The smoke above the Sistine Chapel is always white or black, but the politics behind it? That’s a million shades of gray. Honestly, trying to guess who the next leader of the 1.3 billion Catholics will be is a bit like betting on the weather in a month's time—everyone has a theory, and almost everyone ends up being wrong.
You’ve likely heard the old Roman proverb: "He who enters the conclave a Pope, leaves it a Cardinal." It's a reminder that being the front-runner is often a curse.
In early 2026, the Vatican remains a hive of quiet intensity. With Pope Francis having passed away in April 2025 and the election of Cardinal Robert Prevost as Pope Leo XIV, the Church entered a brand-new era. Prevost’s election was a shock to many—the first American to ever sit on the Chair of Peter. But even as a new papacy begins, the cycle of "papabile" (those considered "pope-material") never really stops. The Church thinks in centuries, not news cycles.
The Men Who Define the Future
When we look at the candidates for new pope, we aren't just looking at names. We are looking at ideologies. The College of Cardinals is currently a reflection of a globalized Church. It’s less Eurocentric than it’s ever been in history.
Take Cardinal Pietro Parolin. He’s 70, Italian, and spent years as the Vatican’s Secretary of State. Basically, he’s the ultimate diplomat. Many see him as the "safety" pick—someone who knows where the bodies are buried but has the grace to never mention it. He’s a bridge-builder. If the Church feels it has moved too fast or too slow, Parolin is the man who can steady the ship without capsizing it.
💡 You might also like: Why the 2013 Moore Oklahoma Tornado Changed Everything We Knew About Survival
Then there is Cardinal Luis Antonio Tagle from the Philippines.
People call him the "Asian Francis." He’s 67, which in "Vatican years" is actually pretty young. Tagle is famous for his emotional intelligence. He cries with the poor. He’s tech-savvy. But he carries the weight of some administrative hiccups from his time at Caritas Internationalis. Some cardinals worry he’s a great pastor but a "meh" manager.
The Geography of Hope
It is a bit wild that we haven't had a contemporary African pope yet. The growth of the Church in Africa is explosive.
- Cardinal Fridolin Ambongo Besungu (DRC): He’s 65 and isn't afraid of a fight. He’s been a loud voice against corruption in the Congo.
- Cardinal Peter Turkson (Ghana): At 76, he’s a veteran. He understands the Curia (the Vatican’s bureaucracy) but remains deeply connected to social justice and climate change issues.
- Cardinal Robert Sarah (Guinea): The hero of the traditionalists. Sarah is 80 now, which technically puts him at the age limit for voting, but his influence is massive. He’s the "anti-Francis" in many ways, favoring silence, liturgy, and strict adherence to tradition.
Why the "Front-Runner" Usually Fails
The reason the candidates for new pope list is so volatile is the two-thirds majority rule. You don't just need a "win." You need a landslide.
📖 Related: Ethics in the News: What Most People Get Wrong
Imagine trying to get 120+ men from every continent, culture, and language to agree on one person. It’s a nightmare. This is why "compromise candidates" like Cardinal Péter Erdő from Hungary often gain steam. Erdő is 72, a canon lawyer, and remarkably disciplined. He’s conservative enough for the traditionalists but respected enough for his intellect by the progressives. He’s the guy you pick when you can’t agree on the superstar.
Then you have Cardinal Matteo Zuppi of Bologna. He’s 69. If you want "Francis 2.0," Zuppi is your guy. He’s a "street priest" who still rides a bike around his diocese. He was a peace envoy for the war in Ukraine. But being too close to the previous Pope can sometimes be a liability. Cardinals often look for a "corrective" to the last guy, even if they liked him.
The American Factor: Leo XIV and Beyond
The election of Robert Prevost (Pope Leo XIV) changed the math. For decades, the rule was "No Americans." The fear was that the Holy See would become an annex of the U.S. State Department. But Prevost, despite being born in Chicago, spent decades in Peru. He was a "dual-citizen" candidate in more ways than one.
His election proved that the old taboos are dead. Now, people are looking at Cardinal Robert Francis Prevost's legacy before it has even fully formed. Will he appoint more Americans? Will he lean into the managerial style of the West, or the pastoral style of the South?
👉 See also: When is the Next Hurricane Coming 2024: What Most People Get Wrong
What Most People Get Wrong
The biggest misconception is that the Conclave is like a political convention. It’s not. There are no speeches. There are no posters. There is a lot of "casual" whispering during coffee breaks.
Cardinals look for three things:
- Holiness: Does this guy actually believe what he’s preaching?
- Language: Can he speak Italian? (Essential for running Rome).
- Backbone: Can he stand up to the world without being a jerk about it?
Honestly, the "dark horse" is usually the one who wins. Someone like Cardinal Pierbattista Pizzaballa, the Latin Patriarch of Jerusalem. He’s 60. He lives in a war zone. He’s shown incredible courage. That kind of "boots on the ground" experience carries a lot of weight when the doors of the Sistine Chapel finally click shut.
Actionable Insights for Following the Papacy
If you want to track the future of the Church without getting lost in the weeds, watch the Consistories. These are the meetings where the Pope creates new cardinals.
- Watch the age brackets: Cardinals lose their vote at 80. If a lot of "liberal" cardinals are turning 80, the balance of power shifts right.
- Look at the peripheries: Pope Francis (and now Leo XIV) favored bishops from places like Tonga, Mongolia, and the Amazon. These men don't care about European "culture wars." They care about survival, migration, and poverty.
- Check the "Papal Name": The name a candidate chooses (like Leo, Francis, or John) tells you exactly what kind of Pope they intend to be.
The search for candidates for new pope is never really over because the Papacy is the world's oldest elective monarchy. It is a slow, grinding process of evolution. To understand where it’s going, don't look at the headlines—look at the men standing in the back of the room during the next big Vatican Mass. That’s where the next Pope is usually hiding.