What just happened? Seriously. If you’ve been looking at the bowl football game scores over the last few weeks, you probably feel like you’ve been watching a fever dream. We all thought we understood how the 12-team playoff would work. We thought the big brands would dominate. Instead, we got Indiana steamrolling Alabama in the Rose Bowl and Miami—yes, the number 10 seed—carving a path to the National Championship.
The scores weren't just surprising. They were occasionally absurd.
Remember that Indiana versus Oregon semifinal? 56–22. That’s not a typo. It was the Chick-fil-A Peach Bowl, a game that was supposed to be a heavyweight bout between two of the best teams in the country. Instead, Indiana looked like they were playing on a different planet.
The Playoff Scores That Broke the Bracket
The expanded playoff has changed the math. It used to be that a single loss in November killed your season. Now, teams like Miami can stumble during the regular season, get in as a double-digit seed, and then go on a tear.
Look at Miami’s road. It started with a gritty 10–3 win over Texas A&M. Then they went to Arlington and dumped the defending champs, Ohio State, 24–14 in the Cotton Bowl. They finished that gauntlet by edging out Ole Miss 31–27 in the Fiesta Bowl. Those bowl football game scores tell a story of a team that learned how to win ugly before they learned how to win big.
Meanwhile, the "Bye Week Curse" became a very real thing this year.
👉 See also: Ohio State Football All White Uniforms: Why the Icy Look Always Sparks a Debate
- Ohio State (No. 2 seed) lost to Miami 14–24.
- Georgia (No. 3 seed) lost to Ole Miss 34–39.
- Texas Tech (No. 4 seed) got shut out by Oregon 0–23.
- Indiana was the only top-four seed to survive their quarterfinal matchup.
Basically, if you had a week off, you probably lost. It’s a wild trend that has analysts like Kirk Herbstreit wondering if the "rest" is actually just "rust."
Non-Playoff Games: Where the Real Weirdness Lives
If you only watched the CFP, you missed the absolute madness of the smaller bowls. The Military Bowl was probably the biggest shocker of the entire month. Pitt went in as nearly two-touchdown favorites against East Carolina. Most people expected a blowout.
The final? 23–17, East Carolina.
Pitt head coach Pat Narduzzi is taking a lot of heat for that one. It's the kind of result that makes you realize bowl season still has that "anything can happen" energy, even in the playoff era. Then you had the Pop-Tarts Bowl. It wasn't just about the edible mascot—though that was something else—it was the game itself. BYU scored 15 unanswered points in the fourth quarter to stun Georgia Tech 25–21.
A Quick Look at the Scores That Mattered
Honestly, keeping track of these is a full-time job. Here are the ones that actually shifted the narrative this season:
✨ Don't miss: Who Won the Golf Tournament This Weekend: Richard T. Lee and the 2026 Season Kickoff
The Big Ten Dominance
Indiana 38, Alabama 3 (Rose Bowl Quarterfinal). Nobody saw a 35-point gap coming here. It felt like a changing of the guard. Then, the Hoosiers followed it up by hunging 56 on Oregon. Curt Cignetti has turned Bloomington into a football factory.
The SEC’s Rough Month
It’s been a tough year for the "It Just Means More" crowd. Aside from Texas beating Michigan 41–27 in the Citrus Bowl, the SEC struggled. Tennessee lost a heartbreaker to Illinois 28–30 in the Music City Bowl. Missouri fell to Virginia 7–13 in the Gator Bowl. When the dust settled, the SEC’s non-playoff bowl record was a dismal 4–10.
The ACC's Revenge
People spent all year calling the ACC "weak." Then the conference went 8–4 in the postseason. Duke beat Arizona State 42–39 in a Sun Bowl shootout. Wake Forest put up 43 on Mississippi State. And obviously, Miami is playing for all the marbles.
Why the Scores Look So Different Now
You’ve probably noticed the scores aren't as consistent as they used to be. One game is a 10–3 defensive struggle, and the next is a 57–20 track meet (shoutout to UTSA for that clinic in the First Responder Bowl).
The transfer portal and opt-outs are the main culprits here.
In the "lower tier" bowls, you might see a team playing without their starting QB or half their defensive line. That’s how you get a result like Army 41, UConn 16 in the Fenway Bowl. Army was focused; UConn looked like they were already thinking about next season.
🔗 Read more: The Truth About the Memphis Grizzlies Record 2025: Why the Standings Don't Tell the Whole Story
But in the playoff games, the scores are high because the talent is condensed. Indiana’s Fernando Mendoza has been surgical. He’s thrown eight touchdowns in two playoff games. When you have elite QBs who aren't opting out because they're playing for a ring, the scoreboard is going to get a workout.
What This Means for You
If you're looking at these bowl football game scores to try and figure out next year’s favorites, take it with a grain of salt. The "rest vs. rust" debate is going to dominate the offseason. We’ve seen that momentum from the first round of the playoff is a massive advantage.
Here is what you should actually take away from this season:
- The Bye is a Trap: Until someone proves they can handle the layoff, bet on the team that played the week before.
- The Big Ten is the New Standard: With a 10–5 record this postseason, they are currently the conference to beat.
- Don't Ignore the "Small" Games: Scores like North Texas 49, San Diego State 47 (New Mexico Bowl) remind us that some of the best football happens when nobody is watching.
Next steps? Keep an eye on the injury reports and portal entries before next year's "Early National Championship" odds drop. The rosters that finished this bowl season won't look anything like the ones that start in August. If you're chasing the best value, look at the teams that showed defensive depth in those high-scoring losses; they're the ones most likely to bounce back.
The National Championship between Indiana and Miami at Hard Rock Stadium is the final piece of the puzzle. Whatever that score ends up being, it’ll be the perfect cap to the most unpredictable bowl season we've ever seen.