The Buffalo Bills have spent years teasing a Super Bowl parade that never quite arrives. Honestly, looking at a Buffalo Bills report card mid-season or even after a playoff exit is a bit like looking at a brilliant student who keeps failing the SATs because they got anxious in the room. They have the talent. They have the quarterback. But grading this team requires looking past the box scores and into the weird, sometimes frustrating gaps between potential and execution.
It's about Josh Allen. It's always about Josh Allen.
When you sit down to grade this roster, you’re basically grading how well the front office has surrounded a generational talent with enough support to survive the gauntlet of the AFC. Some years, they look like an A+ powerhouse that could flatten anyone. Other times, the coaching staff deserves a C- for game management that feels like they're playing "not to lose" instead of going for the throat.
The Quarterback Curve: Josh Allen is the Entire Grading Scale
If you’re grading the quarterback position, it’s an easy A, but it’s a complicated A. Josh Allen is the only player in NFL history who can make a play so spectacular it defies physics and then, three minutes later, throw a ball into triple coverage that makes you want to put your head through a wall.
Critics like to harp on the interceptions. They point to the "sugar high" Josh that Sean McDermott has mentioned in the past. But here is the reality: without Allen, this team isn't even a B- squad. He carries the rushing attack, the vertical passing game, and the emotional weight of Western New York.
During the 2024 season transitions, we saw a shift. Joe Brady took over the offensive coordinator duties full-time, and the Buffalo Bills report card for the offense started to look different. It became less about "Josh, save us" and more about "Everyone touch the ball."
- The "Everybody Eats" philosophy.
- Khalil Shakir becoming a third-down machine.
- Dalton Kincaid’s growth as a focal point.
- James Cook finally proving he’s a true RB1.
But when the lights get brightest, the grade still depends on whether Allen has to do too much. When the offensive line holds up, he's a God. When they don't, the grade tanks because the backup situation in Buffalo has historically been... well, let's just say "incomplete."
Coaching and the McDermott Glass Ceiling
Sean McDermott is a polarizing figure for a guy who wins ten-plus games every year. You have to give him an A for culture. He took a franchise that was a literal joke for seventeen years and turned it into a perennial contender. That matters.
💡 You might also like: El Salvador partido de hoy: Why La Selecta is at a Critical Turning Point
However, the game-day management often drags down the overall Buffalo Bills report card.
Think about the "13 Seconds" debacle in Kansas City. Think about the 12-men-on-the-field penalty against Denver. These are the "F" moments that stay on a permanent record. McDermott is a defensive mastermind, but his critics argue that his defensive-minded conservatism often clashes with the aggressive nature of his superstar quarterback.
He’s a great floor raiser. Is he a ceiling lifter? That’s the question that keeps Bills Mafia up at night.
The Defensive Rebuild: Passing the Test Under Pressure
Last year, everyone expected the defense to fall off a cliff. Matt Milano went down. Tre’Davious White was gone. Jordan Poyer and Micah Hyde—the legendary safety duo—finally reached the end of an era.
Somehow, the grade stayed high.
- Bobby Babich's influence: The defensive coordinator transition was seamless.
- Terrel Bernard: He isn't just a "good" linebacker; he’s arguably the brain of the entire unit.
- Rasul Douglas: The mid-season trade from Green Bay was a masterstroke by GM Brandon Beane.
The defensive line is where the grades get wonky. Ed Oliver earns his paycheck in bursts. He'll have a game where he looks like Aaron Donald, followed by two weeks where he’s relatively quiet. Greg Rousseau is a stud against the run, but the fan base is still waiting for that 15-sack "A+" season that his physical traits suggest is possible. Von Miller’s contract vs. his actual production post-ACL surgery is, frankly, one of the few "D" grades on the roster simply because of the cap hit.
The Skill Positions: Life After Stefon Diggs
When the Bills traded Stefon Diggs to Houston, the national media gave the Buffalo Bills report card a failing grade before the season even started. "Who is Josh going to throw to?" they asked.
