If you were scrolling through social media the morning after the Bridgerton Season 3 finale, you probably saw the digital equivalent of a Regency-era riot. The "ton" was absolutely buzzing. Why? Because the show finally pulled the trigger on a massive book-to-screen deviation that had been whispered about for months. The introduction of Michaela Stirling didn't just add a new face to the cast; it fundamentally reframed Bridgerton Francesca gay theories into a confirmed reality for the show’s future.
Honestly, it’s been a lot to process.
For the uninitiated, or those who haven't spent hours poring over Julia Quinn's When He Was Wicked, Francesca’s story is famously the most "grown-up" of the bunch. It’s a story about grief, infertility, and a second chance at love with her late husband's cousin, Michael Stirling. But in the final moments of Season 3, Michael became Michaela, played by the talented Masali Baduza.
And just like that, the fandom split right down the middle.
What Actually Happened in the Season 3 Finale?
The scene itself was pretty quick. Francesca, now the Countess of Kilmartin, is preparing to leave for Scotland with her new husband, John Stirling. They’re standing at a ball when John introduces her to his cousin.
The moment Francesca lays eyes on Michaela, she freezes. She literally forgets her own name.
👉 See also: Nothing to Lose: Why the Martin Lawrence and Tim Robbins Movie is Still a 90s Classic
It’s a stark contrast to her wedding kiss with John just episodes earlier, which felt... well, fine. It was sweet. It was comfortable. But the reaction to Michaela? That was the "thunderbolt" Violet Bridgerton always talks about. For many fans, this confirmed that the show is leaning into a "compulsory heterosexuality" arc, where Francesca cared for John but didn't feel that visceral, bone-deep passion until she met a woman.
Why the Michaela Stirling Gender-Swap is Such a Big Deal
You’ve gotta understand why book purists are so protective of this specific story. Michael Stirling is often cited as the "ultimate" Bridgerton hero. He’s the "Merry Rake" who has been pining for his cousin’s wife for years.
By making the character a woman, showrunner Jess Brownell has basically signaled that the TV version of Francesca’s story will be a queer romance. This is a huge shift. It’s not just about changing a name; it changes the mechanics of the "forbidden" love. In the books, the guilt comes from Michael loving his cousin's widow. In the show, that guilt will likely be layered with the social taboos of a sapphic relationship in the 1800s.
The "Feelings Differently" Connection
Jess Brownell mentioned in several interviews that she felt Francesca’s book actually paved the way for this. In the novels, Francesca always feels a bit like an outsider in her own family. She’s quieter. She prefers the silence.
While Julia Quinn wrote that as introversion, Brownell—who is queer herself—read it as a classic "coded" experience. She saw a character who didn't quite fit the mold and realized it was a perfect opportunity for LGBTQ+ representation.
✨ Don't miss: How Old Is Paul Heyman? The Real Story of Wrestling’s Greatest Mind
The Backlash: It's Not Just About "The Book"
Let's be real—the reaction hasn't been 100% positive. If you look at Reddit or Instagram, there’s a lot of "Justice for Michael" posting.
Some fans feel like they’ve been "robbed" of a favorite male lead. Others are worried about how the show will handle the infertility plotline. In When He Was Wicked, Francesca’s desperate desire for a child is a massive part of her identity. People are asking: how does that work with two women in the Regency era?
There’s also the critique of Francesca’s reaction. In the book, Michael falls first. He’s the one who is devastated by her beauty while she’s still happily married to John. In the show, it seems like Francesca is the one having the "gay panic" while John is still very much alive and standing right next to her. For some, that felt like it undercut her love for John, which Julia Quinn herself had to defend in a lengthy Instagram post.
"I actually had to fight to have the first four chapters [of the book], which establish that love [for John], included... I'm confident now that when Francesca has her Bridgerton season, it will be the most emotional and heart-wrenching story of the show." — Julia Quinn
The "Boston Marriage" and Historical Context
So, how does a queer Francesca get a "Happily Ever After" in a world where she’s expected to produce an heir?
🔗 Read more: Howie Mandel Cupcake Picture: What Really Happened With That Viral Post
Historically, women of means sometimes entered into what were called "Boston Marriages." These were long-term cohabitating relationships between two women, often accepted by society under the guise of "close friendship" or "companionship."
Since Francesca is now a Dowager Countess with her own estate in Scotland, she actually has more freedom than most. She’s already "done her duty" by marrying. Once she’s a widow, she doesn't necessarily have to remarry a man to maintain her status. This gives the writers a "loophole" to let her and Michaela live together at Kilmartin without the constant threat of a scandal ruining the entire Bridgerton name.
What This Means for Season 4 and Beyond
We don't know for sure if Francesca will be the lead of Season 4. Most signs point to Benedict (who also had some queer exploration this season) or Eloise. But Michaela Stirling is officially part of the inner circle now. She’s traveling to Scotland with the newlyweds.
This means we’re going to see the friendship—and the tension—build over a long period.
It’s a slow burn. A very slow burn.
Key Points to Remember:
- Francesca is likely bisexual or gay: Her reaction to Michaela was the first time we saw her truly "starstruck" by a person.
- The "Michael" from the books is gone: Masali Baduza is our Michaela, and she’s here to stay.
- The themes remain: The showrunners insist they will still tackle grief, second chances, and "feeling different," even if the gender roles have shifted.
- Julia Quinn gave the green light: Despite the fan outcry, the creator of the series is on board with the change.
Honestly, it’s a gutsy move for a show that usually plays it pretty safe with its central romances. Whether you love the change or hate it, you can't deny that it has made Francesca—previously the "forgotten" Bridgerton—the most talked-about sibling in the entire series.
Next Steps for Fans
If you’re struggling with the change, your best bet is to go back and read When He Was Wicked to appreciate the original Michael Stirling, but keep an open mind for the show. Keep an eye on casting news for Season 4, as the production schedule will likely reveal how much screen time Michaela gets in the lead-up to her and Francesca's eventual "Happily Ever After."