It is finally happening. After 16 years of being the most recognizable face of American Catholicism, Cardinal Timothy Dolan is stepping down. If you've walked past St. Patrick’s Cathedral lately, you’ve probably felt the shift in the air. The "Happy Warrior" is hanging up the miter, and for a lot of New Yorkers—Catholic or not—it feels like the end of an era.
This isn't just a routine retirement.
In the world of the Church, everything is slow until it’s suddenly very fast. Dolan turned 75 in February 2025. According to Canon Law, that’s the magic number when bishops have to send a "please let me retire" letter to the Pope. Usually, these letters sit on a desk in Rome for years. But Pope Leo XIV didn’t wait. He accepted it in December 2025, and now, in early 2026, we are watching the actual handoff to Bishop Ronald Hicks.
Who is the new Cardinal of New York City (well, Archbishop for now)?
Technically, the title of cardinal of New York City isn't an automatic hand-me-down. You don't just inherit the red hat. Ronald Hicks is currently the Archbishop-designate. He’s coming in from Joliet, Illinois, and honestly, he’s a bit of a curveball compared to Dolan’s boisterous, "hail fellow well met" Missouri charm.
Hicks is 58. He’s young for this job. He spent years as a missionary in El Salvador and speaks fluent Spanish, which is a massive deal for an archdiocese where the pews are increasingly filled by Latino families.
📖 Related: The Battle of the Chesapeake: Why Washington Should Have Lost
If Dolan was the guy you wanted to grab a beer with at an Al Smith dinner, Hicks seems like the guy who’s going to be in the trenches. He’s already talked about wanting to be a "bridge builder." He’s stepping into a messy situation, though. New York isn't the Catholic powerhouse it was in the 1950s. It’s a city of 2.8 million Catholics, sure, but the infrastructure is creaking.
The Dolan Legacy: More Than Just Jokes
You can’t talk about the cardinal of New York City without looking at what Timothy Dolan actually did. People loved his laugh. They loved his "The Catholic Channel" radio show. But behind the folksy sermons about Stan Musial and the St. Louis Cardinals, he was making some brutal calls.
- The Real Estate Fire Sale: Under Dolan, the Archdiocese basically stopped being a real estate empire. They sold the big office building on First Avenue for nearly $500 million. They merged dozens of parishes. It wasn't popular, but he argued it was necessary to keep the lights on.
- The Abuse Crisis Settlements: This is the heavy stuff. Just before retiring, Dolan announced a $300 million fund to settle claims with over 1,300 survivors of clergy abuse. He pushed for mediation rather than endless court battles. Whether it’s "enough" is a debate that will follow him into retirement, but he moved the needle on transparency more than his predecessors did.
- The Political Combat: He wasn't shy. From fighting the Obama administration over contraception mandates to being a "lone voice" for the NYPD during the 2020 protests, he leaned into the culture wars.
Honestly, he was a media pro. He knew how to use a microphone. But as the Church moves toward 2026, the Vatican seems to want a different vibe—less "political commentator," more "pastoral missionary."
What Most People Get Wrong About the Transition
There’s this idea that Hicks is just a "mini-Francis" or a "Leo XIV clone." It’s a bit more complicated than that. While it’s true that Pope Leo XIV—who was the former Cardinal Robert Prevost of Chicago—tapped a fellow Illinois guy, the job of the cardinal of New York City is unique.
👉 See also: Texas Flash Floods: What Really Happens When a Summer Camp Underwater Becomes the Story
New York is a different beast.
The Archbishop here has to be a diplomat. They have to deal with City Hall, the UN, and a press corpse that is notoriously unforgiving. Hicks is inherited a "global settlement" process with abuse survivors that is still in mediation as of January 2026. He’s also dealing with a priest shortage that saw numbers drop from nearly 1,800 when Dolan started to around 1,200 today.
Basically, the "business" of being a Cardinal is getting harder.
Life After the Red Hat
So, where does Dolan go? He’s not moving back to St. Louis. He’s staying in Manhattan. He’ll be living in a local parish, which is kind of a funny thought—imagine the Cardinal showing up to hear your Saturday afternoon confession.
✨ Don't miss: Teamsters Union Jimmy Hoffa: What Most People Get Wrong
He’s said he wants to keep teaching and writing. He’s even had offers to do a documentary on the American Church. He’s "Cardinal Archbishop Emeritus" now. He still gets to vote in a papal conclave until he turns 80, so he’s not out of the game. He just doesn’t have to worry about the $500 million budget deficits anymore.
Why This Shift Matters for 2026
The installation of Archbishop Hicks on February 6, 2026, marks a hard pivot. We are moving away from the era of the "Prince of the Church" style of leadership.
The new guy has already been spotted celebrating Mass for inmates and focusing on the poor. In a city where the cost of living is driving out the middle class and the migrant crisis is straining every social service, a Spanish-speaking, missionary-minded leader is a tactical choice by the Vatican.
Actionable Insights for New York Catholics (and the Curious)
If you’re wondering how this affects you or your local parish, keep an eye on these three things over the next few months:
- Parish Consolidations: Hicks has hinted at a "missionary" focus. This likely means more resources for under-served immigrant communities and potentially more closures of historic, under-attended churches in Lower Manhattan.
- The Alfred E. Smith Dinner: This is the big test. It’s the event where the cardinal of New York City hosts presidential candidates. Watch how Hicks handles the 2026 political cycle. Will he be as jovial as Dolan, or more reserved?
- Social Outreach: Expect a surge in Church involvement with the migrant centers and local poverty initiatives. Hicks isn't just a "stay in the office" kind of leader.
The transition is officially underway. Whether you agreed with Dolan’s politics or not, you can’t deny he was a giant in the city’s landscape. Hicks has big shoes to fill, but he’s bringing a different set of tools to the job. It’s a new chapter for St. Patrick’s, and for New York, that’s always a story worth following.
For those interested in the official transition details, the Archdiocese of New York website and The Good Newsroom (their official news outlet) are the best places for the actual installation schedule and public Mass times.