Buffalo just wrapped up a regular season that felt like a fever dream. If you only looked at the final scores, you'd see a 12-5 record and think, "Business as usual for Josh Allen." But honestly? The Buffalo Bills game statistics tell a much weirder story than the win-loss column suggests.
They didn't win the AFC East. That hurts.
For the first time since 2019, the New England Patriots (of all teams) snatched the division crown with a 14-3 run. Yet, if you look at the raw efficiency data from the 2025 season, the Bills were arguably the better team on paper. They finished with a point differential that makes you double-check the math: 481 points for and 365 against. That is a +116 margin.
In most universes, that kind of dominance wins you a division. In this one, it just got them the No. 6 seed and a plane ticket to Jacksonville for the Wild Card round.
The Rushing Revolution Nobody Saw Coming
Everyone expects Josh Allen to throw for 4,000 yards. He almost did—finishing with 3,668 yards and 25 passing touchdowns. But the real "holy crap" moment in the 2025 Buffalo Bills game statistics is the ground game.
Buffalo finished the regular season with the No. 1 ranked rushing offense in the NFL. Read that again. Not the Ravens. Not the Niners. The Bills.
James Cook didn't just have a "good" year; he won the NFL rushing title. He carried the rock 309 times for a massive 1,621 yards. He averaged 5.2 yards every time he touched the ball. It’s wild because Buffalo has spent years trying to find a consistent back to take the pressure off Allen, and they finally found him in a guy who looks like he’s gliding through the secondary.
Then you have Josh Allen himself.
The guy is a cheat code. He led the league with 14 rushing touchdowns. If you're a defensive coordinator, how do you even plan for that? You stop Cook, and Allen just lowers his shoulder and barrels into the end zone. The Bills tied a franchise record this year with 13 consecutive regular-season games with a rushing touchdown.
It was relentless.
Why the Defense is Sneakier Than You Think
People talk about the "bend-but-don't-break" style, but Bobby Babich’s unit was actually statistically elite in areas that usually go unnoticed.
- They allowed only 2,668 passing yards all season.
- That’s 156.9 yards per game.
- That was the best mark in the entire league.
You’ve got Cole Bishop, the second-year safety, basically playing like a veteran. He led the team with 85 tackles and grabbed 3 interceptions. And let’s talk about Joey Bosa. Bringing him in was a gamble given his age and injury history, but he finished with 5 sacks and a ridiculous 5 forced fumbles. He’s a specialist at this point, but a terrifying one.
What Really Happened in the Playoffs?
The Wild Card game against the Jaguars was a microcosm of the whole season. Buffalo won 27-24, but it was stressful.
The Buffalo Bills game statistics for that matchup show exactly why this team is so hard to kill. Josh Allen willed them to victory despite taking multiple trips to the sideline for medical checks. He didn't have a massive passing day, but he had two short rushing touchdowns that were essentially the difference.
And Khalil Shakir? Man, he’s become the ultimate "reliable" target. Against the Jags, Allen threw his way 12 times. Shakir caught every single one of them. 12 for 12. That’s a career high in a game where the pressure was high enough to crack most players.
The win was historic, too. It was Buffalo's first road playoff victory since 1992.
The Winter Win Streak and the "New" Identity
There is a stat that Brandon Beane probably has framed in his office: the Bills are 27-5 in regular-season games played in December and January since 2020.
They are the ultimate "cold weather" team, even when they’re playing on the road. This year, they won their first game in Cleveland since 2012 and finally beat a Joe Burrow-led Bengals team.
But there’s a nuance here most people miss. While the offense gets the headlines, the team’s ability to control the clock has changed. They averaged 3:14 per drive. That leads the NFL. Basically, when the Bills have the lead, they are now equipped to just suffocate you with James Cook and a massive offensive line.
✨ Don't miss: ESPN Week 9 NFL Picks: Why the Experts Got it So Wrong
It’s not as "flashy" as the 13-second-era Bills, but it might be more sustainable for a deep run.
Actionable Insights for Bills Fans and Analysts
If you are looking at the Buffalo Bills game statistics to figure out what happens next, keep an eye on these three specific metrics:
- Third Down Efficiency: The Bills converted at a 44.8% clip this year. When that number stays above 40%, they almost never lose.
- Turnover Margin: They finished with a +1 turnover ratio. It's not great, but it’s a huge improvement over the mid-season slump where Allen was throwing picks like they were gifts.
- Red Zone Rushing: 30 of their 62 touchdowns came on the ground. If they can't run the ball inside the 20, the offense stalls.
The road ahead is brutal. They have to go into Denver to face a Broncos defense that has been playing out of its mind. But if the stats tell us anything, it’s that this version of the Bills doesn't need Josh Allen to do everything. They just need him to be the closer.
To get the most out of following the postseason, monitor the "Yards After Contact" (YAC) for James Cook. During the regular season, he averaged 2.2 yards after contact. If Denver's linebackers can't wrap him up on the first hit, Buffalo will likely control the tempo and walk out of Mile High with another win.
Check the official NFL GSIS (Game Statistics and Information System) reports after the Divisional round to see if the Bills maintained their No. 1 rushing status under playoff pressure.