It is a mess. If you live in California and own a firearm, or are thinking about buying one, you’ve probably spent way too much time trying to figure out if a CA large capacity magazine is something you can actually own without getting a knock on the door from the DOJ. One week a judge says the ban is unconstitutional. The next week, an appeals court puts a stay on that ruling. Then there’s "Freedom Week," a brief blip in time that feels like a fever dream for California gun owners.
Honestly, the legal landscape for magazines in the Golden State changes faster than the weather in San Francisco.
Basically, California law defines a "large capacity magazine" as any ammunition feeding device with the capacity to accept more than 10 rounds. This isn't just about those "banana clips" you see in movies. It applies to everything: belt-fed strips, drums, and even those standard 15-round magazines that come in the box with a Glock 19 in 49 other states. If it holds 11 rounds, California calls it "large capacity."
The Legal Rollercoaster of Penal Code 32310
You've probably heard of Duncan v. Bonta. It is the big one. This court case has been bouncing through the legal system like a pinball for years. It all started when a group of plaintiffs, backed by the California Rifle & Pistol Association (CRPA), challenged California Penal Code section 32310. That’s the specific law that bans the manufacture, importation, sale, and even the possession of magazines holding more than 10 rounds.
For a long time, you could keep magazines you owned before 2000. They were "grandfathered" in. Then, California voters passed Proposition 63 in 2016, which tried to strip that protection away and make possession of those old magazines a crime too.
Then came Judge Roger Benitez.
In 2019, Judge Benitez of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of California dropped a massive ruling. He basically said the ban was unconstitutional under the Second Amendment. For one glorious week—now famously known as "Freedom Week"—the ban was unenforceable. People bought hundreds of thousands of magazines. They were shipped in by the truckload.
But then the stay happened. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals stepped in. They didn't necessarily say Benitez was wrong yet, but they "paused" his ruling while the case moved forward. This created a weird legal limbo that we are still living in today.
Can You Get Arrested for a CA Large Capacity Magazine Today?
This is where it gets incredibly nuanced. As of right now, California law still prohibits the sale, gift, or loan of any magazine over 10 rounds. You cannot walk into a gun store in San Diego or Sacramento and buy a 30-round PMAG. You also cannot order one online and have it shipped to your house.
But what about the ones people bought during Freedom Week?
Current court orders generally protect the possession of those specific magazines purchased during that window (March 29, 2019, to April 5, 2019). If you legally acquired a CA large capacity magazine during that time, you are mostly in the clear to keep it, though you can't go around selling it or giving it to your buddy.
However, there is a catch. Law enforcement doesn't always know the specific timeline of your purchase. While possession of a legally acquired magazine isn't a crime under the current stay, it can still be used as a reason for "reasonable suspicion" or "probable cause" in some aggressive jurisdictions. It's a gray area that makes a lot of people nervous.
Why the Capacity Limit Even Exists (According to the State)
California’s argument is simple: they believe that by limiting magazines to 10 rounds, they force a "critical pause" during mass shootings. They argue that the time it takes to reload gives victims a chance to run or tackle the shooter.
Gun rights advocates, like those at the Firearms Policy Coalition (FPC), argue this is total nonsense. They point out that a practiced shooter can change a magazine in about two seconds. They also argue that for a homeowner defending their family against multiple intruders, those extra five or ten rounds could be the difference between life and death.
It’s a fundamental clash of philosophies. One side views the magazine as a public safety hazard; the other views it as a necessary component of a "standard" modern firearm. Remember, for many of the most popular handguns in America, a 10-round magazine is actually a "reduced capacity" magazine specially made just to comply with states like California, New York, and New Jersey.
🔗 Read more: The 2024 Shooting at San Francisco Union Square: What Really Happened to Ricky Pearsall
The Impact of the Bruen Decision
Everything changed in 2022 when the Supreme Court decided NYSRPA v. Bruen. This was a massive shift in how courts have to look at gun laws. The Supreme Court basically said: "Forget the 'public interest' balancing tests. If a law affects the Second Amendment, the government has to prove that the law is consistent with the historical tradition of firearm regulation in the United States."
This sent Duncan v. Bonta back down to the lower courts. Judge Benitez looked at it again through the "Bruen lens" and, unsurprisingly, issued another ruling in late 2023 saying the ban is still unconstitutional. He famously noted that there is no historical tradition from the 1700s or 1800s of the government telling citizens how much ammunition their weapons could hold.
The State of California immediately appealed again. They love their appeals.
Common Misconceptions About 10/30 Magazines
You’ll see these for sale all over California. A "10/30" magazine is a full-sized 30-round magazine body that has been "permanently" blocked so it can only hold 10 rounds.
These are legal. Mostly.
The keyword is permanently. California law doesn't explicitly define what "permanent" means, which is frustrating. Usually, it involves a plastic block inside the magazine that is either riveted to the floorplate or epoxied shut. If you can take it apart with a simple screwdriver and remove the block in ten seconds, the CA DOJ might argue it wasn't permanent. If you have to use a drill or a heat gun to get it open, you're usually on safer ground.
Don't try to be clever and use a temporary block. It's not worth the felony charge.
What’s Next for California Gun Owners?
We are waiting on the Ninth Circuit. Again. They are currently reviewing the case en banc, which means a larger panel of judges will hear it. Given the current makeup of the Ninth Circuit, many expect them to uphold the ban, which would then likely send the case back to the U.S. Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court is the end game here. If they take the case, they could set a national standard that would wipe out magazine capacity limits in every state. But that process takes years.
In the meantime, if you are looking to stay on the right side of the law while still being prepared, there are a few things to keep in mind:
- Stick to 10 rounds for new purchases. Don't try to sneak magazines across the border from Nevada or Arizona. California uses license plate readers at the border and occasionally runs stings at gun shows in neighboring states.
- Keep your receipts. If you were one of the lucky ones who bought magazines during Freedom Week, keep a digital copy of that receipt on your phone. If you're ever questioned, having proof of a legal purchase date is your best defense.
- Support the organizations doing the work. Whether you like them or not, groups like the CRPA and FPC are the ones actually filing the paperwork and sitting in the courtrooms. They provide regular updates on the status of these stays.
- Check your local ordinances. Some cities in California (like San Francisco or Los Angeles) have tried to pass their own even stricter rules. Usually, state law preempts these, but it can still lead to a massive legal headache if you get caught in a local enforcement sweep.
The reality of owning a CA large capacity magazine is that you are participating in a live-action legal experiment. It is a game of wait-and-see. For now, the safest bet is to use what is clearly legal while keeping a very close eye on the docket in the Southern District of California.
Actionable Next Steps
If you currently own magazines with a capacity over 10 rounds in California, verify their origin immediately. If they were purchased during the April 2019 "Freedom Week" window, ensure you have a record of that transaction stored securely. If you acquired them outside of that window or cannot prove their legal acquisition, consult with a firearms attorney before taking them to a public range. For those looking to purchase new equipment, focus on high-quality 10-round magazines or professionally riveted 10/30 variants from reputable manufacturers to ensure compliance with the current stay on Penal Code 32310. Monitor the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals' public calendar for the next scheduled hearing in Duncan v. Bonta to stay ahead of potential shifts in enforcement.