When you think of a clash between the University at Buffalo and Notre Dame, your brain probably goes straight to a lopsided football game or maybe a random soccer match from the nineties. But honestly, the real story lives on the hardwood. It’s a matchup that, until very recently, didn't even exist in the record books.
Most fans assume these two have been playing for decades because they’re both "Rust Belt" adjacent schools with massive regional footprints. Nope. In fact, their first-ever men's basketball meeting didn't happen until November 11, 2024. Before that? Total silence between the programs.
The hype around Buffalo vs Notre Dame usually centers on the David vs. Goliath narrative. You have the mid-major Bulls from the MAC trying to punch up against the blue-blood Irish of the ACC. But if you look at the actual box scores and the way these games play out, it’s rarely that simple. The gap isn't as wide as the brand names suggest.
Why the Buffalo vs Notre Dame Rivalry is Harder Than It Looks
In that 2024 debut at Purcell Pavilion, everyone expected the Irish to cruise. Instead, the Bulls walked into South Bend and went into the locker room with a 40-38 lead at halftime. It was a wake-up call. Buffalo isn't a team that gets intimidated by the "Touchdown Jesus" aura or the banners hanging in the rafters.
The Turning Point
Notre Dame eventually pulled away for an 86-77 win, but they had to sweat for it. A massive 24-2 run early in the second half saved their skin. Tae Davis was the absolute catalyst, dropping 27 points and basically living at the free-throw line where he went 12-of-13.
📖 Related: Ryan Suter: What Most People Get Wrong About the NHL's Ultimate Survivor
But look at what Buffalo did. They out-rebounded the Irish on the offensive glass and hit 11 threes. Ryan Sabol and Bryson Wilson (who had a monster 13 rebounds) proved that the Bulls' scouting and development are legit. They didn't lose because they were out-talented; they lost because they couldn't stop a five-minute tidal wave of momentum.
Beyond the Basketball Court
It's funny, but if you dig into the history of these two schools across all sports, the "firsts" are often surprising.
- Men’s Soccer: Buffalo actually stunned a nationally ranked Notre Dame team 3-2 back in 1997. It’s one of the biggest "forgotten" upsets in UB history.
- Football: They've never actually met on the gridiron. While Buffalo has played plenty of Big Ten and ACC schools, a trip to the House that Rockne Built remains a "bucket list" item for the Bulls' football program.
- Coaching Ties: There’s a weird amount of overlap here. Hamlet Tibbs, the Associate Head Coach for Buffalo, was actually on the Notre Dame staff under Micah Shrewsberry during the 2022-23 season. He knew exactly how the Irish wanted to play because he helped build the system.
The "Shrewsberry" Factor
Micah Shrewsberry is trying to rebuild Notre Dame into a gritty, defensive-minded powerhouse. It's a slow burn. Buffalo, under George Halcovage III, is trying to recapture that "Bracket Buster" energy they had during the Nate Oats and Bobby Hurley eras.
When these two styles clash, you get a very specific type of game. It’s physical. It’s high-variance. Because Notre Dame is leaning so heavily on young stars like Markus Burton and Braeden Shrewsberry, they are susceptible to the kind of veteran backcourt pressure that Buffalo specializes in.
👉 See also: Red Sox vs Yankees: What Most People Get Wrong About Baseball's Biggest Feud
Burton almost put up a triple-double in that first meeting (19 points, 9 rebounds, 8 assists), but Buffalo's Tyson Dunn matched that energy with a 9-assist performance of his own. It was a high-level guard battle that felt more like a March Madness second-round game than a November non-conference tilt.
What to Watch for in Future Matchups
If you're betting on or just watching a future Buffalo vs Notre Dame game, don't look at the seedings or the conference prestige. Look at the "Points in the Paint" and the "Free Throw Percentage."
In their last meeting, Notre Dame won because they dominated the paint 46 to 34. They forced the Bulls into foul trouble and capitalized. Buffalo’s Achilles' heel was the charity stripe—they shot a miserable 54.5%. You can't beat an ACC team on the road when you’re leaving double-digit points at the line.
Key Stats to Remember:
- Halftime Performance: Buffalo has shown they can lead Power Four teams after 20 minutes.
- Three-Point Volume: The Bulls aren't afraid to let it fly, often attempting 30+ shots from deep.
- Home Court Advantage: Purcell Pavilion is a tough place to play, but the crowd can get quiet if a mid-major hangs around past the 10-minute mark of the second half.
Honestly, the Bulls are just a few made free throws away from being a serious problem for the Irish.
✨ Don't miss: OU Football Depth Chart 2025: Why Most Fans Are Getting the Roster Wrong
Actionable Insights for Fans and Analysts
If you are following this matchup or looking to analyze the next scheduled meeting, here is the move.
First, track the development of the "Sophomore Leap" players on both rosters. Notre Dame’s success depends entirely on their young core becoming consistent. Second, watch the MAC standings. When Buffalo is at the top of their conference, they play with a level of "nothing to lose" confidence that is dangerous for Power Four schools.
Next, you should check the current injury reports and roster transfers for both teams, as the "Hamlet Tibbs connection" means both coaching staffs are intimately familiar with each other's playbooks. Keep an eye on the schedule for any potential return games in Buffalo; a matchup at Alumni Arena would be a completely different animal than a game in South Bend.