It was late. August 6, 2008, to be exact. While most of the NFL world was settling into the rhythm of training camp, the New York Jets pulled off a move that felt like a fever dream. They traded for Brett Favre.
The Gunslinger. The Iron Man. The guy who was the Green Bay Packers for sixteen years.
Suddenly, he was wearing hunter green and white. Honestly, if you weren't around for it, it’s hard to describe how much this broke the sports world's brain. The Jets didn't just get a quarterback; they got a circus, a savior, and a massive question mark all wrapped into one 38-year-old package.
The Trade That Shook the League
The divorce between Favre and the Packers was ugly. Like, "don't look at me in the hallway" ugly. Green Bay was ready for the Aaron Rodgers era, but Favre wasn't ready for the rocking chair.
The Packers actually tried to pay him $20 million just to stay retired. Seriously. They wanted him away from the Minnesota Vikings so badly they tried to bribe him into a marketing deal. When that failed, they shipped him to the AFC. The Jets gave up a conditional fourth-round pick. It was a bargain, at least on paper.
There was even a "poison pill" in the deal. If the Jets traded Favre to a divisional rival of the Packers (cough, Minnesota, cough), they’d have to cough up three first-round draft picks. Green Bay was playing chess.
👉 See also: Sammy Sosa Before and After Steroids: What Really Happened
When Brett Favre on Jets Actually Worked
People remember the end of the 2008 season as a disaster. And yeah, it was. But for the first eleven games? Brett Favre on Jets was basically magic.
The team started 8-3. They weren't just winning; they were dominant. In Week 4, Favre tied Joe Namath’s franchise record by tossing six touchdowns against the Arizona Cardinals. Six! The stadium was vibrating.
Then came Week 12. The Jets traveled to Tennessee to take on an undefeated Titans team. The Titans were 10-0. The Jets walked into their house and absolutely dismantled them 34-13. At that moment, the Jets weren't just playoff contenders. They were legitimate Super Bowl favorites.
Favre was completing over 70% of his passes. He was the MVP frontrunner. Fans were buying jerseys faster than the pro shop could stock them. It felt like the "Same Old Jets" curse had finally been lifted by a guy from Mississippi who loved Wrangler jeans.
The Bicep Tear That Ruined Everything
Then, the wheels came off. Or more accurately, the tendon came off.
✨ Don't miss: Saint Benedict's Prep Soccer: Why the Gray Bees Keep Winning Everything
During that 11th game or shortly after, Favre partially tore his biceps tendon in his right arm. This is the part of the story that gets glossed over by people who just look at the final stats. His rocket launcher of an arm suddenly turned into a noodle.
He couldn't zip the ball anymore. He couldn't hit the deep outs. But because he was Brett Favre, and because he had that legendary consecutive starts streak to protect, he kept playing.
The drop-off was staggering:
- First 11 Games: 20 TDs, 13 INTs, 70% completion.
- Last 5 Games: 2 TDs, 9 INTs, 56% completion.
The Jets went 1-4 down the stretch. They missed the playoffs entirely after losing to Chad Pennington—the guy they cut to make room for Favre—and the Miami Dolphins in the season finale. It was the most "Jets" ending possible.
The Controversy No One Saw Coming
It wasn't just the on-field collapse that made this year weird. This was also the season where the Jenn Sterger situation began. Sterger, a gameday host for the Jets, was reportedly receiving unsolicited and inappropriate messages and photos from Favre.
🔗 Read more: Ryan Suter: What Most People Get Wrong About the NHL's Ultimate Survivor
The league eventually fined him $50,000, though not for the messages themselves, but for a lack of cooperation with the investigation. It was a messy, dark cloud over a season that started with so much hope. For many fans, this remains the moment the Favre "hero" image started to crack for good.
Why It Still Matters
Looking back, the Favre experiment was a bridge. It ended the Eric Mangini era and led directly to Rex Ryan and the Mark Sanchez "Ground and Pound" years.
If Favre doesn't get hurt, do the 2008 Jets win a ring? Maybe. They were stacked. Thomas Jones was rushing for 1,300 yards. Kris Jenkins was a mountain in the middle of the defense. Darrelle Revis was becoming Revis Island.
But that's the thing about the Brett Favre on Jets era. It was a high-stakes gamble that almost paid off, only to leave everyone with a massive hangover.
What You Should Take Away
If you're looking at this through a historical lens, remember two things:
- Context is everything. Don't just look at his 22 interceptions and think he was washed. He was elite until his arm literally broke.
- Health over Streaks. If the Jets had benched Favre for Kellen Clemens for two weeks to let that arm heal, the AFC playoffs might have looked very different in 2008.
The lesson here? Sometimes the biggest name isn't the best fit if they aren't willing to admit when they're hurt. The Jets learned that the hard way, and it's a mistake we see teams still making today.
Next time you see a veteran QB "powering through" a visible injury, think back to December 2008 in the Meadowlands. It rarely ends with a trophy.