You've probably seen the petitions. Maybe you’ve even signed one. There's a certain energy that builds up when a sitting president does something—or many things—that half the country absolutely detests. The internet starts buzzing, hashtags trend, and everyone starts asking the same question: can the people of the united states impeach a president directly?
Honestly, the short answer is no. But the real answer is a lot more interesting and kind of messy.
In the U.S., you can’t just gather a million signatures on a Change.org link and boot the Commander-in-Chief out of the Oval Office. We don't have a national "recall" system for the presidency like some states have for their governors. If we did, the history of the last few decades would look wildly different. Instead, we have a rigid, slow-moving process that the Founding Fathers built to be intentionally difficult.
Who actually holds the power?
The Constitution is pretty blunt about this. Article I gives the "sole Power of Impeachment" to the House of Representatives. That’s it. Not the people, not the Supreme Court, and definitely not a popular vote.
Think of the House as the prosecutor. They decide if there's enough evidence to bring charges. If a simple majority (that’s 50% plus one) votes "yes" on even one Article of Impeachment, the president is officially impeached. But here is where it gets confusing: being "impeached" doesn't mean you're fired. It just means you've been formally charged.
Once that happens, the whole thing moves across the hall to the Senate. This is the trial phase. The Chief Justice of the Supreme Court shows up to preside, and the Senators act as the jury. To actually remove a president from office, you need a two-thirds majority in the Senate. That is a massive mountain to climb. In the entire history of the United States, it has never actually happened. Andrew Johnson, Bill Clinton, and Donald Trump were all impeached by the House, but the Senate acquitted every single one of them.
Why the "people" feel left out
It feels weird, right? We live in a democracy, yet we can’t fire the person at the top.
💡 You might also like: 39 Carl St and Kevin Lau: What Actually Happened at the Cole Valley Property
Basically, the guys who wrote the Constitution were terrified of what they called "the tyranny of the majority." They didn't want a president to be kicked out just because they became unpopular for a few months or because a passionate crowd got angry. They wanted the process to be handled by elected representatives who—in theory—would weigh the evidence more soberly than a fired-up electorate.
Does this mean the people have zero power? Not exactly.
While you can’t cast a ballot to impeach, you can make life miserable for the representatives who won't. This is where those petitions and town halls actually matter. If a congressperson thinks they’ll lose their seat in the next election because they refused to impeach an unpopular president, they might suddenly find some "constitutional courage." We saw this during the Nixon era. Richard Nixon wasn't actually impeached; he resigned because his own party told him the "people" (and therefore the votes) had turned against him so hard that conviction was inevitable.
High crimes and misdemeanors (The big mystery)
One of the reasons can the people of the united states impeach a president is such a common search is because the rules are so vague. The Constitution says a president can be removed for "Treason, Bribery, or other high Crimes and Misdemeanors."
What does "high Crimes and Misdemeanors" actually mean?
Whatever Congress says it means.
📖 Related: Effingham County Jail Bookings 72 Hours: What Really Happened
It’s not just about breaking a law you’d find in a dusty legal textbook. It’s about an abuse of power. A president could technically do something completely legal—like refusing to defend the country or pardoning all their friends for every crime imaginable—and still be impeached because it violates the "public trust."
Gerald Ford, before he became president, famously said: "An impeachable offense is whatever a majority of the House of Representatives considers it to be at a given moment in history."
The myth of the "popular impeachment"
You might hear people talk about "impeachment by petition." It’s a myth.
There is no legal mechanism where a certain number of signatures triggers an automatic impeachment. However, there is a tiny, obscure rule in the House Manual (the Jefferson’s Manual) that suggests "memorials" or petitions from a state legislature or even a "grand jury" can be a way to initiate proceedings.
But even then, a member of the House still has to pick it up and turn it into a resolution. The people can provide the fuel, but Congress owns the car and the keys.
Why it almost never works
It’s a math problem, mostly.
👉 See also: Joseph Stalin Political Party: What Most People Get Wrong
Because you need two-thirds of the Senate to convict, you almost always need members of the president's own party to turn on them. In our current political climate, that’s like asking a cat to bark. Everything is so polarized that "high crimes" to one side look like "political persecution" to the other.
Since 1789, the House has initiated impeachment proceedings over 60 times. Most of those were against federal judges. Only 21 times has someone actually been impeached. And out of those? Only eight people—all of them federal judges—were actually convicted and removed.
What can you actually do?
If you’re convinced a president needs to go, waiting for an impeachment that might never come is a recipe for a headache.
- Pressure the gatekeepers. Your Representative is the only person who can actually cast that first vote. Letters, calls, and showing up at their office in the home district carries way more weight than an anonymous online signature.
- Focus on the midterms. If the House is controlled by the president's party, impeachment is usually dead on arrival. If you want a president checked, you have to change the makeup of Congress.
- State-level action. While you can't impeach a president from your living room, some states allow for resolutions that "call upon" Congress to act. It's symbolic, but symbols create political pressure.
Impeachment is a "break glass in case of emergency" tool. It wasn't designed to be easy, and it definitely wasn't designed to be fast. The people's role isn't to be the judge or the jury, but to be the alarm system that tells Congress the building is on fire.
If you want to see change, the most effective tool isn't a petition for impeachment—it's the ballot box in the next election. That is the only time the "people" truly get to act as the jury.
Next steps for you:
Look up your specific House Representative using your zip code on the official House.gov website. Check their public stance on oversight and any current articles of impeachment that have been filed. Understanding where your specific "gatekeeper" stands is the first step in moving from a spectator to an active participant in the constitutional process.