It sounds like something straight out of a Victorian novel or a period drama set in the 1700s. You picture a woman in a long dress, hired by a wealthy family because the mother couldn't—or didn't want to—nurse her own child. But honestly? Breastfeeding wet nursing never actually went away. It just went underground.
In a world of high-tech breast pumps and precision-engineered formula, the idea of another person nursing your baby feels, well, a bit radical to some. To others, it’s just community. Life happens. Sometimes a mother’s milk doesn’t come in. Sometimes she’s on medication that isn't safe for the baby. Sometimes, tragically, a mother isn't there at all.
What’s wild is how much we’ve forgotten about how humans used to survive. Before the mid-20th century, if a mother couldn't breastfeed, a wet nurse was the difference between life and death. There was no backup. No Plan B on the grocery store shelf. Today, while we have those backups, the interest in biological "white gold" has sparked a massive resurgence in cross-nursing and formal wet nursing arrangements.
The Reality of Breastfeeding Wet Nursing Today
It isn't just for the elite anymore. Not even close. Modern wet nursing usually falls into two buckets: the informal "cross-nursing" between friends or sisters, and the more organized (and sometimes paid) arrangements. You’ve probably heard of "milk sharing," where parents swap frozen bags of expressed milk. That’s huge right now. But wet nursing is the "live" version of that. It’s direct.
Why do people do it?
Often, it’s about the antibodies. You see, when a baby nurses directly at the breast, there’s a biological feedback loop. The baby’s saliva actually enters the nipple, and the lactating body analyzes it for pathogens, then adjusts the milk's immunological profile in real-time. You don't get that with a bottle of thawed milk. It's fascinatingly complex.
But it's not all sunshine and bonding. There are real risks. If you’re looking into this, you have to talk about blood-borne pathogens. HIV, HTLV, and Hepatitis can be transmitted through breast milk. In a clinical setting, like a milk bank, they pasteurize the milk. In a wet nursing situation, you’re relying on trust and medical screening.
💡 You might also like: How to take out IUD: What your doctor might not tell you about the process
Dr. Sharon Unger, a neonatologist and co-director of the Rogers Hixon Ontario Human Milk Bank, has often pointed out that while donor milk is the "gold standard" for preterm infants in hospitals, the informal world of sharing milk—and by extension, wet nursing—exists in a gray area of regulation.
The Logistics of Finding a Wet Nurse
You don't just put an ad on Craigslist. Usually.
Most people find their way into this through communities like Human Milk 4 Human Babies or Eats on Feets. These are global networks that facilitate milk sharing based on the principle of informed consent. They don't allow the sale of milk, focusing instead on community support.
When a family seeks a wet nurse, the "interview" process is intense. You aren't just looking for someone with a good supply. You’re looking for a specific lifestyle. Is she a smoker? Does she drink? What’s her diet like? Most importantly, is she willing to undergo blood tests?
The Screening Must-Haves
- Current screening for HIV 1 and 2.
- Hepatitis B and C checks.
- Syphilis (RPR) testing.
- HTLV I and II.
- Confirmation of no drug use, including heavy caffeine or herbal supplements that might affect a sensitive newborn.
It's a lot. It’s basically like dating, but the stakes are your infant’s entire immune system.
Cultural Perspectives and the "Ick" Factor
Let's be real. In Western culture, we’ve hyper-sexualized breasts to the point where the idea of a "stranger" nursing a baby makes people squirm. It’s a weird hang-up. In many Islamic cultures, the concept of Radwa (milk kinship) is deeply ingrained in the law and social fabric. If two children are nursed by the same woman, they become "milk siblings." They have specific familial rights and are even prohibited from marrying one another later in life.
📖 Related: How Much Sugar Are in Apples: What Most People Get Wrong
It’s a beautiful way of looking at it—milk as a literal builder of family ties.
Contrast that with the American perspective where, for decades, formula was marketed as the "scientific" and "cleaner" way to feed. We’re still deconstructing that bias. The shift back toward breastfeeding wet nursing is, in many ways, a rebellion against the commercialization of the first few months of life.
Is It Safe? The Medical Debate
Health organizations are pretty divided here. The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) and the FDA generally advise against informal milk sharing and wet nursing. Their stance is simple: the risk of infection or exposure to medications/contaminants is too high when the milk isn't screened and pasteurized in a lab.
But parents counter this with the "precious resource" argument.
They argue that if a mother is healthy and the screening is transparent, the benefits of fresh, raw human milk outweigh the theoretical risks. This is especially true for babies with severe allergies to cow’s milk protein or those with "failure to thrive" diagnoses.
The Emotional Complexity of the Arrangement
It’s not just a biological transaction. There’s a massive psychological component.
👉 See also: No Alcohol 6 Weeks: The Brutally Honest Truth About What Actually Changes
Imagine you’re a mother who desperately wants to nurse but can't. Watching another woman hold your child to her breast can trigger an avalanche of emotions—grief, inadequacy, but also profound gratitude. It requires a high level of emotional intelligence from both parties.
The wet nurse, too, has a lot to manage. She’s giving of her own body. Prolactin, the hormone responsible for milk production, is also the "mothering hormone." It creates a bond. When the arrangement ends, there can be a real sense of loss.
Practical Steps for Interested Families
If you're considering breastfeeding wet nursing, you can't just wing it. This is one of those times where being "too careful" isn't a thing.
- Get a full medical panel. Don't just take someone's word for it. Ask for recent blood work results. If they're a true professional or a dedicated community member, they won't be offended. They'll expect it.
- Discuss the "What-Ifs." What happens if the wet nurse gets sick? What if the baby starts biting? What if the supply dips? Have these awkward conversations before the baby is latched.
- Monitor the baby's growth. Even with a wet nurse, you need to work with your pediatrician. Track weight gain and wet diapers. Just because it's "natural" doesn't mean it's automatically working perfectly for your specific child.
- Legal Protections. If this is a paid arrangement, get it in writing. It sounds cold, but it protects everyone—the nurse, the parents, and the baby.
The Cost of Human Milk
In some circles, wet nursing is a high-paying job. We’re talking six figures for high-profile clients in cities like New York or London. But for the average person, it’s usually an act of altruism or a modest hourly rate.
The ethics of paying for milk are murky. Critics argue it exploits low-income women. Supporters argue that women should be compensated for the immense physical toll and time commitment of lactating for two. It's a debate that isn't going to be settled anytime soon.
What matters is the health of the infant. Whether the milk comes from a biological mother, a donated bottle, or a wet nurse, the goal is the same: a thriving child.
We’ve spent so long trying to outsource motherhood to machines and powders. Maybe the return of the wet nurse is just us admitting that sometimes, the old ways had a logic that science is only just beginning to fully map out. It’s not for everyone. It’s complex, it’s messy, and it’s deeply personal. But for those who choose it, it’s a life-changing solution.
Actionable Insights for Moving Forward
- Research local laws: Some jurisdictions have specific regulations regarding the sale of human milk. Know where you stand legally.
- Consult a Lactation Consultant (IBCLC): Even if you aren't the one nursing, a consultant can help manage the transition and ensure the baby's latch with the wet nurse is productive.
- Check "Milk Sharing" groups on social media: Look for groups with strict moderation and "About" sections that prioritize safety and testing over quick fixes.
- Prioritize transparency: If a potential wet nurse is hesitant to share medical records or lifestyle details, walk away immediately. Trust is the foundation of this practice.