You're twelve hours into a fast. Your stomach is starting to make those weird whale noises, and you’re staring at a carton of beef bone broth in the fridge like it’s a five-course meal. But then the panic sets in. Will those few sips ruin everything? Does can you drink bone broth while fasting even have a straight answer, or is it one of those "it depends" situations that fitness influencers love to argue about?
Honestly, it really is a bit of both.
If you ask a strict purist who only drinks distilled water and breathes filtered air, they'll tell you that even looking at bone broth is a sin. But if you’re fasting for weight loss or just trying to survive a 24-hour shift without fainting, the answer changes. We need to look at what's actually happening in your cells.
What Happens to Your Body When You Sip Broth
Fasting isn't just one thing. It's a spectrum. Most people are doing it for one of three reasons: metabolic health (weight loss), autophagy (cellular cleanup), or gut rest.
When you consume bone broth, you're taking in protein—specifically collagen—and a tiny bit of fat. This triggers your digestive system. If your goal is 100% total gut rest, then yeah, bone broth breaks your fast. Your pancreas and stomach have to wake up to process those amino acids.
However, if you're fasting for insulin sensitivity, bone broth is kinda like a cheat code. It contains almost zero carbohydrates. Because there's no sugar, your insulin levels stay incredibly low. Dr. Jason Fung, a nephrologist and a huge name in the intermittent fasting world, often mentions that bone broth is a great tool for beginners. It provides electrolytes like magnesium and potassium that keep the "keto flu" at bay. It keeps you hydrated. It keeps you sane.
The Autophagy Argument
This is where things get sticky. Autophagy is that fancy word for your body recycling old, damaged cell parts. It’s triggered by nutrient deprivation. Specifically, a protein called mTOR needs to be suppressed for autophagy to really ramp up.
Since bone broth is basically liquid protein, it contains amino acids like leucine and glycine. These can signal to mTOR that food has arrived. Does a cup of broth completely shut off autophagy? Probably not entirely, but it likely turns the volume down. If you're fasting specifically to maximize cellular repair for a medical condition, you might want to stick to water. But for the average person? A little broth isn't going to undo all your hard work.
Breaking Down the Calories
Let's talk numbers, but keep it simple. Most bone broths have about 30 to 50 calories per cup.
💡 You might also like: Can DayQuil Be Taken At Night: What Happens If You Skip NyQuil
Some "experts" claim that anything under 50 calories won't break a fast. That’s a bit of a myth, honestly. There isn't a magical calorie sensor in your stomach that stays asleep until calorie 51 hits the lining. Your body responds to nutrients, not just the "amount" of energy.
That said, the metabolic impact of 40 calories of protein is vastly different from 40 calories of apple juice. The juice spikes insulin. The broth doesn't.
If you're wondering can you drink bone broth while fasting for weight loss, the answer is a resounding yes. It helps you fast longer. If drinking a cup of warm, salty broth at 4:00 PM prevents you from face-planting into a pizza at 6:00 PM, then the broth is a massive win. You're still in a massive caloric deficit. You're still burning fat.
Sodium: The Unsung Hero of the Fast
People forget that fasting makes you pee. A lot.
When insulin levels drop, your kidneys start dumping sodium. This is why people get headaches, dizzy, or shaky during a fast. It's usually not hunger; it's electrolyte depletion.
Bone broth is a natural saline solution. It’s packed with the stuff your brain needs to function. Instead of popping expensive electrolyte pills, a mug of well-salted broth can make you feel human again within minutes.
- Beef Broth: Usually higher in minerals and has a deeper flavor.
- Chicken Broth: Often lighter and easier on a sensitive stomach.
- Fish Bone Broth: Great for iodine, but... let’s be real, the smell is a lot to handle when you’re hungry.
The Gut Health Factor
Some people fast specifically to heal "leaky gut" or manage IBD. For these folks, bone broth is actually a therapeutic addition. The collagen and gelatin in the broth help "seal" the gut lining.
In this context, we aren't even worried about whether the fast is technically "broken." We're using the fasted state to allow the broth to coat the digestive tract without competition from other foods. It’s a strategy often used in the GAPS diet or by practitioners like Dr. Josh Axe.
