If you spent any time on East Carson Street between 2005 and 2023, you know the vibe. Carson City Saloon Pittsburgh PA wasn't just another bar; it was a three-story monster of a sports bar that defined "South Side nightlife." You’d walk into that massive 1896 German Savings Deposit Bank building and immediately get hit with a wall of noise, Penn State cheers, and the smell of wings. Honestly, it was the kind of place where you either had the best night of your life or a massive headache the next morning.
But things changed. If you’re looking for it today, you might be a little confused.
The reality is that Carson City Saloon—at least the version owned by the Vetere family for nearly two decades—is gone. It didn’t just fade away, either. It closed, reopened, struggled with the changing safety landscape of the South Side, and eventually transformed into something else entirely.
The Rise and Fall of a South Side Landmark
Let's look at the history for a second. The building at 1401 East Carson Street is a beast. It’s got those high ceilings and that classic stone architecture that makes you feel like you're drinking in a fortress. Brian Vetere, along with his brother and father, turned it into a premier destination.
For years, it was the spot.
They had a rooftop deck that looked over the Monongahela River. It wasn't the "skyline view" you get from Mount Washington, but it was breezy and perfect for a Saturday afternoon beer. On game days, the place was packed floor-to-ceiling with Steelers and Pens fans. It was high-energy. It was loud. Basically, it was everything the South Side was known for before things got complicated.
📖 Related: Double Sided Ribbon Satin: Why the Pro Crafters Always Reach for the Good Stuff
Then came July 2023.
The owners made national headlines when they decided to shutter the doors. It wasn't because business was bad—though the "chaos" on the streets was definitely scaring people off. It was a safety protest. After a string of shootings and rising crime in the 1300 and 1400 blocks of East Carson, Vetere basically said "enough is enough." He didn't want his staff walking to their cars at 2:00 AM fearing for their lives.
They did reopen in September 2023 after the city stepped up patrols, but the spark was kinda flickering. By late 2023, the original Carson City Saloon officially closed its chapter.
What Is It Now? Meet Capo's
If you walk past 1401 East Carson Street right now, you won't see the old Saloon signs. You'll see Capo's.
New owners took over the space around December 2023. For a while, there was some confusion because they kept the "Carson City Saloon" name on some paperwork and social media, which actually led to some minor issues with the health department regarding name updates. But today, it’s Capo's.
👉 See also: Dining room layout ideas that actually work for real life
It still hits a lot of those same notes:
- The Rooftop: The deck is still there, and it's still one of the best places to catch some sun on a Saturday.
- The Food: They still do the "pub grub" thing well. We’re talking spicy garlic parmesan wings and burgers that are surprisingly solid for a party bar.
- The Fishbowls: This is a South Side staple that didn't die. They serve these massive cocktails—the Blue Smurf and the Orange Sunrise—that are meant for sharing (or a very long night).
Honestly, the vibe is still very much "sports and party." They have a giant projector in the middle of the room and screens everywhere. If you're looking to watch a big game, the layout of that old bank building still works perfectly for it.
Why the South Side Landscape Shifted
You can't talk about Carson City Saloon Pittsburgh PA without talking about the neighborhood's identity crisis. For decades, the South Side was the "Great White Way" of bars. It had more liquor licenses per square inch than almost anywhere else in the country.
But as old-school spots like Carson City Saloon or even the nearby Hello Bistro started closing or changing hands, it signaled a shift. People started moving toward the North Shore or Lawrenceville for their weekend fix.
The Vetere family moving on was a big deal. They were "legacy" owners. When the people who helped build the scene decide to leave, it tells you a lot about the current state of things. That said, the new management at Capo's is trying to keep that high-energy tradition alive while dealing with the new reality of South Side security and city ordinances.
✨ Don't miss: Different Kinds of Dreads: What Your Stylist Probably Won't Tell You
What to Expect If You Go Today
If you're heading down there thinking it’s still the 2015 version of Carson City Saloon, just adjust your expectations slightly.
The service is generally decent, but like any South Side bar, it gets "distracted" when it's slammed on a Saturday night. Expect a cover charge if there's a DJ or a big event. Expect a security check at the door—the area is much more controlled now with police blockades and restricted parking on weekend nights to keep things from getting too wild.
The menu at Capo's leans heavily into the wings. People swear by the Lemon Pepper and Carolina Gold flavors. Prices are a bit higher than they used to be—$8 for a domestic bottle is pretty standard now—but that’s just inflation and the "South Side tax" at work.
Actionable Tips for Visiting East Carson Street
If you’re planning a night out at 1401 East Carson (Capo's) or any of the surrounding spots, keep these things in mind:
- Check the Name: Don't look for the "Carson City" sign. Look for Capo's. It's the same massive building, just different branding.
- Rooftop Early: If it’s a nice day, the rooftop fills up fast. They don't have a "view" of the skyline, but it’s great for people-watching and getting away from the loud music inside.
- Parking is a Nightmare: Pittsburgh has implemented a lot of parking restrictions on the South Side to curb the "cruising" issues. Use a ride-share or park several blocks away in the residential areas (where permitted) and walk.
- Try the Fishbowls: If you're with a group, the Blue Smurf is the classic experience. Just drink plenty of water.
- Game Days: It is still a premier spot for Steelers games. If you want a table near the projector, get there at least 90 minutes before kickoff.
The era of the original Carson City Saloon Pittsburgh PA might be over, but the building is still standing, and the party hasn't totally stopped. It's just evolving. Whether you're a regular from the old days or a newcomer checking out the South Side for the first time, 1401 East Carson is still the anchor of the neighborhood.
For the most up-to-date hours, check their social media, as they frequently close on Mondays and Tuesdays or shift hours based on the season. If you're looking for that specific "Vetere-owned" experience, you'll have to look at their newer ventures in other parts of the city, but for a loud, wing-filled Saturday in the South Side, the old Saloon building still delivers.