Everything changed in the Vatican faster than anyone expected. If you’ve been following the news lately, you know the atmosphere in Rome has shifted from the long, sometimes polarized era of Francis to the early, defining days of Pope Leo XIV. It’s wild how quickly the "papabile" lists—those rosters of cardinals in line to be pope—get tossed out the window the moment the white smoke actually goes up.
People love to speculate. They treat it like a political horse race. But the College of Cardinals isn't exactly like a parliament, and the guys who look like frontrunners often end up as the ones holding the hats for the guy nobody saw coming.
Honestly, the 2025 conclave proved that the "who’s next" game is mostly about timing and temperament.
The Cardinals in line to be pope: A new landscape
Now that Leo XIV is in the chair, the conversation has moved. We aren't just looking for "the next guy" anymore; we’re looking at who is being positioned to carry the weight if this pontificate is a short one. You've got guys like Cardinal Pietro Parolin and Cardinal Luis Antonio Tagle who were the titans of the last cycle. They’re still around, but their roles have evolved.
Parolin is basically the ultimate diplomat. He’s the Vatican’s Secretary of State, and while some thought his time had passed, he remains a "safe pair of hands" for a Church that sometimes feels like it’s vibrating with too much change. He’s 71 now. In Vatican years, that’s actually kind of prime time.
🔗 Read more: Johnny Somali AI Deepfake: What Really Happened in South Korea
Then there’s Tagle. They call him the "Asian Francis." He’s charismatic, he’s got a great social media presence, and he’s currently the Pro-Prefect for the Dicastery for Evangelization. If the Church wants to keep leaning into the "Global South," he’s the obvious choice. But being the obvious choice is often a curse in a conclave. There's an old Roman saying: "He who enters the conclave a pope, leaves it a cardinal."
The "Street Priest" and the Quiet Power Players
You can't talk about cardinals in line to be pope without mentioning Matteo Zuppi. The guy is the Archbishop of Bologna and has deep ties to the Community of Sant’Egidio. He’s known for being a "street priest"—the kind of guy who actually goes out and talks to people instead of just sitting in a gilded office.
He’s been a peace envoy in some of the messiest conflicts on the planet, including Ukraine. That kind of real-world experience carries a lot of weight when the doors of the Sistine Chapel finally lock.
- Cardinal Mario Grech: The Maltese powerhouse. He’s been the engine behind the Synod on Synodality. If the cardinals want to keep the "listening" style of the Church alive, he’s a huge contender.
- Cardinal Fridolin Ambongo Besungo: From the Democratic Republic of Congo. He represents the massive growth of Catholicism in Africa. He’s outspoken, he’s brave, and he’s not afraid to challenge the status quo.
- Cardinal Péter Erdő: The conservative favorite from Hungary. If the Pendulum swings back toward tradition and canon law, Erdő is usually the name at the top of the list.
Why the "Frontrunner" usually loses
Conclaves are weird. It’s a room full of roughly 120-140 men (depending on who has turned 80 that month) who are all trying to figure out the "vibe" of the Holy Spirit.
💡 You might also like: Sweden School Shooting 2025: What Really Happened at Campus Risbergska
Usually, the first few ballots are just "ego votes." Cardinals vote for their friends or their local heroes. Then, the real drama starts. If a candidate doesn't get momentum quickly, the group starts looking for a compromise. That’s how we get "surprise" popes.
It’s about alliances. It’s about who can bridge the gap between the Europeans and the Americans, or the progressives and the traditionalists.
Take Cardinal Pierbattista Pizzaballa, the Latin Patriarch of Jerusalem. He’s an Italian, but he’s lived in the Middle East for decades. He speaks Hebrew, he knows the complexities of the Holy Land, and he’s managed to stay respected by almost everyone. He’s the kind of "dark horse" that makes the experts look silly when the ballots start counting.
The Age Factor
Age is everything. If the previous papacy was long and exhausting, the cardinals might look for an "interim" pope—someone in their late 70s who will provide a few years of stability without launching any massive new revolutions.
📖 Related: Will Palestine Ever Be Free: What Most People Get Wrong
But if they feel the Church is stalling, they might go for a "young" guy in his early 60s. That’s a 20-year commitment. That’s a terrifying thought for some of these electors.
What actually happens next?
If you're trying to track the cardinals in line to be pope for your own knowledge or just to win a bet with your history-buff uncle, keep your eye on the "Consistories." These are the meetings where the Pope creates new cardinals.
The more guys a Pope appoints from the "peripheries"—places like Mongolia, India, or remote parts of Brazil—the more he’s stacking the deck for a successor who shares his vision.
Next Steps for the Curious:
- Watch the Appointments: Every time the Vatican announces new cardinals, look at where they are from. If they aren't from Rome or Paris, the Church is signaling a shift toward the global majority.
- Follow the Dicasteries: The heads of the major Vatican offices (like Tagle or Grech) are essentially the "Cabinet" of the Pope. Their performance in these roles is their audition for the top job.
- Ignore the Bookies: Betting on the Pope is a long tradition in Rome, but the bookmakers are almost always wrong. They favor fame over "curial influence."
- Check the 80-year-old Rule: Cardinals lose their right to vote the moment they turn 80. In 2026, several key electors will "age out," which changes the math of the next election significantly.
The papacy is one of the world's last true mysteries. While we can analyze the data and look at the resumes of these cardinals, the actual decision happens in a room with no phones, no internet, and a whole lot of history. Keeping an eye on these names isn't just about politics; it’s about watching where the largest religious institution on Earth is heading next.