Let’s be real for a second. If you grew up during the golden age of Dexter’s Lab or Ben 10, you probably spent at least one afternoon daydreaming about who would win in a fight between Samurai Jack and Johnny Bravo. In 2011, Papaya Studio actually tried to answer that question with Cartoon Network Punch Time Explosion. It wasn't perfect. In fact, it was kind of a mess in some places, but it remains one of the most fascinating artifacts of early 2010s gaming history.
People call it a "Smash clone." And honestly? They’re right. It lifts the percentage-based damage system, the ring-out mechanics, and the four-player chaos directly from Nintendo’s playbook. But calling it just a clone misses the point of why people still talk about it on forums or hunt down copies for the Nintendo 3DS and Wii. It was a love letter to a specific era of animation that doesn't really exist anymore.
The Roster: A Fever Dream of 90s and 2000s Nostalgia
The game launched first on the 3DS before getting the "XL" treatment on consoles like the Xbox 360, PS3, and Wii. The roster is where things get weirdly specific. You’ve got the heavy hitters like The Powerpuff Girls and Ben 10, sure. But then you look closer and see Captain Planet. Or Father from Codename: Kids Next Door.
The sheer variety of playstyles was surprisingly deep for a licensed tie-in.
Take Buttercup, for example. She’s a brawler through and through. Then you have Mac and Bloo from Foster’s Home for Imaginary Friends, who play as a duo character, much like the Ice Climbers. The developers didn't just skin generic fighters with Cartoon Network faces; they actually tried to make the movesets feel authentic to the shows. When Johnny Bravo attacks, he’s literally flexing or using hairspray. It’s ridiculous. It’s campy. It’s exactly what a fan would want.
However, the balancing was... non-existent. If you played this competitively (and yes, a tiny competitive scene actually existed for a minute), you knew that certain characters could basically infinite-combo you into oblivion. It wasn't balanced by Sakurai. It was balanced by a studio trying to hit a holiday release window.
🔗 Read more: Why Transformers Fall of Cybertron Megatron Still Sets the Gold Standard for Villain Campaigns
Why the XL Version Changed the Game
If you only played the original 3DS release, you missed out. The Cartoon Network Punch Time Explosion XL version added eight new characters, including Aku and Pinky and the Brain (as an assist, naturally). It also smoothed out some of the more egregious frame rate issues that plagued the handheld version.
The console version felt like a "real" game. It had a full story mode narrated by a guy who sounded suspiciously like a classic TV announcer, weaving together disparate universes through a glitch-themed plot. It was essentially Subspace Emissary but with the Dexter’s Lab volcano base.
One thing that doesn't get enough credit is the "Punch Time" mechanic itself. By collecting glowing cubes, you could trigger a cinematic super move. These were visually spectacular for the time. Seeing the Powerpuff Girls blast a hole through the moon or Captain Planet turning enemies into trees provided that specific dopamine hit that only crossover games can provide.
The Graphics and That "Budget" Feel
Look, we have to talk about the visuals. By 2011 standards, the game looked okay. By today’s standards? It’s rough.
The environments are often static and a bit muddy. Some of the character models—especially the ones based on 2D shows like Chowder—don't transition perfectly into 3D. They have that slightly "uncanny valley" look that happened a lot during the Wii era. But there’s a charm to it. It feels like a time capsule of an era where mid-tier licensed games could still get a physical retail release on three different consoles.
Nowadays, a project like this would likely be a free-to-play mobile game riddled with microtransactions. Back then, you paid your $40, you got the disc, and you had the whole roster (mostly) ready to go.
Comparing the Legacy: Punch Time Explosion vs. MultiVersus
It is impossible to talk about Cartoon Network Punch Time Explosion without mentioning MultiVersus. When MultiVersus dropped, everyone immediately started comparing the two. But they are fundamentally different beasts.
MultiVersus is a live-service product. It’s polished, it’s competitive, and it’s designed to last forever. Punch Time Explosion was a snapshot. It captured a moment when the "Check It" era of Cartoon Network was just beginning and the "Powerhouse" era was fading into memory.
