You’re sitting on the rug, scratching that perfect spot behind your Golden Retriever's ears, and suddenly it happens. The jaw drops. The tongue lolls out. The corners of the mouth turn upward in a way that looks undeniably like a human grin. You take a photo, post it on Instagram with a "look at this happy boy" caption, and go about your day feeling like you’ve truly bonded. But then that nagging voice in the back of your head asks: can dogs really smile, or are we just seeing what we want to see?
It’s complicated.
Honestly, if you ask a room full of veterinary behaviorists, you're going to get a mix of "yes," "sort of," and "it’s actually a submissive gesture." For a long time, the scientific community dismissed the idea of canine smiling as pure anthropomorphism. That’s just a fancy way of saying we project human emotions onto non-human things. We see a face in a grilled cheese sandwich; we see a smile on a Bulldog. But recent research into canine cognition suggests that the connection between a dog's facial muscles and their internal state is much deeper than a simple trick of the light.
The Evolutionary "Grin"
Dogs are masters of manipulation. I mean that in the best way possible. Over roughly 30,000 years of domestication, they’ve evolved specifically to communicate with us. Think about "puppy dog eyes." A study led by Dr. Juliane Kaminski at the University of Portsmouth found that dogs possess a specific muscle—the levator anguli oculi medialis—which allows them to raise their inner eyebrows. Wolves don't have this. It’s a muscle that exists almost entirely to make dogs look more vulnerable and infant-like to humans.
The smile is a similar evolutionary adaptation.
When we talk about whether can dogs really smile, we have to look at the "submissive grin." In the wild, a wolf showing its teeth is usually a threat. It’s a warning to back off. However, dogs have flipped the script. Many dogs use a "smile" to show they aren't a threat. It’s a way of saying, "Hey, I’m friendly! Please don't hurt me, and maybe give me a treat?"
Nobel Prize-winning ethologist Konrad Lorenz described this in his book Man Meets Dog. He noted that dogs often "laugh" when playing, involving a slightly open jaw and a specific rhythmic panting. It’s not a human laugh, but the physiological function is nearly identical. They are signaling joy and a lack of aggression.
👉 See also: Sleeping With Your Neighbor: Why It Is More Complicated Than You Think
The Science of Neoteny
Dogs are basically permanent teenagers. This is known as neoteny—the retention of juvenile traits into adulthood. Because they rely on us for food and shelter, they stay in a "subordinate" mindset compared to their wild ancestors. This social dynamic creates the perfect environment for "smiling" to develop.
If a dog curls their lip slightly and the owner immediately squeals, "Oh my god, he’s smiling!" and gives them a piece of chicken, guess what? That dog is going to do it again. It becomes an operant conditioning loop. The dog learns that a specific facial expression triggers a positive dopamine hit from their human. Is it a "real" smile born of spontaneous joy, or a learned behavior to get snacks?
Does it even matter? If the result is a happy dog and a happy human, the "authenticity" of the muscle movement is almost a moot point.
Deciphering the "Doggie Laugh"
If you want to know if your dog is truly "smiling," you have to listen. Patricia Simonet at Sierra Nevada College conducted a fascinating study where she recorded the sounds dogs make during play. She found a specific frequency of panting—a "forced, breathy exhale"—that differed from standard cooling-down pants.
When she played these recordings back to dogs in a shelter, their stress levels plummeted. They started playing. They wagged their tails. This "dog laugh" is often accompanied by the facial expression we interpret as a smile. It’s a full-body experience.
Look at the Eyes, Not Just the Mouth
A "fake" smile in humans is easy to spot because it doesn't reach the eyes. Dogs are the same. If a dog’s mouth is pulled back into a grin but their eyes are hard, staring, or showing the "whale eye" (white parts showing), that isn't a smile. That’s a dog who is incredibly stressed and might be about to snap.
✨ Don't miss: At Home French Manicure: Why Yours Looks Cheap and How to Fix It
True happiness in a dog is "soft."
Soft eyes.
Wiggly body.
A tail that isn't just wagging, but is making the whole back half of the dog vibrate.
The Difference Between a Smile and a Snarl
This is where things get dangerous. Misinterpreting a dog's facial cues is a leading cause of dog bites, especially with children. You’ve probably seen videos online of a dog "smiling" while someone hugs them. The dog looks like they’re grinning, but their ears are pinned back, they’re licking their lips, and they look stiff.
