You’ve probably been told a lie. Or, at the very least, a half-truth that your high school algebra teacher used to keep things simple. Most students walk away from pre-calculus believing that an asymptote is a "brick wall." They think it’s a line that a curve approaches but never, ever touches.
It’s wrong.
In reality, a function crossing horizontal asymptote is not only possible; it happens all the time in complex engineering and physics. Vertical asymptotes are the ones that are usually "off-limits" because they represent values where the function literally breaks (like dividing by zero). But horizontal asymptotes? They just describe the "end behavior" of a graph. They tell you where the function is headed when $x$ gets obscenely large or small. What the function does in the "middle" of the graph—the local behavior—is fair game. It can dance across that line as much as it wants.
Why We Get It Wrong
We love simple rules. "Asymptotes are lines you can't touch" is a great soundbite. It helps kids pass a Chapter 3 test on rational functions. But it creates a massive mental block later on.
A horizontal asymptote is a limit. Specifically, it’s the value of $L$ such that:
$$\lim_{x \to \infty} f(x) = L \quad \text{or} \quad \lim_{x \to -\infty} f(x) = L$$
Basically, the horizontal asymptote is the "retirement home" for the function. It’s where the function goes to settle down after all the drama of the origin is over. If the function crosses the line at $x = 2$, the limit at infinity doesn't care. The limit only cares about what happens as $x$ approaches a billion. Or ten trillion.
The Classic Example: Sinc Functions and Damped Waves
If you want to see a function crossing horizontal asymptote over and over again, look at a damped sine wave. This is real-world math. Think about a shock absorber on a car. Or a plucked guitar string.
When you hit a bump, the car’s suspension oscillates. It bounces up and down. Eventually, it settles back to its original height. That original height is the horizontal asymptote (usually $y = 0$). As the car settles, it passes through that equilibrium point multiple times. It crosses its asymptote. It’s not breaking any laws of mathematics; it’s just obeying the physics of energy dissipation.
Mathematically, a function like $f(x) = \frac{\sin(x)}{x}$ is the perfect culprit. As $x$ grows, the fraction gets smaller and smaller because the denominator is pulling it toward zero. But the numerator—that $\sin(x)$—keeps flipping between positive and negative. It crosses $y = 0$ every $\pi$ units. Infinitely many times.
Solving for the Intersection Point
How do you actually prove it? Honestly, it’s just basic algebra. People overcomplicate this because they’re intimidated by the word "asymptote."
If you have a rational function like $f(x) = \frac{2x^2 - 4x}{x^2 + 1}$, the horizontal asymptote is $y = 2$. You find that by looking at the leading coefficients. To see if the function crossing horizontal asymptote occurs, you just set the function equal to the asymptote.
$2 = \frac{2x^2 - 4x}{x^2 + 1}$
Multiply both sides by the denominator:
$2(x^2 + 1) = 2x^2 - 4x$
$2x^2 + 2 = 2x^2 - 4x$
✨ Don't miss: Why transparent hair on screen still drives digital artists crazy
The $2x^2$ terms cancel out. You’re left with $2 = -4x$. Solve for $x$, and you get $x = -0.5$.
Boom. The graph crosses its horizontal asymptote at exactly $(-0.5, 2)$. If you were to graph this on Desmos, you’d see the curve dip right through the dotted line and then slowly sneak back up toward it from underneath as it heads toward infinity. It’s a very common behavior for rational functions where the degree of the numerator and denominator are equal.
The Logic of End Behavior
Think of a horizontal asymptote like a shoreline. A swimmer can dive under the water, jump above it, and cross the "surface" (the asymptote) while they are near the beach. But as they swim miles out into the ocean, they might eventually just float right at the surface level.
Standard textbooks from authors like James Stewart (the gold standard for Calculus) emphasize that the definition of a limit at infinity allows for this. The function $f(x)$ just needs to get "arbitrarily close" to the value $L$. It doesn't say it has to stay on one side.
Why Vertical Asymptotes are Different
You’ll almost never see a function cross a vertical asymptote. Why? Because vertical asymptotes usually happen at $x$-values that are excluded from the domain. If $f(x) = \frac{1}{x-3}$, the value $x=3$ makes the denominator zero. The function doesn't exist there. It's a hole in the universe. You can't cross a bridge that isn't built.
But for horizontal lines, we are talking about $y$-values. Most functions are perfectly happy to output a $y$-value that happens to be the same as their long-term limit.
Real-World Applications
In electrical engineering, this happens in "underdamped" systems. If you’re designing a control system—say, the cruise control on a Tesla—you want the car to reach the target speed. Sometimes, the software "overshoots" the speed (crosses the asymptote) before correcting and settling down.
If the car is set to 70 mph, and it hits 71, then 69.5, and finally stabilizes at 70, it has crossed its horizontal asymptote twice.
Data scientists see this too when fitting curves to noisy data. A logistic regression or a specialized neural network might produce a curve that oscillates around a carrying capacity.
Common Misconceptions to Ditch
- "It only crosses once." Nope. As we saw with the $\frac{\sin(x)}{x}$ example, it can cross infinite times.
- "Rational functions can't do it." They absolutely can. If the degrees match or the denominator's degree is higher, crossing is frequent.
- "It means the asymptote is wrong." If you find a crossing point, it doesn't mean you calculated the asymptote incorrectly. It just means the function is interesting.
Actionable Steps for Students and Pros
If you're working on a problem and need to identify if a function crossing horizontal asymptote is happening, follow this workflow:
- Find the asymptote first. Check the degrees. If the bottom is heavier, it’s $y = 0$. If they are equal, it’s the ratio of leading coefficients.
- Set $f(x) = L$. Take your actual function and set it equal to that horizontal line value.
- Solve for $x$. Use algebra to find the intersection. If the $x$ terms all cancel out and you get a false statement (like $5 = 0$), it doesn't cross. If you get a specific $x$ value, that's your crossing point.
- Verify with a graph. Use a tool like Desmos or a TI-84. Zoom in near the origin. Usually, the "crossing" happens for small values of $x$, while the "approaching" happens for large values of $x$.
- Check the "End Behavior." Always remember that the asymptote describes what happens when $x \to \infty$. Anything happening near $x = 0$ is "local behavior" and doesn't change the asymptote’s validity.
Understanding this distinction is what separates someone who just memorizes steps from someone who actually understands how mathematical models work. Don't let the "brick wall" myth limit your understanding of how curves move.