You’ve seen the signs before. Every suburb in the tri-state area has a "Brooklyn" pizza joint. Usually, it’s just a marketing gimmick—a way to trick people into thinking they’re getting a coal-fired masterpiece when they’re actually getting a floppy, grease-soaked mess that tastes like cardboard. But Brooklyn Pizza in Jackson, NJ, is a weird outlier in the best possible way. Located in the Bennett Commons shopping center on County Line Road, it’s the kind of place that shouldn't be this good given its proximity to a ShopRite.
It's busy. Seriously.
If you walk in on a Friday night, the air is thick with the smell of bubbling mozzarella and that specific, slightly charred scent of dough hitting a hot deck. It’s loud. It’s chaotic. It’s exactly what a neighborhood pizzeria is supposed to be. Most people in Jackson have their "spot," but this place has managed to build a cult following that extends way beyond the township borders. Honestly, it’s about the crust. While most Jersey Shore-adjacent pizza suffers from being too doughy or too sweet, the pies here lean into that thin, crispy, slightly salty profile that defines the actual five boroughs.
What People Get Wrong About Brooklyn Pizza Jackson NJ
A lot of folks assume that because it’s in a suburban strip mall, it’s going to be generic. They expect the "New York Style" label to be a suggestion rather than a rule. That's mistake number one. When you order a plain pie here, you aren't getting a thick, bread-like base. You’re getting something with a structural integrity that would make an architect weep.
The fold is the test. You know the one. You pick up a slice, fold it down the middle, and if the tip of the slice doesn’t sag like a wet noodle, you’ve found a winner. At Brooklyn Pizza Jackson NJ, the crunch is audible. It's not just about being thin, though; it's about the ratio. They don't drown the dough in cheap sauce. Instead, they use a bright, slightly acidic tomato base that cuts through the fat of the cheese.
💡 You might also like: Human DNA Found in Hot Dogs: What Really Happened and Why You Shouldn’t Panic
The Grandma Pie Obsession
If you haven't tried the Grandma pie here, you’re basically doing it wrong. It’s a square, but don't call it a Sicilian. It’s thinner, denser, and topped with streaks of marinara and fresh basil. Most pizzerias mess this up by making the crust too oily, basically frying the bottom of the dough until it’s a brick. Here? It’s crunchy on the bottom but still has a bit of chew in the middle.
People travel from Howell and Toms River just for this specific square. It’s become a bit of a local legend. Why? Because they don't skimp on the garlic. You’ll breathe it for two days, and you won’t even care.
Why the Location Matters (and Why It Doesn't)
Jackson is a massive town geographically. You’ve got the Great Adventure crowds, the commuters heading to North Jersey, and the local families who have been there for generations. Bennett Commons isn't exactly the "downtown" of anything, but being at 2105 West County Line Road puts it right in the crosshairs of daily life.
It's a hub.
📖 Related: The Gospel of Matthew: What Most People Get Wrong About the First Book of the New Testament
You’ll see kids in soccer uniforms, guys in work boots, and seniors who have probably been eating the same slice since the place opened. That’s the E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness) of the pizza world. When a place is consistently packed with locals who have ten other options within a three-mile radius, you know the quality isn't a fluke.
The Menu Beyond the Slice
While the name says pizza, the kitchen puts out some surprisingly heavy-hitting Italian-American classics. Let’s talk about the wings for a second. Most pizza places serve wings that feel like an afterthought—soggy, tiny, and tossed in a generic bottled sauce. The wings here actually have some skin-snap to them.
Then there's the pasta.
- Penne alla Vodka that isn't just a pink cream soup.
- Chicken Parm portions that could feed a small army.
- Calzones that are actually baked through, not raw in the center.
It's easy to get distracted by the fancy specialty pies—the Buffalo Chicken or the Salad Pizza (which is still a confusing concept to many, though popular)—but the "Old Fashioned" pie is where the real skill shows. It’s a reverse-layered situation where the cheese goes down first, then the sauce on top. This prevents the dough from getting soggy and creates these little caramelized pockets of tomato that are incredibly addictive.
👉 See also: God Willing and the Creek Don't Rise: The True Story Behind the Phrase Most People Get Wrong
The Reality of the Suburban Pizza War
Jackson, NJ is a literal battlefield for pizzerias. You have competition at every corner. To survive here for years, a business has to be more than just "fine." It has to be reliable. Brooklyn Pizza Jackson NJ has maintained its reputation by staying consistent. That is the hardest thing to do in the food business. Anyone can make a great pie once; making a great pie 400 times a day, seven days a week, is a different animal entirely.
Some critics might say the wait times can get a bit long on weekends. They aren't wrong. If you call in an order at 6:00 PM on a Saturday, don't expect it to be ready in fifteen minutes. That’s just the tax you pay for eating at a place everyone else wants to eat at, too.
Actionable Tips for Your First Visit
Don't just walk in and grab whatever is under the glass. To get the best experience, follow the "local" playbook.
First, check the specials board. They often do seasonal things or weird experimental slices that aren't on the printed menu. Second, if you're ordering a whole pie, ask for it "well done" if you like that extra charred New York snap. Third, don't sleep on the garlic knots. They are heavy on the parsley and oil, exactly like they should be.
If you are planning a large order for a party, call it in at least two hours early. The kitchen is efficient, but the volume they handle is insane. Also, keep in mind that parking in Bennett Commons can be a bit of a nightmare during peak hours, so give yourself an extra five minutes to find a spot that isn't a mile away.
Basically, if you want authentic flavor without driving to the Verrazzano, this is the spot. It's unassuming, it’s loud, and it’s arguably the most consistent slice in Ocean County. Grab a napkin—you’re gonna need it.