That is NOT a smile.
In the world of animal behavior, this is often a "bared-teeth submissive grin." It looks remarkably like a human smile, but it’s actually a sign of extreme anxiety. The dog is trying to appease the human because they feel threatened or uncomfortable. If you see this, stop what you’re doing. Give the dog space.
Can dogs really smile in a way that signals aggression? Technically, no. A snarl is different. A snarl involves vertical retraction of the lips—showing the front canines—and is usually accompanied by a low growl and a wrinkled nose. A smile or submissive grin is more horizontal. The corners of the mouth go back toward the ears.
Breed Specific Grinners
Not all dogs are created equal when it comes to facial expressions. If you own a Samoyed, you’re looking at the "Sammy Smile" every single day. Their mouths are naturally upturned to prevent drool from freezing into icicles on their faces (an evolutionary trait from their Siberian roots).
🔗 Read more: Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen Menu: Why You’re Probably Ordering Wrong
Staffordshire Bull Terriers and Pit Bulls are also famous for their wide, gummy grins. Because of their wide jaw structure, when they relax their mouths, it naturally forms a shape that looks exactly like a human beam. On the other hand, breeds with lots of facial wrinkles, like Bloodhounds or Shar-Peis, might be ecstatic, but you’d never know it by looking at their mouths. Their "smile" might just be a slightly less intense frown.
Case Study: The "Smiling" Greyhound
Greyhounds and other sighthounds often perform what's called a "nitter." They chatter their teeth and pull their lips back when they're excited to see you. To an outsider, it looks like the dog is baring its teeth. To a Greyhound owner, it’s the ultimate compliment. It’s a literal vibration of joy.
Why We Want Them to Smile
There is a psychological phenomenon called the "biophilia hypothesis." It suggests that humans have an innate tendency to seek connections with nature and other forms of life. When we see a dog "smile," our brains release oxytocin—the "cuddle hormone."
We want to believe they are smiling because it validates our relationship with them. It makes the bond feel reciprocal. And while science tells us that dogs don't have the exact same emotional architecture as humans, they do have the same brain structures for processing emotions. They feel joy. They feel fear. They feel attachment.
So, while their "smile" might be a mix of evolutionary mimicry, learned behavior for treats, and submissive signaling, the underlying emotion—contentment—is very real.
How to Tell if Your Dog is Genuinely Happy
If you're still wondering can dogs really smile or if your specific dog is happy, stop looking at the mouth for a second. Check these markers instead:
- The Sleeping Tongue: When a dog is truly relaxed, their jaw muscles loosen so much that the tongue just flops out.
- The "Play Bow": This is the universal canine signal for "everything I’m doing right now is a joke, let's have fun."
- Leaning: A happy, confident dog will often lean their weight against your legs. It’s a "scent-sharing" hug.
- Blinking: Hard stares are aggressive. Slow, soft blinking is a sign of trust and affection.
Actionable Steps for Dog Owners
Understanding your dog's "smile" is about more than just cute photos; it's about being a better guardian for them.
- Audit your "smiling" photos. Go back through your camera roll. Look at the dog's ears and eyes in the photos where they are "smiling." If the ears are tucked back and the eyes look worried, you might have been stressing your dog out for the sake of a "cute" picture.
- Reward the right things. If your dog gives a submissive grin because they are scared (like when you come home to a chewed-up shoe), don't laugh or coo at them. This reinforces their fear. Instead, remain calm and neutral.
- Learn the "Calming Signals." Read up on Turid Rugaas’s work on canine calming signals. It will change how you view your dog's "smile" forever. You'll start seeing lip licks, yawns, and head turns as the complex vocabulary they actually are.
- Watch the tail base. A wagging tail doesn't always mean happy. A tail wagging to the right usually indicates positive feelings, while a wag to the left can indicate negative ones (due to brain hemispheric dominance).
Dogs might not smile for the same reasons we do—they don't find a joke funny or appreciate irony—but they use their faces to bridge the gap between two different species. Whether it's a learned trick or a genuine expression of bliss, a dog's "smile" is a testament to the weird, wonderful, and ancient bond we share. If your dog looks happy, and their body language is loose and wiggly, go ahead and believe the grin. They probably are.