Honestly, if you were sitting in Beaver Stadium on that sweltering Saturday in September 2024, you felt it. That collective pit in the stomach of 103,861 fans. It wasn't supposed to be like that. Penn State was a 34-point favorite. The Bowling Green Falcons were supposed to be a "tune-up" game, a chance to get the second string some reps before the real Big Ten grind started.
Instead? We got a dogfight.
Bowling Green didn't just show up; they walked into one of the most hostile environments in college sports and absolutely punched the Nittany Lions in the mouth. When the halftime whistle blew and the score showed 24-20 in favor of the visitors, the boos from the student section were loud. Real loud. It was a wake-up call that people still talk about when discussing the "ceiling" of James Franklin's program.
The Streak That Died in the First Quarter
For years, Penn State’s defense has been a brick wall early in games. Heading into the Bowling Green Penn State matchup, the Nittany Lions held the nation’s longest streak of not allowing a touchdown on an opponent's opening drive—28 straight games.
Connor Bazelak didn't care.
✨ Don't miss: When Did Green Bay Win Super Bowl History: What Most People Get Wrong
The Bowling Green quarterback, a veteran who had seen plenty of high-level ball at Indiana and Missouri, looked like an All-American. He carved up the secondary, capped off by a 6-yard touchdown pass to Harold Fannin Jr. Just like that, the streak was dead.
It wasn't a fluke, either. Fannin Jr. was a nightmare for the Penn State linebackers all day. He ended up with 11 catches for 137 yards. If you’re a scout, you probably have his name circled in red ink by now. The guy was catching everything Bazelak threw his way, often dragging defenders for an extra three or four yards after contact.
Why the Score Was Closer Than the Stats
You'll hear people say, "Oh, Penn State won, they had 438 total yards." True. But that's a bit of a "box score lie."
The reality is that Bowling Green’s offensive line was surprisingly stout. Even without their star running back Terion Stewart, who was out with an injury, the Falcons' run game was effective enough to keep Penn State's pass rush honest. Jamal Johnson gashed the Lions for a 41-yard touchdown run in the second quarter that left the stadium in a stunned silence.
Penn State looked rusty. Or maybe they were looking ahead. Seven penalties for 71 yards is a lot for a James Franklin-coached team, especially early in the season. It kept Falcons drives alive and stalled out the Nittany Lions' rhythm.
Turning the Tide: The Second Half Surge
Eventually, the depth and raw talent of the Nittany Lions took over. You can only hold back a team like Penn State for so long before the dam breaks.
- Tyler Warren was the MVP of the day. He set a school record for receiving yards by a tight end with 146 yards. Every time Drew Allar needed a "security blanket," Warren was there.
- Nicholas Singleton finally broke loose. His 41-yard touchdown run in the fourth quarter was the dagger that finally put the Falcons away. He finished with 119 yards on the ground.
- The Defense actually woke up. After giving up 24 points in the first half, Tom Allen’s unit allowed only 3 points in the second half. They forced two crucial interceptions that flipped the momentum when the Falcons were threatening to reclaim the lead.
What This Game Taught Us About Penn State
It showed that the Nittany Lions' defense, while elite, can be vulnerable to veteran quarterbacks and creative play-calling. Scot Loeffler, the Bowling Green head coach, had a brilliant game plan. He used a "throw-rich" strategy to attack the secondary before the pass rush could get home.
✨ Don't miss: Did He Make The Putt Com: Why Golfers Are Obsessed With This Tracking Tool
It also proved that Drew Allar has the poise to stay cool when things go south. Some Penn State QBs of the past might have panicked under the boos. Allar just kept feeding Warren and Singleton.
Actionable Takeaways for Fans and Bettors
If you're following matchups like this in the future, keep these nuances in mind:
- Don't ignore the MAC "Giant Killers": Teams like Bowling Green, who have beaten Power Five schools like Minnesota and Georgia Tech in recent years, aren't afraid of the big stage.
- The "Home Opener" Hangover: Heavy favorites often struggle with focus in their first home game after a big road win (like Penn State's win over West Virginia the week prior).
- Watch the Tight End Matchups: If an underdog has a high-volume tight end like Harold Fannin Jr., it can neutralize a superior pass rush by providing quick-out options for the QB.
The 34-27 final score might look like a comfortable enough win on paper years from now, but for those who were there, the Bowling Green Penn State game was a reminder that in college football, nobody is safe. You have to earn it every single Saturday.