Honestly, if you ask any die-hard Bravo fan about Season 4 of the Real Housewives of Beverly Hills, they usually shudder. It was the "dark season." The vibes were off. And right at the center of that swirling vortex of chaos was Carlton Gebbia. She wasn't just a housewife; she was the self-proclaimed Wiccan who lived in a Gothic "sex castle" and seemingly spent her entire tenure trying to hex Kyle Richards' computer.
It's been years since she vanished from our screens. One season. That's all she got. But even now, in 2026, people still talk about her like she’s a local legend—or a cautionary tale.
The Carlton Gebbia RHOBH Experience: Why It Went South
The problem wasn't just the Wicca. Beverly Hills has seen plenty of "woo-woo" behavior. We’ve had psychics, medium readings, and crystals. But Carlton was different. She was aggressive about it. From the second she stepped onto the screen, she had a target on Kyle’s back. Remember the bee incident? Kyle—who is notoriously terrified of bees—wanted one killed. Carlton reacted like it was a personal hit on a family member.
It was awkward. It was forced. You’ve probably seen the clip where she gets offended because Kyle asks if her pentagram tattoo is a Star of David. To be fair, Kyle was being... well, Kyle. But Carlton’s reaction was so over-the-top that it made viewers uncomfortable. She wasn't playing the game of "fancy lunches and light shade." She was playing "I might actually be trying to destroy your life with a candle and some sage."
Why she was actually fired
Bravo usually keeps the "villains" around for at least two seasons to see if they can redeem themselves. Not Carlton. She and Joyce Giraud were both axed after a single year.
💡 You might also like: Songs by Tyler Childers: What Most People Get Wrong
Andy Cohen eventually admitted that production sort of failed Carlton. In his view, she was actually a great mom and a "PTA mom" in real life, but the editors leaned so hard into the "spooky witch" narrative that she became a one-dimensional caricature. She didn't have any real, deep-rooted friendships with the other women besides a brief, trauma-bonded alliance with Lisa Vanderpump. When you don't have friends on this show, you don't have a job.
Life After the Show: Divorce and Scandals
If you thought her time on RHOBH was dramatic, her life after the cameras stopped rolling was a total whirlwind. For years, she and her husband David Gebbia seemed like the "perfectly weird" couple. They had those three kids with the incredible names—Destiny, Mysteri, and Cross. They had the 15,000-square-foot Gothic mansion that looked like a vampire’s vacation home.
Then it all fell apart.
David filed for divorce in 2017 after 20 years of marriage. It wasn't one of those "we're still best friends" Hollywood divorces at first. There were rumors. There were reports of Carlton being hospitalized after a night of heavy drinking.
📖 Related: Questions From Black Card Revoked: The Culture Test That Might Just Get You Roasted
And then came the lawsuit.
A former housekeeper sued Carlton, alleging physical and emotional abuse. The claims were pretty wild—allegations of being pushed, slapped, and Carlton being under the influence frequently. Carlton denied it all, claiming the housekeeper was just bitter over a jewelry dispute. Regardless of the truth, it was a messy, public exit from the high-society life she'd portrayed on TV.
Where is Carlton Gebbia in 2026?
She basically went underground. She sold that massive Gothic house—the one featured on Million Dollar Listing—for nearly $14 million. She moved to Florida for a while. She stayed off the grid.
But here is the thing: she’s still a practicing Wiccan. She didn't drop the persona when the cameras left. If you check out her social media today, she's still posting about the moon, her rituals, and her kids. She’s surprisingly low-key now.
👉 See also: The Reality of Sex Movies From Africa: Censorship, Nollywood, and the Digital Underground
The Lisa Vanderpump Connection
People always ask if she’s still friends with LVP. Surprisingly, Lisa hasn't totally closed the door on her. In recent years, Lisa even mentioned that she’d give Carlton a second chance because she enjoyed her "wicked" sense of humor. In a world where everyone is trying to be a "relatable influencer," Carlton was authentically, aggressively herself. Even if that self was a bit much for Tuesday night television.
Real Talk: Was She a Good Housewife?
- The Pros: She was rich. Truly rich. Her house was a character on its own. She wasn't afraid of the OGs.
- The Cons: She was too "one-note." The feud with Kyle felt manufactured from day one. She lacked the "fun" element that makes a villain likable.
Actionable Insights for the Bravo Obsessed
If you're looking to revisit the Carlton era or just curious about how she fits into the RHOBH lore, here is the move:
- Rewatch Season 4 with fresh eyes. Focus on the background details of her house. It’s an interior design fever dream.
- Check out her jewelry line. She spent years designing pieces that reflect her "Gothic-chic" aesthetic. It’s actually pretty high-quality if you’re into that look.
- Follow the "Vanderpump" trail. Since Carlton was one of the few who stood by Lisa during the "Puppygate" precursors, her old blog posts on the Bravo site actually provide a lot of context for why the group dynamics shifted so heavily against LVP later on.
Carlton was a flash in the pan, but she left a scorched-earth trail behind her. She proved that even in Beverly Hills, there’s such a thing as being "too much" for TV. Whether she was a misunderstood spiritualist or just a reality TV misfire, she remains one of the most polarizing figures to ever hold a diamond.