You're standing in the middle of the feed store. It smells like dusty grain and old wood. There it is—the stack. Huge, towering rows of paper sacks. You reach for a 50 lb bag of chicken feed because, honestly, the 10-pounders are a joke if you have more than three birds. But here's the thing: most people just grab the cheapest bag and toss it in the truck.
That’s a mistake.
A big one. Feeding chickens isn't just about filling bellies; it's about the math of protein, the science of spoilage, and the weird reality that a "bargain" bag might actually cost you more in the long run. If your hens stop laying or start eating their own eggs, the bag you just lugged home is probably the culprit.
Why the 50 lb bag of chicken feed is the industry standard
Ever wonder why 50 pounds? It’s the sweet spot. It’s heavy enough to require a bit of muscle but light enough that a single person can sling it over a shoulder. In the agricultural world, this is the "standard unit." Whether it's Purina, Nutrena, or a local mill mix, this size is what the infrastructure is built for.
Think about the physics. Shipping five 10-lb bags is a logistical nightmare compared to one 50-lb sack. The packaging waste is lower. The handling is streamlined. But for you, the backyard keeper, it’s about the "freshness window."
A standard Rhode Island Red or Orpington eats about 1/4 pound of feed a day. Do the math. If you have five birds, they’re going through about 1.25 pounds daily. That 50 lb bag of chicken feed is going to last you 40 days.
That’s perfect.
Wait much longer than six weeks, and the vitamins start to degrade. The fats in the grain can go rancid, especially in humid climates like the Southeast or during a swampy Midwest summer. If you’ve got a massive flock of 20 birds, that bag is gone in ten days. If you only have two "pet" silkies? You’re buying way too much at once. You’ll be feeding them stale, cardboard-tasting pellets by week eight.
The Protein Problem: Not all bags are equal
Walk down the aisle and you’ll see "Layer," "Starter," and "Grower."
🔗 Read more: Blue Tabby Maine Coon: What Most People Get Wrong About This Striking Coat
The most common 50 lb bag of chicken feed you'll find is a 16% protein Layer pellet. That’s the baseline. It’s what most people need. But here is where the nuance kicks in. During the fall molt—when your yard looks like a pillow exploded—16% isn't enough. Your birds are literally growing a new set of clothes. Feathers are almost entirely protein.
I’ve seen folks stick to the same bag year-round and then wonder why their birds look ragged and quit laying for four months. Switching to a 20% "Feather Fixer" or a broiler feed for a few weeks can change everything.
- Starter/Grower: Usually 18-20% protein. No added calcium. If you feed this to laying hens long-term without a side of oyster shell, their bones will turn to rubber.
- Layer Feed: 16% protein with about 3-4% calcium. Don't feed this to chicks. The calcium load will wreck their developing kidneys.
- All-Flock: A middle-ground 18% protein. Great if you have ducks, roosters, and hens together.
Storage: The fastest way to waste fifty bucks
You get home. You drop the bag on the garage floor. Big mistake.
Concrete wicks moisture. Even if it looks dry, it's not. Within a week, the bottom three inches of that 50 lb bag of chicken feed will be a clumpy, moldy mess. Moldy feed contains mycotoxins. These can kill a bird faster than a fox in a coop.
Get a metal trash can.
Seriously. Plastic bins are okay for a while, but a determined rat can chew through a heavy-duty Rubbermaid in a single night. I’ve seen it. It’s impressive and infuriating. A galvanized steel bin with a locking lid is the only real defense. It keeps the mice out, it keeps the moisture out, and it keeps the nutritional integrity in.
Also, keep it out of the sun. Heat accelerates the breakdown of Vitamin A and E. If you’re storing your feed in a hot tin shed in July, that bag is losing its punch every single day.
The "Fines" Factor
Open a bag and look at the bottom. You’ll see "fines"—that powdery stuff that isn't quite a pellet. Most chickens hate it. They’ll flick it out of the feeder looking for the "good bits." If you buy a low-quality 50 lb bag of chicken feed, you might be getting 5 or 10 pounds of dust.
💡 You might also like: Blue Bathroom Wall Tiles: What Most People Get Wrong About Color and Mood
That’s 20% of your money literally on the ground.
Higher-end brands like Scratch and Peck or New Country Organics often use whole grains. There’s no dust because nothing is ground up and pressed. It looks like birdseed. The downside? The chickens "sort" it. They’ll eat the corn and peas and leave the small seeds. It’s a trade-off.
The Organic vs. Conventional Debate
This is where the price jump happens. A conventional 50 lb bag of chicken feed might run you $18 to $24. The organic, soy-free, non-GMO version? You’re looking at $35 to $50.
Is it worth it?
It depends on why you have chickens. If you’re trying to save money on eggs, organic feed makes that impossible. You'll be eating $8-a-dozen eggs. But if you’re sensitive to soy, or if you’re worried about glyphosate residues in the corn, the extra twenty bucks is the price of peace of mind.
Dr. Patrick Biggs, a poultry nutritionist at Purina, often points out that the bird's digestive tract is incredibly efficient at processing standard grains. However, the organic movement isn't just about the bird; it's about the soil those grains were grown in. If you're going organic, make sure the bag has the USDA Organic seal. "All-natural" is a marketing term that means absolutely nothing in the feed world.
Reading the tag (The secret code)
Every 50 lb bag of chicken feed has a tag sewn into the bottom or top. Don’t throw it away. It’s the "Nutrition Facts" label for your birds.
Look for the Lysine and Methionine levels. These are essential amino acids. If they aren't listed, the company is probably using low-quality protein sources. You want to see at least 0.30% Methionine for good feather health and egg size.
📖 Related: BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse Superstition Springs Menu: What to Order Right Now
Also, check the "Date of Manufacture." Some big-box stores have bags that have been sitting in a warehouse for six months. You want feed that was bagged within the last 30 to 60 days. Anything older is basically just filler with some minerals sprinkled on top.
Pellets, Crumbles, or Mash?
This is a personal preference—for the chicken.
- Pellets: Great for reducing waste. They don't blow away. Harder for the birds to "sort."
- Crumbles: Basically smashed pellets. Great for smaller breeds or birds that are picky eaters.
- Mash: Un-processed, ground-up grain. Usually used in commercial settings or for very young birds. It's messy.
Most people buying a 50 lb bag of chicken feed for a backyard flock should stick to pellets. They flow better in automatic feeders and don't turn into a paste the second a raindrop hits them.
Actionable Steps for the Smart Chicken Keeper
Don't just buy the bag. Manage the bag.
First, get a dedicated scoop. A 16-oz metal feed scoop usually holds about half a pound of pellets. If you know exactly how much you're scooping, you can track if your birds are eating more or less than usual—which is often the first sign of illness.
Second, do the "Sniff Test." When you open a fresh 50 lb bag of chicken feed, it should smell like grain, maybe a bit like molasses or earth. If it smells sour, musty, or like "old paint," take it back. Any reputable feed store will swap it out.
Third, supplement—but don't overdo it. Kitchen scraps are great, but they should never make up more than 10% of the diet. That balanced bag of feed is a complete ration. If you fill them up on bread and watermelon, they aren't getting the calcium and protein they need to actually produce an egg.
Lastly, check your local mills. Often, a local elevator will mix a "custom" poultry ration that is fresher and cheaper than the big national brands. You won't get the fancy colorful bag, but your hens will probably thank you for it.
Invest in a good storage bin, watch the expiration dates, and match the protein to the season. It’s the difference between a struggling flock and a yard full of healthy, productive birds.