If you’ve been anywhere near TikTok or reality TV news lately, you’ve probably seen the name Carly popping up alongside a lot of heated debate. For those who grew up watching 16 and Pregnant and Teen Mom, the names Brandon and Teresa are synonymous with a very specific, very emotional chapter of TV history. They are the couple who adopted Carly, the first biological child of Catelynn Lowell and Tyler Baltierra, back in 2009.
Fast forward to 2026, and what started as a "textbook" example of open adoption has turned into a complicated, public standoff. It’s messy. It’s heartbreaking. And honestly, it’s a massive lesson in the boundaries of privacy in the age of social media.
The Reality of the Block
In late 2024 and throughout 2025, the relationship between the biological parents (Catelynn and Tyler) and the adoptive parents (Brandon and Teresa Davis) effectively collapsed. Catelynn went public with the news that she had been blocked.
Basically, the "open" part of the adoption—which once included yearly visits and text updates—has slammed shut.
📖 Related: Lindsay Lohan Leak: What Really Happened with the List and the Scams
Why now? It wasn't one single event. It was a slow burn of boundary-crossing that finally hit a wall. For years, Brandon and Teresa have asked for one thing: privacy. They didn't sign up to be reality stars. They signed up to be parents. But when your child's biological parents have millions of followers and a platform on MTV, "private" is a hard thing to maintain.
The Friction Points That Changed Everything
- The Social Media Factor: Tyler and Catelynn often shared photos of Carly, or even just details about her life, against the Davises' wishes. Even sharing a photo of the back of her head became a point of contention.
- The "Inappropriate" Gifts: In early 2025, reports surfaced that Brandon and Teresa reached out via their adoption coordinator, Dawn Baker, to label recent gifts from the Baltierras as "excessive" and "inappropriate." We're talking about things like blankets with photos of Carly’s biological siblings labeled as "sisters."
- The YouTube/TikTok Rants: Whenever a visit was denied, the Baltierras took to social media to vent. To fans, it looked like transparency. To Brandon and Teresa, it likely looked like a public smear campaign.
What Most People Get Wrong About the "Contract"
There’s a huge misconception that an open adoption is a legally binding visitation schedule like a divorce decree. In most states, including where this adoption took place, open adoption agreements are not legally enforceable. Brandon and Teresa were never legally required to provide yearly visits until Carly was 18. They did it because they wanted to. They actually extended the "guaranteed" contact period far beyond the initial five-year window discussed at the start.
The reality is that as Carly became a teenager (she turned 16 in 2025), her own voice started to matter more. There are strong indications from sources close to the situation that the "block" wasn't just a parental decision—it was about protecting a teenager who didn't want her private life used as a storyline for a TV show she never asked to be on.
👉 See also: Kaley Cuoco Tit Size: What Most People Get Wrong About Her Transformation
The Singing Video Controversy
One of the weirdest moments in this saga happened recently involving a video of Carly singing. Brandon and Teresa reportedly offered to let Catelynn and Tyler watch a video of Carly performing, but with a catch: they had to watch it in a controlled environment (like with a mediator or Dr. Drew) and couldn't have a digital copy.
The Baltierras refused. They wanted the link. They wanted the "access."
This highlight's the fundamental gap between the two families. One side sees a digital link as a right to their biological daughter’s milestones. The other side sees a digital link as a liability—something that could be leaked, shared, or posted on TikTok within minutes.
✨ Don't miss: Dale Mercer Net Worth: Why the RHONY Star is Richer Than You Think
Why This Matters Beyond Reality TV
The story of Brandon, Teresa, and Carly is a cautionary tale for the digital age. It’s about the "Right to be Forgotten." Carly is a young woman now. She has a life, a school, and friends who likely have no idea she was the subject of a national adoption debate before she could even walk.
When Catelynn and Tyler post about being "blocked," they aren't just talking to their fans. They are creating a digital footprint that Carly will eventually have to navigate.
Actionable Insights for Navigating Adoption Conversations
If you're following this story or dealing with similar family dynamics, here are a few things to keep in mind:
- Prioritize the Adoptee's Agency: As children grow into teens, the "openness" of an adoption often shifts to follow the child's comfort level, not the adults' desires.
- Privacy is a Form of Care: In a world of oversharing, keeping a child off social media is often the most protective thing a parent (adoptive or biological) can do.
- Understand the Legal Reality: If you are entering an adoption, know that "open" usually relies on trust and relationship-building, not a court order. Once that trust is broken, the door often closes.
The saga of Brandon, Teresa, and Carly isn't over, but it has definitely moved into a new, quieter phase. For Carly’s sake, that quiet might be exactly what she needs.
Next Steps:
If you want to understand more about the legalities of these types of agreements, you should look into the specific Open Adoption Statutes by state, as they vary wildly between places like Michigan and North Carolina. You can also research the Adoptee Rights Movement, which focuses on the perspective of the children involved rather than the parents.