Most guys think they’re wearing a button down when they aren’t. It’s a weirdly specific pet peeve for menswear nerds, but there is a massive difference between a "button-up" and a "button-down." If those tiny points on your collar aren’t literally fastened to the shirt body by buttons, you’re just wearing a standard dress shirt.
It started with polo players. Back in the late 19th century, players in England were getting annoyed because their collars kept flapping into their faces during matches. John E. Brooks, of Brooks Brothers fame, saw this, thought it was brilliant, and brought the "button-down polo shirt" to America in 1896. He basically changed the trajectory of American Ivy League style forever.
The Oxford Cloth Button Down (OCBD) is the actual goat
If you’re looking for the quintessential version of button down shirts for men, you’re looking for the OCBD. Oxford cloth is a basketweave fabric. It’s thick. It’s durable. Honestly, it gets better the more you wash it.
You’ve probably seen the cheap versions at fast-fashion malls that feel like sandpaper. Avoid those. A real Oxford should have a "heft" to it. The beauty of this specific shirt is its versatility. You can wear it with a navy blazer to a wedding, or you can throw it on over a t-shirt with some beat-up chinos for a grocery run. It doesn't care.
Why the collar roll matters more than you think
Ask any tailoring enthusiast about "the roll." They’ll talk your ear off. A good button down collar shouldn't lay flat and dead against the collarbone. It should have a soft, S-shaped curve. This happens when the collar points are long enough and the buttons are placed just right.
Mass-market brands often screw this up by making the collar points too short. This results in a stiff, flat look that feels corporate and soulless. If you want to look like you know what you’re doing, look for a "unlined" or "soft" collar. It feels less like a uniform and more like a second skin. Brands like Drake's or Wythe New York have basically built their entire reputations on getting this one specific curve right.
🔗 Read more: Marie Kondo The Life Changing Magic of Tidying Up: What Most People Get Wrong
Choosing the right fit without looking like a balloon
Fit is where most guys give up. You either get the "slim fit" that makes you look like a vacuum-sealed sausage, or the "classic fit" that has enough excess fabric in the back to act as a sail.
Modern button down shirts for men usually come in three flavors:
- Slim Fit: Best for guys with a narrow frame or those who like a very clean, tucked-in look.
- Athletic Fit: More room in the chest and shoulders but tapers at the waist. Harder to find but worth the search.
- Relaxed/Classic: This is making a huge comeback. High-end labels like Stoffa are leaning back into fuller cuts. It’s breathable. It’s comfortable. Just make sure the shoulder seams actually hit the end of your shoulders.
Don't ignore the hem. If the shirt has a long, dramatic "tail," it’s meant to be tucked in. If the bottom is straight across or has a very shallow curve, you can wear it untucked. Wearing a long-tailed dress shirt untucked is the fastest way to look like you're wearing a nightgown. Don't do it.
The fabric rabbit hole: Beyond basic cotton
Cotton is the standard, but it isn't the only player.
- Chambray: Looks like denim but it’s a plain weave. It’s rugged. It’s the "workwear" version of the button down.
- Flannel: Essential for winter. Look for "brushed" cotton. It’s fuzzy and traps heat.
- Linen blends: Pure linen wrinkles if you even look at it funny. A cotton-linen blend gives you the breathability of linen with the structure of cotton. Perfect for July heatwaves.
I once bought a 100% synthetic "non-iron" button down for a business trip. Big mistake. It felt like wearing a plastic bag. While the "non-iron" labels are tempting, they’re usually treated with formaldehyde resins. They don't breathe. You’ll sweat through it in twenty minutes. Stick to natural fibers. A few wrinkles never killed anyone; in fact, with an Oxford shirt, the wrinkles are part of the charm. It shows you’re actually living in the clothes.
💡 You might also like: Why Transparent Plus Size Models Are Changing How We Actually Shop
How to actually care for these things
Stop dry cleaning your button down shirts for men. Seriously. The harsh chemicals and high-heat "pressing" machines shatter the mother-of-pearl buttons and weaken the fabric fibers.
Wash them at home. Cold water. Hang them up to dry. If you absolutely hate ironing, steam them while they’re on the hanger. If you use a dryer, take them out while they are still slightly damp. This prevents the collar from shrinking into a tight, uncomfortable circle around your neck.
Also, pay attention to the "ring around the collar." It’s basically just skin oils and sweat. Use a dedicated stain stick or even just some Dawn dish soap on the collar band before throwing it in the wash. It saves the shirt from looking yellow and gross after six months.
Surprising facts about the buttons themselves
Most people ignore the buttons, but they are a massive indicator of quality. Cheap shirts use plastic (polyester) buttons. They’re uniform and boring.
High-end button down shirts for men use Mother of Pearl. These are carved from sea shells. They stay cool to the touch and have a depth of color that plastic can't mimic. If you see "cross-stitched" buttons, that’s a good sign—it means they’re less likely to pop off when you’re reaching for something. Some Italian brands even use a "shanking" technique where the button is wrapped in thread to stand off the fabric slightly, making it easier to button with one hand.
📖 Related: Weather Forecast Calumet MI: What Most People Get Wrong About Keweenaw Winters
Actionable steps for your wardrobe
If you're starting from scratch, don't buy a rainbow of colors. You really only need three.
Start with a white Oxford. It’s the baseline. Then get a light blue one—it’s the most flattering color for almost every skin tone. Your third should be a "university stripe" (white with thin blue vertical stripes). These three will cover 90% of your life events.
Go to a store and try on three different sizes in the same brand. Sizes aren't universal. A "Medium" at J.Crew is not a "Medium" at Ralph Lauren. Pay attention to the sleeve length; the cuff should land right at the base of your thumb. If it’s covering your knuckles, it’s too long. If it’s showing your wrist bone, it’s too short.
Check the "yoke"—that's the piece of fabric that goes across your shoulder blades. A "split yoke" (where the fabric is cut into two pieces and joined in the middle) is a hallmark of better construction because it allows for a bit more stretch and movement.
Stop overthinking the "rules." The button down is inherently a casual garment. It was born on a sports field. If the collar is buttoned down, you have permission to relax. Roll up the sleeves. Leave the top two buttons open. It’s a shirt, not a straitjacket.
Next Steps for Your Closet:
- Audit your current shirts and donate anything made of 100% synthetic "non-iron" material that doesn't breathe.
- Measure your neck and sleeve length properly using a soft tape measure so you can shop online with actual data.
- Invest in a high-quality wooden hanger for your favorite Oxford; wire hangers will ruin the shoulder shape over time.
- Look for "vintage" Brooks Brothers on resale sites—the older versions often have the legendary "unlined" collar roll that modern mass-market versions lack.