You’ve probably been there. You reach into the dark corner of the pantry, grab a russet for tonight's mash, and realize it’s starting to look like a science project. Those little white or green nubs—the "eyes"—are staring back at you. It’s a common kitchen dilemma that sparks a lot of internal debate. Is it trash? Or can you just hack it off and keep going?
Honestly, the short answer is no, you shouldn't eat them. But that doesn't mean the whole potato is a lost cause.
The eyes are where the potato is trying to grow a new plant. They’re concentrated hubs of energy and, more importantly, high concentrations of glycoalkaloids. Specifically, we're talking about solanine and chaconine. These aren't just "bitter flavors." They are actual defense mechanisms the plant uses to stop insects and fungi from eating it. If you eat enough of them, they’ll do a number on your digestive system.
The Chemistry Behind Why You Can’t Eat Potato Eyes
Potatoes are part of the nightshade family, Solanaceae. This family includes tomatoes and eggplants, but it also includes deadly nightshade. While a grocery store potato isn't going to kill you under normal circumstances, it carries the family genes for toxicity.
When a potato starts to sprout, it’s signaling that it's moving out of its "dormant" phase. It wants to grow. To protect those vulnerable new sprouts, the plant sends a massive surge of solanine to the eyes. According to research from the National Capital Poison Center, solanine is found throughout the potato but is most concentrated in the skin, the sprouts, and the eyes.
It’s a dose-dependent toxin.
🔗 Read more: Marie Kondo The Life Changing Magic of Tidying Up: What Most People Get Wrong
A few eyes won't send you to the ER, but they can definitely cause a nasty bout of "potato poisoning." Symptoms usually kick in about 8 to 12 hours after eating. You’re looking at stomach cramps, nausea, diarrhea, and in some cases, a scratchy throat or a headache. Most people just assume they have a 24-hour bug, but it’s often the sprouted hash browns from breakfast.
Why Green Means Trouble
You’ll often notice that the area around the eyes turns green. That green isn't the solanine itself—it's chlorophyll. Chlorophyll is harmless. However, the same light exposure that triggers chlorophyll production also triggers solanine production. Think of the green color as a warning light on your dashboard. If the eye is sprouting and the skin around it is green, the toxin levels are peaking.
Can You Save the Potato?
I’m a big fan of not wasting food. If every slightly sprouted potato went in the bin, we’d be throwing away tons of perfectly good starch.
If the potato is still firm, you can save it.
Basically, you take a paring knife or the little metal loop on the side of a vegetable peeler and dig those eyes out. You need to be aggressive. Don't just skim the surface; gouge out the eye and a small radius of the flesh around it. If the rest of the potato is hard to the touch and the skin isn't shriveled, it’s fine to eat.
💡 You might also like: Why Transparent Plus Size Models Are Changing How We Actually Shop
But—and this is a big "but"—if the potato has gone soft or wrinkled, the starch has been converted into sugars to feed those sprouts. The texture will be mealy, the taste will be weirdly sweet and bitter, and the solanine has likely migrated deeper into the tuber. At that point, toss it. Or better yet, plant it in the garden.
Cooking Doesn't Kill the Toxin
This is a major misconception. People think, "Oh, I'll just boil it or fry it, and the heat will kill the poison."
Nope.
Solanine is incredibly heat-stable. It doesn't break down at standard cooking temperatures. Boiling potatoes can actually be worse because it doesn't neutralize the toxin; it just stays in the flesh. Deep frying at very high temperatures ($170°C$ or $338°F$) might reduce glycoalkaloid levels slightly, but not enough to make a toxic potato safe.
Real-World Risks and Expert Opinions
Dr. Margaret S. Smith, a plant breeding expert at Cornell University, has often pointed out that while modern commercial potatoes are bred to have low glycoalkaloid levels, storage conditions change everything. If potatoes are left under bright grocery store lights or in a warm kitchen, those levels spike.
📖 Related: Weather Forecast Calumet MI: What Most People Get Wrong About Keweenaw Winters
There have been historical cases of mass poisonings. One of the most cited in toxological literature occurred in 1979 in South London, where 78 schoolboys fell ill after eating potatoes that had been stored improperly over the summer. They suffered from vomiting, fever, and even some neurological symptoms like confusion. This is rare, but it highlights that potato eyes aren't just a culinary nuisance.
Identifying "The Point of No Return"
How do you know when to walk away?
- Sprouts longer than an inch: The potato has spent too much energy; the toxin spread is likely.
- Bitter taste: If you take a bite and it tastes "off" or leaves a burning sensation on your tongue, spit it out. That's the solanine talking.
- Softness: If you can squeeze the potato and it feels like a stress ball, it's done.
- Widespread greening: If more than 10% of the skin is green, it's safer to discard it than to try and peel it all away.
Storing Your Spuds Properly
If you want to stop the eyes from growing in the first place, stop putting them in the fridge. Cold temperatures actually turn potato starch into sugar, which makes them turn brown and sweet when fried (and can lead to higher levels of acrylamide, a whole different issue).
Instead, find a cool, dark, dry place. A basement or a low pantry shelf is perfect. And keep them away from onions. Onions release ethylene gas, which acts like a biological "go" signal for potatoes to start sprouting their eyes.
I usually keep mine in a breathable burlap bag or a cardboard box. Plastic bags are the enemy because they trap moisture, which leads to rot and faster sprouting.
Practical Steps for Your Kitchen
Next time you're prepping dinner and you see those eyes, follow this workflow:
- The Squeeze Test: Give the potato a firm squeeze. If it’s mushy, it’s compost.
- The Surgical Strike: Use the tip of your peeler to dig out the eye entirely. If the flesh underneath is white and crisp, you’re golden.
- Peel Deep: If there was greening around the eye, peel that section extra deep. Don't be stingy.
- Rinse: Give the peeled potatoes a good wash to remove any residual surface solanine.
- Observe the Flavor: If the cooked dish has a bitter aftertaste, stop eating. It’s not worth the stomach ache.
Potato eyes are a natural part of the plant's life cycle, but they don't belong on your plate. By being a bit ruthless with your paring knife and smart about your storage, you can avoid the toxins while saving your grocery budget. Just remember: when in doubt, cut it out. If the potato looks like it’s trying to walk away on its own "legs," let it go.