You’ve seen the photos. A soft, hazy cloud of deep red wine tones surrounding a pair of green eyes that suddenly look like emeralds. It’s gorgeous. But then you try it at home, and suddenly you look like you’ve got a severe case of pink eye or haven't slept since 2019. It’s frustrating. Burgundy eye makeup looks are notoriously tricky because the line between "sultry editorial" and "medical emergency" is thinner than a liquid liner wing.
The truth is that burgundy isn't just one color. It’s a spectrum. You have your oxbloods, your maroons, your deep berries, and those brownish-reds that look almost chocolatey until the light hits them. People fail because they treat burgundy like a neutral. It’s not. It’s a statement that requires a bit of color theory and a lot of blending.
👉 See also: How the New York Times Dialect Test Guessed Where You Grew Up (and Why It Still Works)
Honestly, the biggest mistake is the lack of transition. If you slap a matte burgundy directly onto a pale eyelid, it’s going to look harsh. You need a bridge. Think about using a warm peach or a soft tan in the crease first. This gives the red pigments a place to land so they don't look like a bruise.
The Secret to Nailing Burgundy Eye Makeup Looks Without the Red-Eye Effect
Most people think they can't wear reds. That's usually wrong. Everyone can wear burgundy, but the "how" depends entirely on your undertone. If you have cool, pinkish skin, a burgundy with too much blue in it can make you look tired. If you’re warm or olive, those super-orange-based maroons might just disappear into your skin or look muddy.
Patrick Ta, a makeup artist who basically pioneered the "monochromatic red" look on celebrities like Gigi Hadid, often suggests tight-lining with black or dark brown when using these shades. Why? Because you need a structural "break" between the red pigment and the white of your eye. Without that dark line of mascara or eyeliner, the burgundy bleeds into the eye itself, which is exactly why people end up looking sick.
Texture is your best friend
Don't just stick to mattes. A matte burgundy is bold, sure, but a shimmer or a metallic cranberry in the center of the lid adds dimension that prevents the look from feeling "flat." Flat red is dangerous. Dimensional red is expensive-looking.
I’ve spent hours messing with different palettes—from the classic Anastasia Beverly Hills Modern Renaissance to the newer, more pigmented options from Pat McGrath—and the consensus is always the same: start small. You don’t need to go full "vampire chic" on day one. A simple wash of a sheer burgundy cream shadow can be more effective than a 15-step smoky eye. It’s about the vibe, not just the saturation.
Stop Ignoring Your Concealer
This is non-negotiable. If you are leaning into burgundy eye makeup looks, your under-eye concealer has to be flawless. Burgundy has a way of pulling out every purple, blue, or green vein in your skin. If you have dark circles, the red tones in the eyeshadow will act like a giant neon sign pointing right at them.
You’ve got to color correct. Use a peach or orange corrector to neutralize the blue tones under the eyes before applying your foundation. It sounds like extra work, but it’s the difference between looking like a Victorian ghost and looking like a runway model. Also, keep the rest of your face relatively neutral. A bright red lip with a heavy burgundy eye can be... a lot. It’s a bit "costume party" for most Tuesday afternoons. Try a nude lip with a hint of brown or a sheer berry tint instead.
Real-world examples of what works
- The "Wash of Wine": Using a single satin-finish maroon shadow all over the lid and blending it out until it’s almost a shadow. It’s low effort but high impact.
- The Burgundy Wing: If you’re scared of the color, just use a wet angled brush and some burgundy shadow to create a wing. It’s subtle. People will notice something is different but won't be able to put their finger on it.
- The Halo Eye: Deep burgundy on the inner and outer corners, with a bright rose gold or champagne shimmer right in the middle. This keeps the look "open" and prevents your eyes from looking small.
How to Choose the Right Shade for Your Eye Color
It’s all about the color wheel. If you remember middle school art class, you know that complementary colors sit opposite each other. This is why burgundy is a "cheat code" for certain eye colors.
