In 1995, Brian Wheeler was basically just a guy with a car he didn’t need and a $20,000 loan from his dad. He was 25, fresh out of the University of Central Florida, and had exactly zero experience running a restaurant. Most people would call that a recipe for a disaster. Instead, it became the foundation for Tijuana Flats, a brand that eventually defined the "fast-casual" Tex-Mex scene across the Southeast for nearly three decades.
But if you’ve walked into a Flats lately, things feel different. Maybe a little quieter. Maybe the menu looks a bit "corporate."
There’s a reason for that. Brian Wheeler hasn't been at the helm for a long time.
The story of Brian Wheeler Tijuana Flats isn't just about burritos and hot sauce—though there was plenty of both. It’s a case study in what happens when a "founder-led" culture meets the cold, hard reality of private equity and bankruptcy court. Honestly, it’s kind of a heartbreak for anyone who grew up eating at the original Winter Park location.
The $20,000 Gamble and the "Smack My Ass" Era
Brian didn't have a business plan. Not really. He had a vibe. He wanted a place that felt like a bar but served food that didn't suck. He modeled the original concept after Burrito Brothers in Gainesville—a legendary spot for UF students—because he loved that laid-back, "anything goes" atmosphere.
The first shop opened in a strip mall. It was small. It was gritty. Brian was the one rolling the burritos and, as he later admitted, he didn't realize how much the "closing shift" actually involved until he was doing it himself at 2:00 AM.
Then came the hot sauce.
You can't talk about Brian Wheeler Tijuana Flats without mentioning the sauce bar. Brian created the "Smack My Ass & Call Me Sally" line, which, let's be real, was a bold move in the 90s. It wasn't just about the heat; it was about the attitude. That "over-the-top" personality is what made the brand explode. By 1999, he’d caught the eye of Camp Fitch, a retired restaurant exec who saw the potential for systems and scale. Together with Brian’s dad, Chester (who left a Fortune 500 career to be the CFO), they turned a college-town taco joint into a regional powerhouse.
When Private Equity Stepped In
For twenty years, Brian Wheeler was the heart of the brand. By 2015, Tijuana Flats had grown to over 140 locations and employed 3,000 people. It was a massive success story.
But 2015 was also the year everything changed.
Brian sold the company to AUA Private Equity Partners. At the time, he felt confident. He figured they had the resources to take the brand to the next level. "I had confidence in the new management's capability," he’d later say. But as is often the case when a founder exits, the "soul" of the business started to drift.
📖 Related: Opening a Coffee Shop: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grind
The Divergence of Vision
Once the original leadership was gone, the "mature" look started to take over. The hand-painted murals by artist Christopher Galipeau—which featured weird characters like a giant green god—were iconic. After Galipeau passed away, the company tried to replicate the style, but it never felt quite the same.
The new owners started tinkering with the menu. By 2021, they introduced major changes hoping to boost sales. According to bankruptcy court documents, it did the exact opposite. Customers who loved the "old Flats" felt alienated. The food became "over-engineered."
The 2024 Bankruptcy: What Really Happened?
In April 2024, the news hit like a ton of bricks. Tijuana Flats filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy and immediately shut down 11 locations. It was bought by a group called Flatheads, LLC.
Brian Wheeler didn't hold back when asked about it. He told news outlets it was "heartbreaking" to see the decline of something he’d devoted most of his life to. He explicitly blamed the downturn on decisions made post-sale that diverged from the original vision.
💡 You might also like: Bill Ballard Birmingham AL: The Media Veteran Behind the Magic City Scenes
- Food Costs: Inflation hit the restaurant industry hard in 2023 and 2024.
- Labor: Finding and keeping staff became an expensive nightmare.
- Identity Crisis: The brand tried to be too many things to too many people.
As of early 2026, the chain is still operating under new management (led by CEO James Greco), trying to "return to its roots." They’ve been trimming the menu and focusing on quality again. But for many fans, the Brian Wheeler Tijuana Flats era is a relic of the past.
Brian's New Chapter: Big Taco and the Return to Simple
Brian Wheeler isn't exactly sitting around retired, though. He’s back in the kitchen—sort of.
In late 2023, he launched Big Taco in Casselberry, Florida. This time, he brought his sons, Jake and Gavin, into the business. It’s a full-circle moment. The vibe is "Old Las Vegas" meets classic Tex-Mex.
The philosophy at Big Taco is a direct reaction to what happened at Tijuana Flats. Brian’s new mantra? "A taco is just a taco." No over-engineering. No corporate fluff. Just quality ingredients and a service-first attitude.
It’s interesting to watch a founder basically compete with the ghost of his own legacy. While Tijuana Flats tries to find its way out of the bankruptcy shadow, Big Taco is trying to capture that 1995 magic all over again.
Actionable Takeaways for Business Owners
If you're an entrepreneur or a fan of the brand, there are some pretty heavy lessons here.
- Culture is hard to scale: Once the person who "lives and breathes" the brand leaves, the culture starts to leak. If you're selling a business, ensure the "intangibles" are documented or protected.
- Don't over-engineer the product: People liked Tijuana Flats because it was simple and fun. When they tried to get "fancy" or "corporate" with the menu in 2021, the customers walked.
- Watch the Debt: Private equity often brings debt. In a high-inflation environment, that debt becomes a noose.
- Legacy matters: Brian’s name is still synonymous with the brand’s "golden age." If you're taking over a founder-led company, respect the original fan base before trying to "evolve."
The story of Brian Wheeler Tijuana Flats is a reminder that in the restaurant world, you're only as good as the last burrito you rolled. Brian has moved on to building something new with his kids, and the Flats is fighting to survive. Whether the new owners can actually "reinvigorate" the brand remains to be seen, but the original spirit of 1995 is now living over at Big Taco.