Honestly, if you missed the BYU vs Oklahoma State game this past October, you missed out on one of the most chaotic, heart-pounding finishes in recent college football history. Most people think of "classic" rivalries and go straight to the Iron Bowl or the Big House. But there is something weirdly magical happening between the Cougars and the Cowboys.
It's basically a clash of cultures that has somehow turned into a high-stakes chess match on grass.
When BYU entered the Big 12, everyone wondered if they’d fit in. They didn’t just fit; they started burning the house down. The October 18, 2024, game in Provo was the perfect example. BYU was sitting at 6-0, ranked No. 13, and Oklahoma State was desperately trying to snap a losing skid. What followed was a 38-35 thriller that wasn't decided until there were literal seconds left on the clock.
👉 See also: Bubba Watson: What Most People Get Wrong About Golf’s Great Creative
The Night Provo Almost Lost Its Mind
You’ve got to picture the scene. LaVell Edwards Stadium is rocking. It's cloudy, 45 degrees, and the air feels like football. Oklahoma State, despite their struggles, comes out swinging. Ollie Gordon II—who is basically a human cheat code when he's healthy—was ripping off runs like he was playing against a high school JV team.
He finished that night with 107 yards and two touchdowns on the ground, plus another receiving score.
But then there's Jake Retzlaff. BYU’s quarterback is the definition of "never say die." He threw two interceptions that could have sunk a lesser team, but he also ran for 81 yards and a score. The game was a total see-saw.
- First Quarter: Retzlaff scores a 4-yard run; Ollie Gordon answers with a 50-yard sprint.
- Second Quarter: Things get messy. OSU takes a 21-14 lead into the half after Gordon catches a touchdown pass from Garret Rangel.
- Third Quarter: BYU roars back with 14 unanswered points.
The drama in the fourth quarter was almost too much. Oklahoma State took the lead 35-31 with only 1:13 left. Most fans in the stands were starting to look for their car keys. But Retzlaff had other ideas. He led an 8-play, 75-yard drive in about a minute. He found Darius Lassiter for a 35-yard touchdown with 10 seconds left.
Game over. 38-35. Pandemonium.
It’s Not Just About Football
While the football side of BYU vs Oklahoma State gets the most TV time, the basketball court is where the real tactical wars happen. On January 14, 2025, the two met in the Marriott Center. BYU walked away with an 85-69 win, but the score doesn't tell the whole story of how physical that game was.
College basketball in the Big 12 is a meat grinder.
Honestly, playing at BYU is a nightmare for visiting teams. The altitude is one thing, but the crowd is relentless. Oklahoma State’s coach, Mike Boynton (and later Steve Lutz), has often talked about how the preparation for a trip to Provo is different than anywhere else in the league. You aren't just playing a team; you're playing an entire ecosystem.
The Historic Context (For the Nerds)
Believe it or not, these two have a history that goes way back before the Big 12 was even a thing. They met in the Fiesta Bowl in 1974 and the Tangerine Bowl in 1976. Back then, Oklahoma State dominated. They beat BYU 16-6 and 49-21 in those games.
For decades, that was the book on this matchup.
Then came 2023. Oklahoma State won a 40-34 double-overtime thriller in Stillwater. It was a heartbreaker for BYU fans because it was the final game of the regular season, and it felt like they had the Cowboys on the ropes. Since that game, though, the momentum has shifted. Oklahoma State has actually struggled significantly in conference play, while BYU has utilized their home-field advantage to become a legitimate Big 12 powerhouse.
What Most People Get Wrong About This Matchup
There’s a misconception that BYU vs Oklahoma State is a "new" rivalry. People think it’s just two teams forced together by conference expansion. That’s wrong.
The DNA of these two programs is surprisingly similar. Both have massive, dedicated fan bases. Both are located in places where the university is the center of the universe. And both programs pride themselves on a specific brand of "toughness" that isn't always about being the fastest or the strongest, but about being the most disciplined.
The real difference lately has been the "Cardiac Cougs" factor.
Under Kalani Sitake, BYU has developed this weird habit of winning games they probably should lose. On the flip side, Mike Gundy’s Oklahoma State teams have historically been the ones who pull off the miracle wins. Lately, it feels like those roles have flipped. OSU is the team playing great for three quarters and then losing the handle in the final minutes.
Hard Truths and Stat Splits
If you're looking at the numbers, the 2024 football game showed a huge disparity in how these teams move the ball.
- Rushing: Both teams are elite here. OSU had 269 rushing yards; BYU had 255. That's a lot of "ground and pound."
- Turnovers: This is where BYU usually wins. In that 38-35 game, they survived three interceptions. Usually, that’s a death sentence.
- Third Down Conversions: Oklahoma State was 9-of-13. That is a massive success rate. Usually, if you convert nearly 70% of your third downs, you win the game by two touchdowns.
The fact that BYU won despite those stats tells you everything you need to know about the "X-factor" in this series. It’s emotional. It’s loud. It’s unpredictable.
👉 See also: ESPN Allstate Playoff Predictor Explained: What Most Fans Get Wrong
Practical Takeaways for Fans
If you're planning on watching or attending the next BYU vs Oklahoma State showdown, keep a few things in mind:
- Hydrate for Provo: If you're an OSU fan traveling to Utah, the altitude is no joke. It's 4,500 feet above sea level. You'll feel it by the second quarter.
- The "Ollie Gordon" Rule: Never count out the Cowboys if #0 is on the field. Even if the offense looks stagnant, he can break a 60-yarder at any second.
- The Last Two Minutes: Do. Not. Leave. Early. These games are almost always decided in the final 120 seconds.
Basically, this has become the "stress bowl" of the Big 12. Whether it's on the gridiron or the hardwood, expect the unexpected. The 2024-2025 cycle proved that these two schools are going to be thorns in each other's sides for a long time.
What to Do Next
Keep an eye on the injury reports before the next matchup, specifically regarding the quarterback situation at Oklahoma State. After Garret Rangel went down in the 2024 game, the dynamic changed instantly. For BYU, watch the development of LJ Martin. He’s becoming the bell cow they need to take the pressure off Retzlaff.
Check the upcoming Big 12 schedule to see if the next meeting is a night game. In Provo, the "dark" games are notoriously difficult for visitors. If you're betting or just playing fantasy, always lean toward the home team in this specific series—the home-field advantage has been the deciding factor in three of the last four meetings across all sports.