📖 Related: Meaning of Grand Slam: Why We Use It for Tennis, Baseball, and Breakfast
Turns out, the answer was "literally whoever is open."
By removing a target-dominant WR1, the offense actually became harder to defend. Khalil Shakir’s catch rate is borderline absurd. Keon Coleman, the rookie out of Florida State, brought a physical jump-ball element that Diggs lacked.
But there’s a nuance here. In a tight playoff game against a team like the Ravens or the Chiefs, do you miss having a guy who demands a double-team? Probably. The "WR by committee" approach is a great regular-season strategy, but it’s a B+ strategy in a world where you need an A+ to beat Patrick Mahomes.
Special Teams and the "Kicker Problem"
Tyler Bass was once the most reliable part of the Bills' scoring machine. Lately, the "Buffalo Bills report card" for special teams has been a rollercoaster. The miss against the Chiefs in the playoffs was a heartbreaker. It wasn't just the miss; it was the loss of confidence that seemed to linger.
Special teams coach Matthew Smiley has had to navigate a lot of turnover. The return game with Brandon Codrington showed flashes of life, but the kicking game remains the one area where Bills fans hold their breath every time the ball is snapped. You can't win a Super Bowl with a "maybe" at kicker.
The Front Office: Brandon Beane’s Salary Cap Gymnastics
You have to respect the hustle. Brandon Beane has had to navigate a "cap hell" scenario that would have ruined lesser franchises. He’s the reason the Buffalo Bills report card stays respectable year after year.
He finds gems in the middle rounds.
He isn't afraid to admit a mistake and move on (see: Diggs, Tre White).
He manages the roster like a chess player, always thinking two moves ahead.
👉 See also: NFL Week 5 2025 Point Spreads: What Most People Get Wrong
The only "C" on his resume lately is the lack of a knockout punch in free agency for a true interior defensive presence or a high-end edge rusher that doesn't cost $20 million a year. But given what he’s had to work with, he’s an honors student.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Bills
People look at the Bills and see "chokers." That’s a lazy grade.
The reality is that the Bills are operating in an era with the greatest quarterback to ever play (Mahomes) and a conference that is deeper than it has been in decades. Their "failure" is losing by three points in the divisional round. For 28 other teams, that’s a dream season.
A fair Buffalo Bills report card acknowledges that they are a top-5 organization in the NFL. They are consistently well-prepared, high-scoring, and resilient. But in Buffalo, "B+" isn't passing anymore. It's Super Bowl or bust.
Actionable Insights for Following the Bills
- Watch the Pre-Snap Motion: Under Joe Brady, the Bills' grade improves when they use heavy motion to identify man vs. zone for Josh Allen. If the offense looks static, the grade is dropping.
- Monitor the Sack-to-Pressure Ratio: The Bills often get pressure but fail to finish the sack. Improving this "finisher" grade is the key to a deep playoff run.
- Track Second-Half Adjustments: Historically, the Bills' report card dips in the third quarter. Watch if the coaching staff can evolve their mid-game strategy to avoid those "lulls" that let teams back into games.
- Focus on the Injury Report: Because the Bills rely so heavily on specific "glue guys" like Matt Milano and Terrel Bernard, their team grade can swing from an A to a C based on just two names on the injury list.
The Buffalo Bills remain a fascinating study in excellence versus the ultimate prize. They are a team that does almost everything right, yet finds themselves constantly searching for that final 2% that turns a "Great" report card into a "Champion" one.
Keep a close eye on the development of the younger core—Kincaid, Bernard, and Coleman. Their ability to graduate from "promising" to "elite" will determine if the next Buffalo Bills report card finally comes with a trophy.
Next Steps for Bills Analysis:
Evaluate the current cap space heading into the next draft cycle. Look specifically at the safety position and the aging veteran contracts on the defensive line. These are the areas where the "grade" must improve through cheap, rookie-scale talent if the team wants to remain competitive while paying Josh Allen's massive (and deserved) contract.