Green Eyes: You win. Burgundy and red are opposite green. This is the most dramatic contrast you can get. A deep wine shade will make green eyes look almost neon.
Blue Eyes: Look for burgundies that lean a bit more orange or copper. Since orange is the complement to blue, these "warm" burgundies will make the blue pop without clashing.
Brown Eyes: You can wear almost anything. Brown eyes usually have hidden flecks of gold or green. A purple-leaning burgundy will bring out the gold, while a true brick-red will make the brown look deeper and richer.
Hazel Eyes: This is where it gets fun. Depending on the shade of burgundy you pick, you can "pull" the green out of hazel eyes or make them look more amber. It’s basically magic.
✨ Don't miss: Black and White Persian Cats: Why This Classic Look Still Wins Every Time
Common Pitfalls: Why Your Look Feels "Off"
Sometimes you do everything right and it still looks weird. Usually, it’s one of three things. First, the eyebrows. If your eyes are very "warm" with burgundy tones, but your eyebrows are a very "cool" ashy grey, they’re going to fight each other. Try using a slightly warmer brow pencil.
Second, the "bruise" factor. If you blend burgundy too far down onto the lower lash line without enough precision, it mimics the look of a bruise. Keep the lower lash line tight. Use a smaller brush than you think you need.
Third, and this is a big one: lighting. Burgundy looks different under LED lights than it does in the sun. Always check your blend in natural light. What looks like a soft transition in your bathroom might look like a harsh streak of red in the car mirror. We’ve all been there. It’s not fun.
The Evolution of the Red Palette
We used to be terrified of red eyeshadow. Back in the early 2000s, it was something only "alternative" kids or high-fashion stylists touched. Then came the "warm neutral" explosion of 2016, and suddenly everyone realized that reddish-browns are actually quite flattering.
Today, the technology in pigments has changed. We have "pressed pigments" now that stay true to color. In the past, a burgundy might turn muddy or greyish after two hours of wear. Now, brands like Natasha Denona or Huda Beauty use high-quality synthetic fluorphlogopite (basically lab-made mica) to ensure the shimmer stays bright and the red stays red. It makes the whole process much easier for the average person who doesn't have a professional glam squad.
Essential Tools for the Job
- A dense packing brush: For getting that deep pigment onto the lid.
- A fluffy blending brush: This is your "eraser." Use it to soften edges.
- A dark brown eyeliner: Black can sometimes be too harsh with burgundy; a dark chocolate brown creates a softer, more sophisticated "frame" for the eye.
- A high-quality primer: Red pigments are notorious for staining the skin. A primer acts as a barrier and helps the color pop.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Look
Ready to try it? Don't overthink it. Makeup is supposed to be fun, not a math equation. If you mess up, just wipe it off and try again.
Start by prepping your lids with a base that matches your skin tone. This hides any tiny veins and gives you a blank canvas. Take a light taupe or tan and buff it into your crease with a big, fluffy brush. This is your "safety net."
Next, take your burgundy. Don't go straight for the middle of the lid. Start at the outer corner and "dab" the color on. Once the brush has less product on it, then you can start sweeping it toward the center. This creates a natural gradient. If it feels too dark, take that same fluffy brush you used for the tan and go over the edges.
Finish with a lot of black mascara. Seriously, a lot. You want your lashes to be a thick, black curtain that sits in front of the burgundy. It provides the contrast that makes the look intentional.
Next Steps:
- Audit your current collection: Look for "hidden" burgundies in your palettes that you’ve been ignoring.
- Experiment with liner: Try a burgundy pencil on your waterline for a "secret" pop of color.
- Check your lighting: Always do a "sunlight check" before leaving the house to ensure your blending is seamless.
- Pair with neutrals: Keep your blush and lipstick in the same color family (warm or cool) but much lower in intensity to keep the focus on your eyes.
Burgundy is a power color. It’s bold, it’s sophisticated, and it’s surprisingly versatile once you stop being afraid of it. Just remember: blend more than you think you need to, use a dark liner to anchor the look, and always, always conceal those under-eyes.