You know that weird feeling when two teams that almost never play each other suddenly become the most interesting thing on the Sunday slate? That is exactly the vibe whenever we talk about a buffalo bills vs chicago bears matchup. On paper, it is just an AFC-NFC crossover. In reality, it has become this strange, cross-conference barometer for where the league’s most desperate—and most passionate—fanbases actually stand.
Honestly, if you looked at the score from their most recent preseason clash in August 2025, you’d think the Bills had forgotten how to play football. A 38-0 shutout in favor of Chicago? At Soldier Field? It felt like a fever dream. Caleb Williams looked like the "Prince Who Was Promised," surgical and calm, while Buffalo’s depth chart seemed to dissolve under the Chicago heat. But as any seasoned fan will tell you, preseason scores are basically lies we tell ourselves in the summer.
The real story of the buffalo bills vs chicago bears rivalry—if you can even call it that—is one of extreme swings. Since 1970, these two have only met 15 times in the regular season. Chicago currently holds the edge with an 8-7 record (or 11-6 if you count the pre-merger chaos from the 1920s), but stats like that don't capture the sheer weirdness of the games. Like that 2022 Christmas Eve game where the Bills braved -10 degree wind chills to steamroll the Bears 35-13. One year it’s a defensive slugfest; the next, it’s a 41-9 Chicago blowout like we saw in 2018.
The Quarterback Mirror: Josh Allen and Caleb Williams
Everyone is obsessed with the "Next Josh Allen" label. It’s the ultimate draft season trope. But when you look at Caleb Williams’ second-year trajectory in 2025, the parallels are actually a bit spooky. Early on, critics hammered Williams for a completion percentage that hovered around 58-59%. Sound familiar? That was the exact same stick used to beat Josh Allen during his first two years in Western New York.
The difference? The Bears' roster in 2025 is arguably more "ready" than the Bills' roster was during Allen's developmental years. With Ben Johnson calling the plays in Chicago, Williams has a support system that Allen had to basically build from scratch with Brian Daboll.
Why the Comparison Matters
- The Dual-Threat Problem: Allen is a linebacker in a quarterback's body who will stiff-arm your best safety into the turf. Williams is more of a "slinker," using lateral agility to extend plays.
- Arm Talent: Both can throw a ball through a car wash without it getting wet. That "hero ball" mentality is a double-edged sword for both franchises.
- The Financial Window: Chicago is currently in that sweet spot where their QB is cheap, allowing them to stack the defense. Buffalo is in the "Josh Allen is the System" era, where he has to carry a massive cap hit and a rotating cast of receivers.
What Really Happened in the 2025 Preseason?
Let's talk about that 38-0 game for a second because people are still bringing it up in group chats. Caleb Williams played just two series, but he went 6-for-10 for 130 yards and a beautiful touchdown to Olamide Zaccheaus. It wasn't just that he was good; it was that the Bills' secondary, led that night by guys like Damar Hamlin, looked a step slow against Ben Johnson’s scheme.
On the other side, Buffalo’s offense was a ghost. Mitchell Trubisky—the man who knows both buildings well—couldn't get anything going, finishing with a passer rating in the 60s. Mike White wasn't much better. While Bills fans shouldn't panic about a preseason game where Josh Allen didn't take a snap, it did expose a lack of depth that haunted them later in the 2025 season.
Defensive Identities: The Turnover Factory vs. The Wall
If you want to understand the buffalo bills vs chicago bears dynamic, you have to look at the coordinators. In Chicago, the defense has turned into a literal turnover factory. In 2025, they led the league with 23 interceptions. Kevin Byard might be 32, but the guy is a magnet for the football.
Buffalo plays a different game. Under Sean McDermott, it’s about "safe" pressure. They don't always gamble for the pick, but they’ll make your life miserable in the red zone. This creates a fascinating tactical "pull" when they meet. Chicago wants to create chaos and short fields; Buffalo wants to force you into a 12-play drive and hope you get bored and make a mistake.
Looking Ahead to 2026
Mark your calendars, because the 2026 NFL schedule is already locked in for these two. Since the AFC East and NFC North are on the rotation, the Bears will be traveling to Highmark Stadium in Orchard Park.
If you’ve never been to a game in Buffalo in November or December, it’s basically a snowy gladiator pit. For a Chicago team that is used to the lakefront winds, it’s the one road trip that won’t intimidate them. We are looking at a potential "First Place vs. First Place" matchup depending on how the 2025 playoffs shake out.
Keys for the 2026 Matchup
- The Trenches: Buffalo’s offensive line took a hit with Dion Dawkins' recent injury struggles. If Chicago’s front four stays healthy, Allen will be running for his life.
- The "Burden" Factor: Keep an eye on Luther Burden III. The Bears' young wideout is becoming a nightmare for zone coverages, which is exactly what Buffalo loves to run.
- The Weather: This is a "Trench Game" specialty. Both teams are built for cold weather, which usually means the over/under will be deceptively high until the first snowflake hits.
The Actionable Takeaway for Fans
If you are betting on or just following the buffalo bills vs chicago bears narrative, stop looking at the historical "all-time" record. It doesn't matter what happened in 1994. Focus on the 2025-2026 efficiency stats.
Watch the turnover margins. Chicago is living and dying by the takeaway right now. If Josh Allen plays "clean" football, Buffalo usually wins by two scores. If he enters "chaos mode," the Bears' ball-hawking secondary will end the game by the third quarter. For the 2026 season, expect the Bills to be slight home favorites, but the value is almost always on the Chicago defense to keep it within a touchdown.
✨ Don't miss: Did Brewers Win Today: What Really Happened at American Family Field
Final Insights for the Next Matchup
The best way to prep for the next time these two meet is to monitor the injury reports specifically for the interior defensive line. Both teams rely on "clogging the middle" to force quarterbacks into bad throws. When those big bodies are out, the game opens up into a shootout.
Keep an eye on the 2026 draft needs for both teams; Buffalo is hunting for more explosive edge help, while Chicago is still looking to solidify the offensive line to protect their franchise centerpiece. This isn't just a game; it's a clash of two very different ways to build a contender in the modern NFL.