You’re staring at a screen full of silicone and stainless steel. It’s overwhelming. Honestly, the first time most people think about a butt plug try on session, they're terrified of picking something way too big or, weirdly enough, something so small it doesn't do anything at all. It’s a literal pain in the ass if you get it wrong. But here’s the thing: your body is remarkably resilient, provided you actually listen to it instead of forcing a "goal" size.
Anxiety is the biggest mood killer here. When you're nervous, your pelvic floor muscles—specifically the external and internal anal sphincters—clench up like a fist. Trying to insert anything when you're tense is a recipe for a bad Saturday night. This isn't just about "buying a toy." It's about understanding how the anatomy of the rectum works, which is surprisingly sophisticated. Unlike the vaginal canal, the anus doesn't self-lubricate. It’s a one-way street that requires a bit of negotiation to turn into a two-way alley.
Why a Butt Plug Try On Is Different Than You Think
Most people assume they can just "eyeball" a size. Bad idea. A butt plug try on at home—since you obviously can't do this in a store—is about testing your comfort ceiling. You've got to consider the "flare." Every legitimate plug has a flared base. If it doesn't, do not put it near your body. Seriously. The rectum has a "vacuum" effect; without a base, that toy is gone, and you’re headed for a very awkward ER visit.
Doctors like Dr. Evan Goldstein, a renowned anal surgeon, often point out that the internal sphincter is involuntary. You can't just "tell" it to relax with your brain. You have to coax it. This is why the "try on" phase usually involves a kit of graduated sizes. You don't start with a large; you start with something roughly the size of a pinky finger.
It’s kinda like stretching for a workout. You wouldn't try to do the splits without warming up your hamstrings for weeks. Your first butt plug try on should feel like a gentle pressure, not a sharp pinch. If it hurts, stop. Full stop. Pain is the body's way of saying "micro-tears are happening," and you really don't want those in an area prone to bacteria.
Choosing Your Materials Wisely
Material matters more than color or "vibes."
- Silicone: This is the gold standard. It's non-porous. It warms up to body temperature quickly.
- Glass/Stainless Steel: These are for the "advanced" crowd or those who like temperature play. They have zero "give."
- Jelly/PVC: Avoid these. They smell like a chemical factory because they are porous and can harbor bacteria even after a wash.
When you're doing your first butt plug try on, silicone is the safest bet because it has a slight "squish" factor. It’s more forgiving. If you’re sensitive to latex, make sure you're getting 100% medical-grade silicone. Brands like b-Vibe or NJoy are often cited by sexual health educators because they focus on anatomical curves rather than just "looking cool."
The Lube Factor
You cannot use too much lube. Period. For a butt plug try on to be successful, you need a high-quality water-based or silicone-based lubricant. Quick tip: if you're using a silicone toy, stay away from silicone lube—it’ll degrade the toy's surface and make it "sticky" or pitted over time.
Go for something thick. Thin, runny lubes disappear too fast. You want something with "staying power" so the plug can glide past the sphincter muscles without friction. Friction is the enemy of a good time.
Navigating the "First Time" Sizing
So, you've got your kit. You're ready. Sit on a towel—trust me on this one. Gravity can be your friend or your enemy here. Many people find that lying on their side with knees tucked (the fetal position) is the easiest way to manage a butt plug try on because it relaxes the glutes.
💡 You might also like: Wait, What Is Zoey Short For? The Greek Roots and Modern Meanings
- Start by just touching the area. Get used to the sensation.
- Use plenty of lube on the toy and yourself.
- Apply the tip of the smallest plug to the opening.
- Don't push. Just hold it there.
- Take a deep breath. As you exhale, gently guide it in.
The "push" should come from your muscles, almost like you're trying to have a bowel movement. This naturally opens the sphincter. It sounds counterintuitive, but "pushing out" while "sliding in" is the secret move pros use. If you feel a "pop" sensation, that’s just the plug passing the internal sphincter. Once it’s in, let it sit. Don't move it around yet. Let your body adjust to the "fullness" feeling.
Common Misconceptions About Sizing
A lot of folks think they need to "work up" to a massive size to be "good" at this. That’s nonsense. For many, the sensation of a small or medium plug is actually more intense because it stimulates the prostate (in men) or the A-spot (in women) without causing discomfort.
Size isn't a trophy.
If a medium feels "too much" during your butt plug try on, stay at small for a month. There's no rush. Your body isn't a race track. Over-stretching can lead to fissures, which are tiny cracks in the skin that sting like crazy and take forever to heal because, well, you have to use that area of your body every day.
Training Kits vs. Single Plugs
If you're serious about this, buy a "trainer kit." These are sets of three or four plugs that gradually increase in diameter by millimeters. This is the most scientific way to handle a butt plug try on.
Trying to jump from a "beginner" plug to a "large" is like trying to lift 200lbs when you’ve only ever lifted a gallon of milk. It won't work, and you'll probably hurt yourself. Kits from reputable companies like Tantus or CalExotics are designed specifically for this gradual progression.
Cleanliness and Aftercare
After you finish your butt plug try on session, cleaning is mandatory. Warm water and mild soap usually do the trick for silicone. If you want to be extra, use a dedicated toy cleaner.
Listen to your body afterward. A little bit of "awareness" in the area is normal, but actual pain or bleeding is not. If you see blood, you went too fast or used a toy that was too hard or poorly finished (watch out for "seams" on cheap plastic toys).
Actionable Next Steps
- Audit your drawer: If you have any toys made of "jelly" or "rubber" that smell porous, toss them. They aren't worth the risk of an infection.
- Measure your current comfort: If you're currently using a toy, measure its diameter at the widest point. When looking for your next butt plug try on candidate, only go up by 0.25 inches in diameter at most.
- Invest in "cushioned" lube: Look for lubes containing cellulose or glycerin-free options if you're prone to yeast infections or sensitivity.
- Practice pelvic floor drops: Learn to consciously "drop" or relax your pelvic floor while breathing. This makes the actual insertion process 100% easier.
- Set a timer: Don't leave a plug in for hours the first time. Start with 10-15 minutes to see how your tissue reacts to the sustained pressure.
The goal is pleasure and exploration, not endurance. If you approach your butt plug try on with patience and a massive bottle of lube, you'll find it's a lot less intimidating than the internet makes it out to be.