cast for Merchant of Venice is basically a nightmare for any director. Honestly, it’s one of those plays that sits right on the edge of being a "comedy" while actually being a gut-wrenching tragedy about religious hate and legal loopholes. If you cast a Shylock who is too villainous, the modern audience hates you. If you cast a Portia who is too sweet, you lose the cold, calculated edge she needs to win that trial.
You’ve probably seen the 2004 movie with Al Pacino, right? That’s usually the first thing people think of when they look up the cast. But the history of who has played these roles—from the Royal Shakespeare Company (RSC) to the Globe—tells a much weirder and more interesting story than just one Hollywood flick.
The Al Pacino Era: The 2004 Movie Cast
The 2004 film is kinda the "gold standard" for a lot of students and casual fans. Michael Radford directed it, and he didn't hold back on the grit. The cast merchant of Venice featured here was stacked with heavy hitters.
- Al Pacino as Shylock: Pacino didn't play him as a cartoon villain. He was exhausted. You can see the weight of the Venetian ghetto on his shoulders.
- Jeremy Irons as Antonio: He played the titular "Merchant" with a sort of quiet, depressed longing. There’s a lot of subtext between him and Bassanio in this version.
- Joseph Fiennes as Bassanio: Fresh off Shakespeare in Love, Fiennes brought that desperate, romantic energy that makes you realize Bassanio is basically a broke socialite.
- Lynn Collins as Portia: She had to balance being a witty heiress with the gravitas of a fake lawyer. Most people remember her red hair and the "mercy" speech.
What really worked with this cast was the chemistry. You actually believed Antonio would give up a pound of flesh for Bassanio because Jeremy Irons looked at Joseph Fiennes like he was the only thing worth living for. It wasn't just a business deal; it felt personal.
When Shylock Becomes the Hero (or the Victim)
For centuries, Shylock was played as a caricature. A "monster of unrelieved evil," as some old critics put it. Then came Edmund Kean in 1814. He changed everything by playing Shylock with sympathy.
Since then, the cast merchant of Venice has seen some incredible transformations. Take Patrick Stewart, for example. Long before he was Captain Picard, he was doing Shakespeare. He’s played Shylock multiple times, notably in a 1978 RSC production and again in 2011 in a Las Vegas-themed version. Stewart plays him with a sharp, intellectual bite. He’s not just a victim; he’s the smartest guy in the room who gets screwed by a technicality.
📖 Related: Alfonso Cuarón: Why the Harry Potter 3 Director Changed the Wizarding World Forever
Then there's the legendary Henry Irving. Back in 1879, his Shylock was so popular it ran for 250 nights. He played him as an "aristocratic, proud" man. His Portia? The famous Ellen Terry. They were the "it" couple of the Victorian stage.
Recent Standouts at the Globe and West End
If you’re looking for something more recent, Jonathan Pryce at the Globe (2015) was a masterclass. What made that production wild was that his real-life daughter, Phoebe Pryce, played his daughter Jessica. That added a layer of actual heartbreak when she ran away with his money.
More recently, we had Tracy-Ann Oberman in The Merchant of Venice 1936. She flipped the script by playing Shylock as a Jewish matriarch in London’s East End, facing off against British fascists. It changed the whole dynamic of the "bond." Suddenly, the merchant wasn't just a guy with a loan; it was about survival in a pre-war tension cooker.
The "Other" Characters Who Make or Break the Play
We always talk about Shylock and Portia, but the supporting cast merchant of Venice determines if the play is actually funny or just depressing.
The "Salanio and Salarino" Problem
These two are basically the "filler" guys who talk a lot and don't do much. But in the 2004 film, they were played by John Sessions and Gregor Fisher, who actually gave them personalities. They’re the "bros" of Venice, and if they aren't played as slightly annoying, the play drags.
👉 See also: Why the Cast of Hold Your Breath 2024 Makes This Dust Bowl Horror Actually Work
Launcelot Gobbo
He’s the "clown." In the 2010 Broadway revival, Christopher Fitzgerald played him alongside Al Pacino. If the actor playing Gobbo isn't physically funny, his scenes feel like an ancient SNL skit that went on too long.
Jessica and Lorenzo
Their elopement is supposed to be romantic, but honestly, it’s kinda messed up. In the RSC's 2015 production, Scarlett Brooks and James Corrigan played them with a lot of insecurity. You get the feeling Lorenzo only wants her for the jewels she stole. It's dark.
Why Casting Portia is a Trap
Portia is the hardest role to cast. She starts off as a bored girl in a mansion (Belmont) and ends up as the most powerful legal mind in Venice. If an actress plays her too "girly" in the beginning, the transition to the courtroom feels fake.
Lily Rabe played Portia in the 2010 Shakespeare in the Park production (which eventually moved to Broadway). She was brilliant because she showed Portia’s anxiety. Choosing a husband via a "casket test" is stressful. Rabe showed that beneath the wit, Portia was terrified of her father’s will.
Key Castings You Should Know
| Actor | Role | Production | Why it Matters |
|---|---|---|---|
| Laurence Olivier | Shylock | 1970 National Theatre | He played him as a Victorian businessman; very assimilated and sharp. |
| Judi Dench | Portia | 1971 RSC | She brought a level of intelligence that made the legal trial feel like a chess match. |
| David Harbour | Bassanio | 2010 Broadway | Before Stranger Things, he played a very masculine, desperate version of the character. |
| Makram J. Khoury | Shylock | 2015 RSC | As a celebrated Palestinian-Israeli actor, his casting added massive political weight to the role. |
The Nuance of the "Gay" Antonio
Modern directors almost always cast Antonio with the assumption that he’s in love with Bassanio. It’s the only thing that explains why he’d risk his life for a guy who just wants to go marry a rich girl.
✨ Don't miss: Is Steven Weber Leaving Chicago Med? What Really Happened With Dean Archer
In the 2004 film, Jeremy Irons played this with such subtlety. It wasn't "loud," but you felt his loneliness. Compare that to Dominic Mafham at the Globe, who played opposite Jonathan Pryce. The "gay angle" was much more evident there, making the ending of the play—where Antonio is left alone while everyone else goes off in couples—truly tragic.
Moving Forward: How to Watch
If you're trying to get into the play, don't just read the script. Shakespeare was meant to be seen.
- Start with the 2004 Film: It’s the most accessible way to see a high-budget cast merchant of Venice.
- Look for RSC Archives: If you can find the Antony Sher (1987) or David Suchet (1981) versions, watch them. They represent the peak of "physical" Shylocks.
- Check National Theatre at Home: They often cycle through their filmed stage productions.
Basically, the "best" cast is the one that makes you feel uncomfortable. This isn't a play that’s supposed to have a "happily ever after." When you see a cast that makes the courtroom scene feel like a horror movie, you’ve found the right one.
To really understand the dynamics, your next step should be comparing the "Hath a Jew eyes" speech across three different actors—Pacino, Stewart, and Olivier. The difference in their delivery will tell you everything you need to know about how they viewed the character’s humanity.
***