📖 Related: Nuts Are Keto Friendly (Usually), But These 3 Mistakes Will Kick You Out Of Ketosis
How to Choose the Right Broth
Don't go buy that cheap "beef flavored" stock cube from the bottom shelf. That's not bone broth; that's a salt lick with yellow dye #5.
True bone broth is simmered for 12 to 24 hours. This long cook time breaks down the bones and connective tissue, releasing the marrow and collagen. You want the stuff that turns into jelly when it’s cold. If it’s liquid at fridge temperature, it’s probably just watered-down stock.
Look for:
- Organic/Grass-fed bones: Toxins are often stored in the fat and marrow of animals. You don't want to concentrate those.
- Minimal ingredients: Just bones, water, maybe some apple cider vinegar (which helps pull the minerals out), and salt.
- No added sugar: You'd be surprised how many commercial brands sneak cane sugar into savory broth. Avoid that like the plague.
Real World Scenarios
Let's look at Dave. Dave is doing a 16:8 fast. He eats from noon to 8 PM. If Dave drinks bone broth at 10 AM, he has technically broken his fast two hours early. Is he going to gain weight? No. Is his insulin going to skyrocket? No. He's fine.
Then there's Sarah. Sarah is doing a 3-day water fast for deep autophagy because she has an autoimmune flare-up. If Sarah drinks bone broth, she might be blunting the specific cellular process she’s trying to achieve. For her, it might be a "no."
It’s all about your "why."
Common Misconceptions About Broth and Fasting
A lot of people think bone broth is a "free food." It's not. It still has calories. If you drink two quarts of it throughout the day, you're consuming 400 calories and a significant amount of protein. At that point, you aren't fasting; you're on a liquid diet.
There's a big difference between a "bridge" and a "meal." Use broth as a bridge to get you to your next eating window. Don't use it as a crutch to avoid the actual discipline of fasting.
👉 See also: That Time a Doctor With Measles Treating Kids Sparked a Massive Health Crisis
Practical Steps for Using Bone Broth While Fasting
If you've decided to incorporate bone broth, here is how to do it without messing up your progress.
First, wait until you're actually struggling. Don't just drink it because it's "time." Use it as a tool when the hunger pangs become a distraction or when you feel a headache coming on.
Second, keep the portion to about 8-12 ounces. That's enough to provide the minerals and the "full" feeling without flooding your system with too many amino acids.
Third, make it yourself if you can. Throw some leftover marrow bones in a slow cooker with a splash of vinegar and leave it alone for a day. It's cheaper and way more nutrient-dense than the boxed stuff.
Finally, listen to your body. If drinking broth makes you even hungrier (which happens to some people because it triggers digestive enzymes), then stop. Some people find that any taste of food makes the "hunger hormone" ghrelin spike, making the fast harder, not easier.
The Verdict
So, can you drink bone broth while fasting?
Yes, if your goal is weight loss, metabolic health, or gut healing. It's a fantastic tool that makes fasting sustainable for the long haul.
No, if you are a purist chasing the absolute maximum levels of autophagy or if you are preparing for a medical procedure that requires a strictly clear liquid (water-only) fast.
For 95% of people reading this, bone broth is a "yes." It’s a bridge that helps you reach your goals without feeling like a miserable, starving zombie.
What to do next
- Identify your goal: Are you fasting for weight loss or deep cellular repair?
- Check your pantry: Look at the labels on your broth. If there's yeast extract, sugar, or "natural flavors," toss it.
- Start small: Try a half-cup next time you feel like quitting your fast early.
- Monitor your results: Notice if the broth makes you feel energized or if it makes you crave a sandwich. Your body's data is better than any article.
- Stay hydrated: Even with broth, you still need plenty of plain water.
Fasting shouldn't be a form of torture. It's a tool for health. If a little bit of salty, savory broth helps you stay on track and feel better, then use it. The best fasting protocol is the one you can actually stick to. High-quality bone broth provides the essential minerals and amino acids that keep your electrolytes balanced and your hunger managed, allowing you to extend your fasting window further than you might with water alone. Focus on the quality of the bones and the simplicity of the ingredients to ensure you're getting the most benefit with the least amount of metabolic interference.