The NFC South is usually a mess, but the 2025 season finale took "divisional chaos" to a whole new level. Honestly, if you blinked during the final two weeks of the season, you probably missed the most bizarre power shift in the rivalry's history. For years, the Tampa Bay Buccaneers owned the Carolina Panthers. They had this five-game winning streak that felt like it would never end, including a 48-14 blowout back in late 2024 that was just painful to watch. But things changed.
Basically, the script flipped right when it mattered most.
The Week 18 matchup at Raymond James Stadium on January 3, 2026, wasn't just another game. It was a "winner-stays-alive" scenario that felt like playoff football in everything but name. The Panthers came into Tampa with an 8-8 record, needing a win to clinch their first division title since 2015. The Bucs, sitting at 7-9 and riding a brutal four-game losing streak, were desperate. They needed a win and some help from the Falcons to keep their five-year reign over the South intact.
The Quarterback Duel: Bryce Young vs. Baker Mayfield
You've got to look at the numbers to see how close this really was. People love to bash Bryce Young, but his third year in the league showed some serious grit. Heading into that final stretch, he had 23 touchdowns and only 11 interceptions. Compare that to Baker Mayfield, who put up 26 touchdowns and 11 picks. They were almost identical on paper.
In their Week 16 meeting—just 13 days before the finale—Young actually outplayed Mayfield. He threw for 191 yards and two scores, leading the Panthers to a 23-20 win that snapped Baker’s personal 5-0 record against Carolina. It was a massive statement. Young has this weird knack for game-winning drives; 12 of his 14 career wins at that point had come in the fourth quarter or overtime.
Tampa's offense, meanwhile, was leaning heavily on the ground game. Bucky Irving and Rachaad White were doing the heavy lifting because the passing attack was, well, kinda shaky. In that Week 16 loss, Mayfield only threw for 145 yards. You aren't going to win many games in the modern NFL with those numbers unless your defense is pitching a shutout.
💡 You might also like: Why Isn't Mbappe Playing Today: The Real Madrid Crisis Explained
Why the Week 18 Result Still Stings for Tampa
The final score on January 3 was 16-14 in favor of the Buccaneers. On the surface, a win is a win, right? Wrong.
Even though Chase McLaughlin nailed those field goals and Mayfield found Cade Otton for an 18-yard score early on, the victory ended up being hollow. Because the Falcons lost to the Saints the following day, the division title didn't go to Tampa. Instead, it triggered a three-way tiebreaker at 8-9.
Here is the part that most people get wrong about the tiebreaker rules. Usually, you look at divisional record or common games. But because the Panthers had swept the Falcons earlier in the season, they held the tiebreaker in a three-way tie scenario. So, despite losing the actual game to the Bucs in Week 18, the Carolina Panthers were the ones celebrating the NFC South championship.
It was surreal. The Bucs won the battle but lost the war because of how the math shook out.
Defensive Standouts and Rookie Impact
Both teams were dealing with some serious injury baggage by the time January rolled around. The Panthers lost their star rookie tight end Ja'Tavion Sanders to a season-ending ankle injury right before the game. That's a huge blow when you're trying to build rhythm with a young QB.
📖 Related: Tottenham vs FC Barcelona: Why This Matchup Still Matters in 2026
On the flip side, the Bucs' defense was led by the legendary Lavonte David. The guy is a machine. During that Week 18 game, he was chasing the franchise tackle record held by Derrick Brooks. He finished the season with over 100 tackles again. It's wild how consistent he is.
- Lathan Ransom: The rookie safety for the Panthers who basically saved their season in Week 16 with a sliding interception against Mayfield.
- Tetairoa McMillan: Carolina's wideout who became Bryce Young's favorite target, especially on deep balls which was a huge weakness for them in 2024.
- Jacob Parrish: A bright spot for Tampa's secondary, grabbing a massive pick against Young in the finale to keep the game within reach.
The Rivalry Shift
Carolina actually leads the all-time series 27-25 now. It’s one of the most balanced rivalries in the NFL, even if it doesn't get the national media love that the Cowboys or Eagles do.
The 2025 season proved that the "post-Tom Brady" era in the South is wide open. For a while, it looked like Tampa would just cruise with Mayfield, but the Panthers’ investment in the offensive line—bringing in guys like Robert Hunt and Damien Lewis—finally started to pay off. They protected Young better, giving him a 63.6% completion rate for the season.
Tampa Bay's biggest issue was their "bend-but-dont-break" defense eventually just breaking. They were ranked 26th against the pass. If you're giving up 236 yards a game through the air, you're asking for trouble, especially against a division rival that plays you twice a year and knows your schemes inside out.
Actionable Insights for the 2026 Season
If you're a fan or a bettor looking at this matchup moving forward, keep these three things in mind.
👉 See also: Buddy Hield Sacramento Kings: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
First, watch the turnover margin. In the last three meetings between these teams, the winner was the team that won the turnover battle. It sounds like a cliché, but with these two, it’s a law. Mayfield's tendency to force balls into tight windows against Carolina's zone coverage has been his undoing.
Second, the Panthers’ "alternating" pattern is real. In the back half of 2025, they literally alternated wins and losses for ten straight weeks. It’s a sign of an inconsistent team that plays up or down to its competition.
Third, pay attention to the trenches. When Carolina can run the ball with Rico Dowdle and Chuba Hubbard, Bryce Young becomes a different player. If the Bucs can't improve their 21st-ranked rush offense, they'll continue to put too much pressure on Mayfield's shoulder.
The NFC South crown is currently in Charlotte, but given how thin the margins were in those 16-14 and 23-20 games, the 2026 series is anyone's guess. Start by tracking the health of the Panthers' secondary and the Bucs' aging linebacker core during the upcoming preseason.