If you were scrolling through Instagram in 2019, you couldn't escape the "fence jump." It was the reality TV moment heard 'round the world. Cassie Randolph, the soft-spoken blonde from Huntington Beach, had just walked away from Colton Underwood, and the Bachelor franchise was effectively in meltdown. But fast forward to 2026, and the conversation around Cassie Randolph movies and tv shows looks a lot different than people expected back then.
Most fans assumed she’d follow the standard influencer-to-actress pipeline. You know the one—get a million followers, land a guest spot on a sitcom, and maybe do a Hallmark movie. Honestly? Cassie kinda did the opposite. While her sister, Michelle Randolph, has become a massive breakout star in Taylor Sheridan’s Yellowstone universe (1923 and Landman), Cassie has been incredibly picky about what she puts on screen.
The Reality Roots: Young Once and The Bachelor
Long before the ABC cameras found her, Cassie was actually a veteran of the "micro-reality" scene. If you haven't seen Young Once, it’s a bit of a trip. It’s a documentary-style series that followed students at Biola University, a conservative Christian school in Southern California.
- Young Once (2016-2019): This wasn't polished TV. It was raw, low-budget, and basically followed Cassie and her then-boyfriend Caelan Tiongson as they navigated faith and relationships.
- The Bachelor Season 23 (2019): This is where she became a household name. She didn't just appear; she essentially broke the show's format by leaving before the finale, only to have Colton chase her down.
Looking back, her stint on The Bachelor was more than just a dating show appearance. It was a catalyst for a massive national conversation about consent and boundaries following the pair's eventual, and very public, legal battle in 2020. Since then, her "TV shows" have mostly consisted of high-profile interviews on Good Morning America and The View, where she’s handled some pretty heavy topics with a level of grace that’s frankly rare for reality alumni.
📖 Related: Brandi Love Explained: Why the Businesswoman and Adult Icon Still Matters in 2026
Does Cassie Randolph Actually Do Movies?
This is where the confusion usually starts. If you search for Cassie Randolph movies and tv shows, you’ll see her name pop up next to titles like A Cowboy Christmas Romance.
But here’s the kicker: she’s often credited as an actress because she frequently appears in projects alongside her sister or her now-husband, musician Brighton Reinhardt. In 2023, she appeared in the Lifetime movie A Cowboy Christmas Romance, but if you blink, you might miss her. She played "Michelle," a small role that felt more like a fun cameo than a serious "I’m an actress now" pivot.
She also famously starred as the love interest in Brighton’s music video for "Dreaming" in 2021. While it’s not a feature film, the production quality was high enough that fans started campaigning for her to get a lead role in a rom-com. It hasn't happened yet. And honestly? It might never happen.
👉 See also: Melania Trump Wedding Photos: What Most People Get Wrong
Why She’s Not the Next Big Movie Star (By Choice)
The most fascinating thing about Cassie’s "filmography" is the stuff she hasn't done. She reportedly turned down a spot in Colton Underwood’s Netflix series Coming Out Colton. She’s stayed away from the Bachelor in Paradise circuit.
Instead of chasing IMDB credits, she finished her Master’s degree in Speech-Language Pathology at the University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire in 2021. In an industry where people sell their souls for five more minutes of screen time, Cassie went and got a day job. Well, a "day job" that she balances with a massive social media presence and occasional TV appearances.
The Randolph Resume Breakdown:
- A Cowboy Christmas Romance (2023): Her primary scripted credit.
- Show Us Your Pets (2022): A quick, lighthearted appearance that fits her brand.
- Valerie’s Home Cooking (2020): A guest spot that showed her more domestic, relatable side.
- The Bachelor: The Greatest Seasons – Ever! (2020): A retrospective look at her time in the franchise.
The 2026 Perspective: Life After the Cameras
Now that it’s 2026, Cassie’s life has shifted even further from the Hollywood lights. Her recent marriage to Brighton Reinhardt at a luxury villa in Costa Rica was covered by major outlets, but she’s mostly stayed in the "lifestyle" lane rather than the "acting" lane.
✨ Don't miss: Erika Kirk Married Before: What Really Happened With the Rumors
She's proven that you can be a reality TV "winner" without making reality TV your entire personality. While she supports her sister Michelle’s meteoric rise in Hollywood, Cassie seems content being the supportive sibling and a professional speech pathologist.
It’s easy to get her confused with Michelle, especially since they look so much alike and often work together on brand deals. But if you’re looking for a long list of movies starring Cassie Randolph, you’re going to be disappointed. Her "filmography" is more about a girl who accidentally got famous, handled the fallout of a messy public breakup, and decided that a quiet life was actually the bigger prize.
If you’re tracking her career, don’t look for her on movie posters. Look for her in the credits of speech therapy journals or the occasional high-end lifestyle segment. She’s one of the few who realized that being on TV is a great way to start a career, but it doesn't have to be the career itself.
Actionable Insight: If you're a fan of the Randolph sisters, follow Michelle for the big-screen updates and Taylor Sheridan drama, but keep an eye on Cassie’s YouTube and Instagram for more grounded, "real-life" content that focuses on her professional work and her life in Huntington Beach.