You’re hanging out in a classic Roblox hangout game, maybe trying to relive the 2015 era, when suddenly you hear it. A high-pitched, digital cackle. Then a bubbling sound. It repeats every few seconds, relentless and unyielding. You look around, and there’s an avatar sporting a grey cap with two neon-green soda cans strapped to the sides, tubes running straight into their head. That, honestly, is the Brighteyes' Witches Brew Hat, and it might be one of the most polarizing items ever coded into the platform.
Most people see a hat and think "cosmetic." In Roblox, that’s usually the case. But back in the mid-2010s, the developers were experimenting with items that actually did things. This specific hat doesn't just sit there looking spooky; it makes noise. A lot of it. For collectors, it’s a nostalgic badge of honor from a 2015 Halloween event. For everyone else in the server? It’s basically a localized audio assault.
The 2015 Halloween Origin Story
October 2015 was a weirdly productive time for Roblox. They released the "Joyless Gift of the Saddest Eyes," a mysterious present that cost 700 Robux. In the world of Roblox "Gifts," you’d buy the box and wait for it to "open" on a specific date. On October 16th, that box popped open and revealed the Brighteyes' Witches Brew Hat.
It was named after Brighteyes (Christina McGrath), a former Roblox employee and a legendary figure in the community who eventually married Shedletsky. If the design looks familiar, that’s because it’s a direct retexture of her previous iconic item, the Brighteyes' Bloxy Cola Hat. Instead of the classic red and white soda cans, this one went full "witchy" with grey fabric and glowing green Witches Brew cans.
Actually, the design is a pretty clear nod to the Bonk Helm from Team Fortress 2. Roblox has a long history of "borrowing" aesthetics from Valve, and this was no exception. But while the TF2 version just looked cool, the Roblox version had a trick up its sleeve.
📖 Related: Is the PlayStation 5 Slim Console Digital Edition Actually Worth It?
Why It’s the Only "Off-Sale" Sound Hat You’ll See
Here is the thing that most people get wrong about "sound items" on Roblox. Most of them are either Limiteds—meaning they can be traded for absurd amounts of Robux—or they’re modern UGC items that have since been moderated.
The Brighteyes' Witches Brew Hat is a unicorn. It is:
- Off-sale: You cannot buy it anymore.
- Non-limited: You can’t trade for it. If you didn't get it in 2015, you’re out of luck.
- Active: It still produces sound to this day.
Every 5 to 15 seconds, the hat triggers one of three sounds: a witch’s laugh, a bubbling cauldron noise, or a short, eerie tune. The kicker? Everyone nearby hears it. In 2024, Roblox even showcased the hat during the Innovation Awards in a segment called "Hey! Gimme That Limited!", giving it a modern PBR (Physically Based Rendering) makeover for the livestream. It’s one of only four known items in the entire catalog that creates ambient sound, alongside Telamon’s Chicken Suit, the Transient Harmonica, and the original Bloxy Cola Hat.
The Love-Hate Relationship with Developers
If you talk to veteran game devs, they usually have a bone to pick with this hat. Imagine spending weeks balancing the audio of your horror game, only for a player to walk in wearing a hat that plays a "NYE-HE-HE" laugh every ten seconds. It breaks the immersion. It’s distracting.
👉 See also: How to Solve 6x6 Rubik's Cube Without Losing Your Mind
For years, there have been threads on the DevForum asking for a way to "mute" specific accessories. Because the sound is baked into the item’s script, it’s not always easy for a casual developer to disable without specifically targeting that AssetID.
But for the owners? That’s the point. It’s a flex. It says, "I was there for the 2015 Halloween event, I spent 700 Robux on a sad-looking gift, and now you have to listen to my soda cans bubble."
Is It Actually Rare?
Rarity in Roblox is a moving target. According to Rolimon’s data, the "Joyless Gift of the Saddest Eyes" was purchased about 3,589 times before it went off-sale. Compared to modern items that sell millions of copies, that’s a tiny number. However, since it isn't a "Limited," there isn't a public "Value" assigned to it in the trading community.
You can't sell it for a million Robux like you can with a Dominus. It sits in your inventory, a permanent part of your collection. Its value is purely social. It’s a piece of "old Roblox" history that still functions exactly as it did nearly a decade ago.
✨ Don't miss: How Orc Names in Skyrim Actually Work: It's All About the Bloodline
What to Do If You See (or Want) One
Honestly, if you’re looking to get your hands on the original Brighteyes' Witches Brew Hat today, you're basically out of luck unless you buy an account that already has it—which, let's be real, is a great way to get banned. However, the rise of the UGC (User Generated Content) program means there are dozens of "tribute" versions and "Witch Brew Caps" available for under 100 Robux.
The catch? Most modern UGC hats aren't allowed to play ambient sound loops like the original. Roblox cracked down on that to prevent people from making "loud" hats that ruin the experience for others. The original 2015 version is grandfathered in.
Your Next Steps:
- Check Your Inventory: If you played in 2015, search your "Hats" category. You might be sitting on one of the few sound-emitting items left on the platform.
- Mute Your Audio: If you're a developer dealing with "noise griefers," look into scripting a filter that removes
Soundobjects fromAccessoryattachments upon player character load. - Browse the Catalog: If you just like the aesthetic, search for "Witches Brew" in the marketplace. You won't get the cackle, but you'll get the look for a fraction of the historical cost.
The Brighteyes' Witches Brew Hat isn't just an accessory. It’s a loud, bubbling reminder of a time when Roblox was a bit more chaotic and a lot more experimental. It’s annoying, sure, but the platform would be a lot quieter—and a lot more boring—without it.