If you’ve been scrolling through Reddit or TikTok lately, you’ve probably seen the name Carlo popping up in some pretty heated threads. He isn’t your typical 90 Day Fiancé lead who’s just trying to figure out a visa. Honestly, the guy became a total wrecking ball on the spin-off 90 Day: Hunt for Love.
He’s basically the human equivalent of a "skip" button, yet we can't stop watching. Why? Because the self-destruction was so unhinged that it actually felt real for once. No fake scripts needed when someone is this messy.
Who Exactly is Carlo on 90 Day Fiance?
Let’s get the basics down. Carlo appeared on the 2025 series 90 Day: Hunt for Love. This isn't the show where they’re already engaged; it’s more like a chaotic retreat where singles from the franchise—and some new faces—try to find a match.
Carlo, a 38-year-old who somehow carries the energy of a 19-year-old frat boy who just discovered hair gel, quickly became the season’s "villain" (though "cringe lord" is probably more accurate).
He was caught in a triangle between two women: Tiffany and Elise.
✨ Don't miss: Temuera Morrison as Boba Fett: Why Fans Are Still Divided Over the Daimyo of Tatooine
Most guys would try to be smooth. Not Carlo. He managed to lie to both of them, talk trash behind their backs, and then act shocked when the "receipts" came out at the Tell All. It was painful. It was awkward. It was peak TLC.
The Infamous "Mud Date" and the Downfall
One of the moments that really cemented his legacy was the "mud date." You’d think a romantic outing involving mud would be, I don't know, earthy? Instead, it was just a stage for Carlo to fumble his way through basic human interaction.
He didn't just mess up the date; he went on to attack other cast members, like Jay, for seemingly no reason other than insecurity.
Why the Tell All was a Bloodbath
If you missed the Hunt for Love Tell All, you missed one of the most embarrassing moments in the entire 90 Day universe. Usually, the "villains" like Big Ed or Angela Deem at least try to defend themselves with loud shouting.
🔗 Read more: Why Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy Actors Still Define the Modern Spy Thriller
Carlo? He just sat there while Cole (another cast member) dropped the hammer.
- The Rumors: Cole claimed Carlo called Tiffany "fat and ugly" behind her back.
- The Double Play: He was telling Elise he wanted her while simultaneously trying to lock things down with Tiffany.
- The Walk-off: It got so bad—with literal screenshots and text receipts—that Carlo actually had to walk off the stage.
He couldn't handle the reckoning. Honestly, seeing him get "annihilated" (as the fans put it) was the closure we all needed after watching him manipulate his way through the season.
Is He Still With Elise?
Short answer: Kinda looks like a big no.
While they seemed to have a "connection" on screen, the "Between the Sheets" episodes told a different story. Elise seemed super bitter whenever his name came up.
💡 You might also like: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
There were even rumors that Carlo texted Tiffany the morning after leaving the retreat and then immediately blocked her. Classy, right? That's the Carlo 90 Day Fiance experience in a nutshell. High drama, zero accountability, and a trail of blocked numbers.
What Most People Get Wrong About Carlo
People keep comparing him to past villains, but there’s a nuance here. Unlike some cast members who are clearly "playing a character" for fame, Carlo seemed genuinely incapable of regulating his emotions.
On Reddit, fans have debated whether he's just a "fame-seeking freak" or if we actually witnessed a real-time mid-life crisis. He’s been compared to Mr. Spicoli from Fast Times at Ridgemont High because of the way he talks and his constant "sunburnt" look, but Spicoli was at least likable. Carlo is more like the guy who refuses to leave the party when the lights come on.
The Takeaway: Reality TV Ethics
Watching Carlo 90 Day Fiance reminds us why we watch these shows. We want to see people who make us feel better about our own lives.
If you're feeling like you've messed up a relationship or said the wrong thing, just go back and watch the Carlo Tell All. You’ll feel like a saint in comparison.
Next Steps for 90 Day Fans:
If you want to see the full meltdown, look for the 90 Day: Hunt for Love Season 1 Tell All. It's currently streaming on Max and Discovery+. Pay close attention to the background reactions of the other cast members—their faces honestly tell a better story than the actual dialogue. Also, keep an eye on Tiffany’s social media; she’s been way more open about the "real" Carlo since the cameras stopped rolling.