The story of Carly, Tyler, and Catelynn isn't just a reality TV plotline. It is a fifteen-year saga that basically redefined how a generation of viewers understands open adoption. If you’ve followed Teen Mom since the early days of 16 and Pregnant in 2009, you remember the gut-wrenching scene of two teenagers, Tyler Baltierra and Catelynn Lowell, handing their newborn daughter over to her adoptive parents, Brandon and Teresa Davis.
It was supposed to be "open." But lately? It’s been anything but.
The situation has gotten incredibly messy. We aren’t just talking about a few missed phone calls. We are talking about blocked numbers, public call-outs, and a growing divide between biological and adoptive parents that has fans taking sides like it’s a championship game. Honestly, the nuance here is what most people miss when they're just scrolling through Instagram.
What’s Actually Happening with Carly’s Parents Right Now?
To understand why the search for "Carly, Tyler, and Catelynn’s daughter" is spiking, you have to look at the recent fallout. In early 2025, Catelynn confirmed a heartbreaking reality: they are blocked. Brandon and Teresa, the people raising Carly (who is now sixteen), have effectively shut down direct communication.
Why? It’s a classic case of boundary crossing meeting a desire for privacy.
For years, Brandon and Teresa have stayed off-camera. They don’t want the fame. They don't want the "Teen Mom" spotlight. But Tyler and Catelynn’s lives are the spotlight. This fundamental clash peaked when Catelynn began posting her frustrations on social media, claiming she was being "ignored for months." In the world of adoption, "venting" to millions of followers is often seen as a massive breach of trust.
🔗 Read more: Ethan Slater and Frankie Grande: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
The Breaking Point
The drama hit a fever pitch when it was revealed that Tyler and Catelynn had allegedly been in contact with a minor who claimed to be a friend of Carly’s. Tyler defended this as "desperation," a way to know if their daughter was okay when her parents wouldn't answer. To Brandon and Teresa, it likely felt like a terrifying intrusion into their daughter’s private life.
Then there was the blanket.
Catelynn sent Carly a personalized blanket featuring photos of her and her biological sisters—Novalee, Vaeda, and Rya. While intended as a sweet gift, critics (and reportedly the adoptive parents) felt it was "inappropriate" because it pushed a "sister" narrative that Carly might not be ready for, or that complicates her relationship with her adoptive brother, Graham.
The Reality of the "Open" Adoption Agreement
Most people think an open adoption is a legally binding contract for visitation. It’s not. In Michigan, where the adoption was processed, these agreements are usually more of a "gentleman’s agreement." They rely entirely on mutual respect.
- Legality: Adoptive parents have 100% of the legal rights. They can close the door at any time if they believe it’s in the child's best interest.
- The Mediator: Dawn Baker, the original adoption counselor, has been stuck in the middle for over a decade. In late 2024, she famously advised Tyler and Catelynn to "take a pause" and stop sending gifts.
- The Future: Now that Carly is sixteen, the clock is ticking toward her eighteenth birthday. At that point, the "gatekeeping" ends, and Carly gets to decide for herself if she wants a relationship with the Baltierras.
Why Fans are Torn (and Why it Matters)
You’ve probably seen the Reddit threads. They are brutal. On one side, you have people who feel for Tyler and Catelynn. They were kids who made a brave choice under immense pressure from their own dysfunctional parents (looking at you, April and Butch). They’ve stayed together—a rarity in the franchise—and have built a stable life with their three other daughters.
💡 You might also like: Leonardo DiCaprio Met Gala: What Really Happened with His Secret Debut
On the flip side, there is a very vocal group that says, "You gave her up. You don't get to be the parent now." They argue that by constantly talking about Carly on TV, Tyler and Catelynn are exploiting her story for a paycheck, making it impossible for her to have a normal, private adolescence.
It’s a complicated grey area. Adoption trauma is real, and it doesn't just go away because you have more kids later. Tyler recently admitted he has "adoption regrets," which is a massive admission after years of being the poster couple for "the right choice."
What Most People Get Wrong About the Other Daughters
A huge part of the "Carly Tyler and Caitlin" search involves their other kids. Some fans get confused, thinking Carly is still in their home or that she lives with her sisters.
The couple has three "rainbow babies" and younger daughters:
- Novalee Reign: Born in 2015. She’s the one most aware of Carly, often seen on the show asking when she can see her big sister.
- Vaeda Luma: Born in 2019.
- Rya Rose: Born in 2021.
Catelynn and Tyler have been very open with these girls about Carly. They want them to know they have a sister out there. But some child psychologists argue that putting that emotional weight on the younger kids—who then cry because they can’t see a sibling they barely know—might be doing more harm than good.
📖 Related: Mia Khalifa New Sex Research: Why Everyone Is Still Obsessed With Her 2014 Career
The Actionable Truth: Lessons from the Baltierra Story
Whether you’re an adoptee, a birth parent, or just a fan, there are real-world takeaways from this messy situation.
First, boundaries are everything. In any open adoption, the adoptive parents' comfort level dictates the pace. If you push too hard, the door usually slams shut.
Second, social media is a minefield. Using a public platform to pressure someone into communication almost always backfires. It creates a "hostage" dynamic where the other party feels forced to comply, which isn't the foundation of a healthy relationship.
Finally, wait for the child. Carly is a person, not a plot point. As she enters her late teens, her voice is the only one that will eventually matter. Tyler and Catelynn have started an email account for her, writing messages she can read when she’s ready. This is probably their smartest move yet—it moves the conversation from the public eye to a private digital space where Carly can find them on her own terms.
What to Watch for Next
Keep an eye on the upcoming seasons of Teen Mom: The Next Chapter. While the cameras can't film Carly, they definitely film the fallout. The "adoption file" Tyler recently mentioned receiving is supposedly full of "shocking" details that might explain why the relationship soured so quickly.
If you are following this story, the best thing you can do is look past the headlines and realize that at the center of this is a teenage girl just trying to navigate high school while her birth parents are famous for giving her away. It’s a heavy burden to carry.
Next Steps for You:
If you're interested in the ethics of open adoption, research the difference between "fully open," "semi-open," and "closed" adoptions in your specific state. You can also follow the Adoptee Rights Law Center for updates on how legislation is changing regarding birth record access for children like Carly once they hit adulthood.