✨ Don't miss: Getting the Most Out of Fallout 3 Console Commands Without Breaking Your Save
The voice acting in Punch Time was a mixed bag. They got some of the original VAs, but not all of them. This led to some characters sounding slightly "off," which added to the fever-dream quality of the experience. MultiVersus has the budget for the full cast, but it lacks that chaotic, "anything goes" energy of the 2011 title. In Punch Time, the stages were arguably more creative. Fighting on the back of a giant Cheese from Foster's while he screams "I like chocolate milk!" is a level of absurdity MultiVersus hasn't quite reached yet.
The Technical Reality: Glitches and All
The game was buggy. Let's not sugarcoat it.
You would frequently see characters clipping through platforms. The AI in the story mode was either brain-dead or possessed by a God-tier fighting game pro with no middle ground. On the 3DS, the frame rate would chug if more than two players used their specials at the same time.
Yet, for a kid in 2011, none of that mattered.
The game offered a "Crossover" experience that was previously only available in fan-made Flash games or M.U.G.E.N. builds. It was official. It was on the shelf at GameStop. For many, it was the first time they realized that the shows they loved were part of a larger, interconnected brand.
Where to Find It Today
If you want to play it now, you’re looking at the secondary market. The game isn't available on digital storefronts anymore due to the complicated web of licensing agreements that eventually expire.
- Wii Version: Generally considered the most stable and fun for local multiplayer.
- PS3/Xbox 360: These have the best resolution and the full "XL" roster.
- 3DS: Only for the completionists. The small screen and technical limitations make it the weakest way to play.
Prices for the XL versions have stayed surprisingly steady. It hasn't spiked into the hundreds of dollars like some "hidden gems," but it’s not bargain-bin fodder either. Collectors value it because it’s one of the few instances where characters like Captain Planet appear in a modern fighting game context.
The Enduring Appeal of Mascot Brawlers
Why do we keep coming back to games like Cartoon Network Punch Time Explosion? It’s the "toy box" effect.
As kids, we mix our action figures. We make Batman fight a dinosaur. This game was the digital version of that. It didn't need to be Melee. It just needed to let us hit Kevin Levin with a giant mallet while playing as Amy from The Powerpuff Girls.
The game serves as a reminder that not every title needs to be a 10/10 masterpiece to be memorable. Sometimes, being the only game where you can see Grim from The Grim Adventures of Billy & Mandy lay the smackdown on Ben 10 is enough to earn a spot in gaming history.
It was ambitious. It was flawed. It was loud. It was exactly what Cartoon Network represented at the turn of the decade. While it might be overshadowed by newer, shinier platform fighters, those who played it remember the sheer hype of seeing that first trailer and realizing that, for once, the "What If" scenarios were coming true.
✨ Don't miss: Duet Night Abyss Tier List: Who Actually Carries the Meta in 2026?
How to Experience the Game Now
If you are planning on diving back into this title, skip the handheld versions entirely. They don't do the scope of the game justice. Look for the XL version on a console. If you're a fan of animation history, pay close attention to the assist characters—many of them are deep cuts that show the developers actually cared about the source material.
- Check Local Retro Shops: You can often find the Wii version for a reasonable price.
- Verify the Version: Make sure the box says "XL" to ensure you get the extra characters and refined gameplay.
- Invite Friends: This game is 100% better as a "beer and pizza" couch co-op experience than a solo endeavor. The jank becomes part of the fun when you're laughing at it with friends.
- Explore the Vault: Spend time in the in-game gallery. The unlockable clips and trivia are a great trip down memory lane for anyone who grew up with the network.
The game isn't going to win any "Best of All Time" awards, but as a piece of Cartoon Network memorabilia, it is indispensable. It represents a transition point in TV history and a bold, if slightly messy, attempt to bring the Smash Bros. formula to the masses. Give it a shot, embrace the glitches, and enjoy the chaos.