Honestly, walking into the Gerald Schoenfeld Theatre feels less like taking a seat for a Broadway play and more like stumbling into a late-night session at a hidden Havana studio. You’ve probably heard the album. Maybe you’ve seen the Wim Wenders documentary where those legendary Cuban musicians, then in their 80s and 90s, finally got their global flowers. But the Buena Vista Social Club play Broadway Off Broadway journey is something different entirely. It’s not a museum piece. It’s a loud, sweaty, rhythm-soaked reclamation of history that doesn’t care if you speak Spanish or not.
The music hits you first. It’s unavoidable. The 12-piece band isn't hidden in a pit; they are the heart of the stage, front and center. When that first note of "Chan Chan" rings out, you realize this isn't just another jukebox musical trying to capitalize on nostalgia. It’s a technical and emotional feat that somehow survived the leap from the intimate Atlantic Theater Company Off-Broadway to the big leagues of midtown Manhattan without losing its soul.
Why the Jump from Off-Broadway to the Schoenfeld Actually Worked
Most shows lose their "cool" when they move to Broadway. They get polished until they’re shiny and sterile. Fortunately, director Saheem Ali and book writer Marco Ramirez (who wrote the incredible The Royale) didn't let that happen here. When the production lived at the Atlantic’s Linda Gross Theater in 2023, it was a hot ticket because of its grit. It felt like a secret.
The Broadway version, which opened in March 2025, actually leaned harder into the history. They tightened the "slender" plot—Ramirez basically cut a gun-running subplot and focused on what actually matters: the friction between the musicians. You've got two timelines happening at once. One is 1956, right as the Cuban Revolution is bubbling over, and the other is 1996, when Juan de Marcos González is trying to get the old gang back together to record that landmark album.
The Duel of the Omaras
The show revolves around Omara Portuondo. In the 90s timeline, she’s played by Natalie Venetia Belcon (who won a Tony for this, by the way). She’s regal. She’s guarded. Then you have Isa Antonetti playing the younger Omara, a woman trying to find her voice while her sister Haydee dreams of the glitzy, tourist-heavy Tropicana.
📖 Related: Who is Really in the Enola Holmes 2 Cast? A Look at the Faces Behind the Mystery
Watching the two Omaras mirror each other across forty years is... well, it’s haunting. There is a specific moment where they almost overlap while singing a bolero that makes the hair on your arms stand up. It’s not just about "the good old days." It’s about the people who stayed in Cuba, the people who left, and the music that survived the silence in between.
The "Spanish Problem" (That Isn't a Problem)
One of the biggest gambles this show took was keeping every single song in Spanish. No subtitles. No clunky English translations to make it "accessible" for the tourists. Basically, the creators trusted the audience.
And it pays off. You don't need to know the literal translation of "Dos Gardenias" to understand the heartache dripping off the stage. If anything, translating these songs would have killed the vibe. The rhythm is the language. If you're sitting there worrying about the libretto, you're missing the point. The show treats the music as a character that doesn't need a translator.
A Masterclass in Movement
You can't talk about the Buena Vista Social Club play Broadway Off Broadway transition without mentioning the choreography. Patricia Delgado and Justin Peck (the guy who did Illinoise and Spielberg’s West Side Story) created something that feels improvised but is actually incredibly complex.
👉 See also: Priyanka Chopra Latest Movies: Why Her 2026 Slate Is Riskier Than You Think
- It’s a mix of Afro-Cuban folk.
- There's classic ballroom elegance.
- You see the gritty, street-level energy of Havana.
- The dancers move through the band like they’re part of the orchestration.
It never feels like a "dance break." It feels like the only possible way these people could express what they’re feeling when the words run out.
What Critics Got Wrong About the "Wispy" Plot
Some critics complained that the story is a bit thin. They’re not entirely wrong, but they’re also missing the forest for the trees. This isn't Les Mis. It’s a concept musical. The "plot" is the act of creation. It’s about the literal physical effort of Ibrahim Ferrer (played by the soulful Mel Semé) and Compay Segundo (Julio Monge) finding their spark again after decades of being forgotten by the world.
The tension isn't in some manufactured drama; it’s in the weight of the years. When the older Ibrahim sings "Bruca Manigua," he isn't just singing a song; he’s reclaiming his identity. That’s the "action." If you’re looking for a complex three-act structure with multiple twists, you’re in the wrong theater. But if you want to see the exact moment a human soul catches fire again, this is it.
The Real Stars: The Musicians
We have to talk about the band. These aren't just Broadway pit players. They are world-class instrumentalists.
✨ Don't miss: Why This Is How We Roll FGL Is Still The Song That Defines Modern Country
- Marco Paguia (Music Director/Piano): He keeps the whole engine running.
- Renesito Avich: His work on the Tres guitar is worth the price of admission alone.
- Hery Paz: The flute solo in "Candela" is basically a religious experience.
The production even won a Special Tony Award for the band. That never happens. It tells you everything you need to know about where the priorities of this show lie.
Planning Your Visit: The Practical Stuff
If you’re heading to the Schoenfeld, here’s the deal. The show runs about 2 hours and 10 minutes with one intermission. It’s a fast 130 minutes.
- Seat Selection: Honestly, try to get as close as possible. This is a show about intimacy. You want to see the sweat on the percussionists.
- The Booklet: Look for the nine-page illustrated booklet in the Playbill. It explains the history of 15 songs in the show. Read it during intermission; it adds a whole layer of depth to the second act.
- Tickets: As of early 2026, tickets are on sale through May. It’s still a tough get on weekends, so aim for a Tuesday or Wednesday night if you want to avoid the $300 premium markups.
The Buena Vista Social Club play Broadway Off Broadway arc is a rare success story. It proved that you don't need to "Americanize" a story to make it a hit. You just need to tell it with enough heart and enough bass to make the floorboards shake.
To truly appreciate the show, listen to the original 1997 album one more time before you go. Pay attention to Ibrahim Ferrer’s voice—that grainy, beautiful texture. Then, when you see Mel Semé channel that same energy on stage, you’ll realize why this story had to be told in a theater. It’s a ghost story where the ghosts are finally allowed to dance.
Check the official Broadway website for the latest casting updates, as several understudies have been stepping into the principal roles this season and are receiving rave reviews of their own. If you have the chance to see Natalie Toro as the Omara understudy, take it—she brings a completely different, equally powerful energy to the role.
Next Step: You should listen to the 2025 Broadway Cast Recording alongside the original 1997 album to hear how Marco Paguia reimagined the orchestrations for a live theatrical space.